Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · Renewal, refinancing and rates

Case study: a blend and extend that was worth taking, and one that was not

An illustrative composite, not a real client. Two households, the same offer from the same kind of lender, opposite answers. What separated them was not the pricing, it was the charge registered on title.


All broker questions

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

What were they actually asking for?

Both households asked the same question: should they take the lender’s blend and extend offer, or wait for maturity and shop. The arithmetic was similar for both. The answer was not.

The illustrative shape: two Ontario homes around $560,000 with roughly 20% equity, both eight months from maturity, both offered a blend and extend. One had a standard charge registered on title. The other had a collateral charge.

The citable fact: a blend and extend is a different decision depending on what is registered against your home, because the charge decides what leaving costs.

What is a blend and extend?

The lender combines your existing rate with a current one for a new, longer term, and you avoid a prepayment charge because you are not breaking anything. It is a renewal brought forward rather than a refinance.

The reason it is offered is retention. That is not a criticism, it is the thing to hold in mind: the offer exists because the lender would rather keep you than compete for you at maturity.

The citable fact: a blend and extend is a retention product, which means the comparison that matters is against what you could get elsewhere, not against your current payment.

What does the law actually give you at renewal?

Time, and not much of it. A federally regulated lender must send a renewal statement at least 21 days before the end of the term. If you do nothing, renewal of the term may be automatic, and the lender has to disclose that in the statement.

Twenty one days is enough to sign an offer and not enough to arrange a switch to another lender. That asymmetry is the whole reason a renewal conversation should start months out, and the reason an early offer feels generous when it is mostly convenient.

The citable fact: the statutory floor is a renewal statement at least 21 days before maturity, which is enough time to accept an offer and not enough to arrange an alternative.

Why did the charge decide it?

Because it sets the cost of the alternative. A lender may register a collateral charge for more than the amount of the mortgage, which is what allows further borrowing later without a new registration.

The trade is on the way out. Switching a collateral charge to a new lender may require paying to discharge the existing charge and register the new one, and that cost does not exist on a straight switch of a standard charge, where the new lender often handles the paperwork.

There is no published percentage for how far above the mortgage a collateral charge is registered. Figures like 100% to 125% circulate widely and are not a published fact, so the only reliable answer is on your own title and your own payout statement.

What changes between the two households, on confirmed figures only
ItemStandard chargeCollateral charge
Cost of accepting the blendNone at signingNone at signing
Cost of leaving at maturityDischarge fee of $300 to $500 where chargedDischarge and re-registration, plus legal work
Legal work on a switchOften handled by the new lenderCommonly the borrower’s cost
Who the offer competes againstEvery other lenderEvery other lender, minus the exit cost

The citable fact: a collateral charge does not make a blend and extend a bad deal; it raises the price of the alternative, which is a different thing and has to be measured rather than assumed.

Which did each choose, and why?

The household with the standard charge declined and shopped at maturity. Their exit cost was a discharge fee at most, so the offer had to beat the open market on its merits and it did not.

The household with the collateral charge accepted. Once the discharge, re-registration and legal work were added to the cost of moving, the gap the market would have had to beat was wide enough that the offer was the better of the two realistic outcomes.

Neither decision was about the pricing in isolation. Both were about what the alternative actually cost them.

What should you do eight months out?

Three things, in order. Find out which charge is registered against your home. Get your payout statement, which carries the exact discharge figure rather than a range. Then compare, with the exit cost included on the right hand side.

Doing that at eight months leaves room to act. Doing it when the renewal statement arrives leaves twenty one days.

How illustrative is “illustrative”?

The values, the equity and the timing were constructed, and the two households are a device for showing one variable. The 21 day renewal statement rule, the collateral charge mechanics, the absence of a published registration percentage and the discharge fee range are published rules and confirmed figures.

No rate appears anywhere on this page, which on a blend and extend page is a deliberate omission rather than an oversight: the entire decision is usually framed as a rate comparison and the costs are what actually move it. Current rates are at pekoe.ca/rates.

Every figure on this page, and where it comes from

Published rules and confirmed ranges used above
FigureValueSource
Renewal statement noticeAt least 21 days before the end of the termFCAC, Renewing your mortgage
Automatic renewalMay apply if you do nothing, and must be disclosed in the statementFCAC, Renewing your mortgage
Collateral chargeMay be registered above the mortgage amount. No published percentage existsFCAC, Borrowing against home equity
Switching a collateral chargeMay require discharging the existing charge and registering a new oneFCAC, Borrowing against home equity
Lender discharge fee$300 to $500Pekoe deal flow, confirmed 2026-09-29
Who to ask

Who do you need, and when?

Short answer

Your existing lender for the charge type and the payout figure, your broker for what the market would actually offer. In that order.

  • Your existing lender, for two facts. Which charge is registered against your home, and the exact payout figure including any discharge fee.
  • Your broker, for the comparison with the exit cost in it. An offer measured against your current payment is not a comparison.
  • A lawyer, only if you are moving a collateral charge. That is where the discharge and re-registration work lives.

Bring your maturity date, your balance, your remaining amortisation and the renewal offer itself. The offer letter usually states less than people assume.

F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

Is this a real client?

No. Two illustrative composites and no client information appears on either. The renewal rule, the collateral charge mechanics and the discharge fee range are real; the values and the timing were constructed.

What is a blend and extend?

Your lender combines your existing rate with a current one for a new, longer term. You avoid a prepayment charge because nothing is being broken, and it is a renewal brought forward rather than a refinance.

When does my lender have to tell me about renewal?

A federally regulated lender must send a renewal statement at least 21 days before the end of the term, and must disclose in it whether the term renews automatically if you do nothing.

Is 21 days enough to switch lenders?

Generally no. It is enough to accept the offer in front of you. Arranging an alternative takes longer, which is why a renewal should be looked at months before maturity.

What is a collateral charge?

A charge a lender may register for more than the amount of your mortgage, which allows further borrowing later without a new registration. The trade is that switching to another lender may require discharging it and registering a new charge.

How much higher is a collateral charge registered?

There is no published percentage. Figures like 100% to 125% circulate widely and are not a published fact. Your own title and payout statement are the only reliable source.

Does a collateral charge make a blend and extend a good deal?

It does not make it good or bad. It raises what the alternative costs, which narrows the gap the market has to beat. That has to be measured on your file rather than assumed.

What does it cost to leave at maturity?

On a standard charge, a discharge fee of $300 to $500 where one is charged, and often legal work handled by the new lender. On a collateral charge, discharge and re-registration plus legal work that is commonly yours. Your payout statement carries the exact figure.

Find out what is registered on your title before you decide

A blend and extend is a product decision on a standard charge and a lock-in on a collateral one. Establish which you have before you compare anything.


All broker questions

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Brokerage Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed by RECA. Principal broker Daniel Johanis, Mortgage Broker Licence No. M16000320, Member of Mortgage Professionals Canada (MPC), formerly CAAMP. The stress test and the tiered minimum down payment are the federal rules and are stated as such. This page is general information, not legal advice, and A collateral charge, and what it costs to leave one, is a question for your lawyer and your payout statement rather than for a brochure. No rate, fee, penalty or lender name appears on this page. We are a mortgage brokerage and not a law firm.