Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · Investors

Do you owe tax when you turn your home into a rental?

Possibly, at the moment you change the use rather than when you sell. CRA treats a complete conversion to income-producing use as a deemed disposition at fair market value. An election can defer it, but that election carries a four-year cap and a condition most people break by accident.


All broker questions

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

The event

What is a deemed disposition on a change of use?

Short answer

Where a taxpayer has completely converted a principal residence to an income-producing use, paragraph 45(1)(a) deems them to have disposed of the property, both land and building, at fair market value. No sale happens and no money changes hands, but a disposition is recorded.

That is the point most owners miss. They expect the tax question to arrive when they eventually sell, and it arrives when the tenant moves in.

The practical effect is that any gain accrued while you lived there is measured at that moment, which is also why the principal residence exemption matters so much on the first half of the timeline.

The citable fact: where a principal residence is completely converted to an income-producing use, paragraph 45(1)(a) deems a disposition of both land and building at fair market value.

The deferral

Can the deemed disposition be deferred?

Short answer

Yes, by electing under subsection 45(2) to be deemed not to have made the change in use. The election is made by a letter to that effect, signed by the taxpayer and filed with the income tax return for the year in which the change of use occurred.

It is a letter rather than a prescribed form, which is part of why it is so often missed. There is no box on the return prompting you to make it.

It also has to be filed with the return for the year of the change, so it is a decision taken at the time rather than one that can be made later when the consequences become apparent.

The citable fact: the subsection 45(2) election is made by a signed letter filed with the income tax return for the year in which the change of use occurred.

The cap

How long does the election protect you?

Short answer

Up to four tax years. A property can qualify as a taxpayer’s principal residence for up to four tax years during which a subsection 45(2) election remains in force. It is not open-ended, which is one of the most misunderstood parts of this.

Section 54.1 can remove the four-year limit where its conditions are met, including a relocation for employment of at least 40 kilometres and a resumption of habitation afterwards.

That is a narrow door designed for people moved by an employer, not a general extension for anyone who decides to keep renting the house out.

What the election does and does not do
QuestionAnswer
Defers the deemed dispositionYes, while in force
Years it can coverUp to four tax years
Can the four years be extendedOnly where section 54.1 conditions are met
Made byA signed letter with that year’s return
Survives a CCA claimNo

The citable fact: a property can qualify as a principal residence for up to four tax years during which a subsection 45(2) election remains in force.

The trap

What silently cancels the election?

Short answer

Claiming capital cost allowance. If CCA is claimed on the property, the election is considered to be rescinded on the first day of the year in which that claim is made. CRA states plainly that for years covered by a 45(2) election, CCA should not be claimed.

This is where accidents happen, because claiming depreciation on a rental is ordinary practice and an accountant preparing the rental schedule may not know an election is in force.

The rescission is also retroactive to the first day of that year rather than running from the date of the claim, so a single year’s CCA undoes the protection for the whole of it.

The citable fact: if capital cost allowance is claimed on the property, the subsection 45(2) election is considered rescinded on the first day of the year in which the claim is made.

Part of the house

What if you only rent out part of it?

Short answer

A partial conversion triggers a deemed disposition of the converted portion under paragraph 45(1)(c), usually calculated on the basis of the area involved. But CRA does not apply it where three conditions all hold.

Those three are that the income-producing use is ancillary to the main residential use, that there is no structural change to the property, and that no capital cost allowance is claimed.

That is the dividing line between renting a basement room and converting a house into a duplex. Put in a separate entrance and a second kitchen and the structural condition is in play.

The three conditions that keep a partial rental out of 45(1)(c)
ConditionWhat breaks it
Income use is ancillary to the main residential useThe rented share becomes the larger or primary use
No structural change to the propertyA separate entrance, a second kitchen, a legal suite conversion
No capital cost allowance claimedAny CCA claim on the building or its components

The citable fact: CRA does not apply a deemed disposition on a partial conversion where the income-producing use is ancillary, there is no structural change, and no capital cost allowance is claimed.

Reporting

Do you have to report it even if no tax is owing?

Short answer

Yes. Since 2016 CRA will only allow the principal residence exemption if you report the disposition and designation on your income tax return, using Form T2091(IND). Failing to report is a separate problem from owing tax.

A late designation carries a penalty, calculated as the lesser of $8,000 or $100 for each complete month from the original due date to the date the request is made.

Because the deemed disposition is invisible in a bank statement, this is a filing obligation that arrives without a prompt, which is exactly the kind that gets missed for years.

The citable fact: since 2016 the principal residence exemption is only allowed where the disposition and designation are reported on the return, on Form T2091(IND).

Going back

What about moving back in later?

Short answer

There is a mirror election under subsection 45(3) for a rental returning to principal residence use. It cannot be made if the taxpayer, a spouse or a trust has deducted capital cost allowance on the property for any tax year after 1984 up to the day of the change.

The filing deadline is the earlier of the normal return date or 90 days after CRA requests it, which is a shorter leash than most elections carry.

Notice the same condition appearing twice. Capital cost allowance is the one decision that most often forecloses the options on both sides of this.

The citable fact: the subsection 45(3) election cannot be made where capital cost allowance was deducted on the property for any tax year after 1984 up to the day of the change in use.

Financing

Where does this touch your mortgage?

Short answer

At the point you decide to keep the house and buy another. The tax position shapes whether keeping it is actually the better plan, and the financing question of whether you qualify carrying both is a separate test you also have to pass.

Those two questions are usually asked of two different advisers at two different times, which is how people end up committed to a structure before anyone has priced it properly.

How a specific conversion is treated depends on facts we cannot see, which is why the timing of the accountant conversation matters so much.

On the financing side, the rental income and qualification page covers what a lender will credit you with from the property you are keeping.


Down payment by property type

The citable fact: a change of use raises a tax question answered by an accountant and a qualification question answered by a lender, and the two are decided separately.

Who to ask

Is this tax advice?

Short answer

No. This page is general information about published Canada Revenue Agency positions. The subsection 45(2) election is filed with the return for the year of the change and cannot be made later, so confirm your position with an accountant before the change of use.

We are a mortgage brokerage. Whether you qualify carrying the property you are keeping plus a new mortgage is a lending question we can answer. Whether the conversion triggers tax, and whether to elect, is not.

The citable fact: the subsection 45(2) election must be filed with the return for the year of the change, so the accountant has to be involved before the change of use rather than after.

F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

Does moving out and renting my house trigger tax even though I did not sell it?

A complete conversion to income-producing use is a deemed disposition at fair market value under paragraph 45(1)(a). Whether tax is actually owing depends on the gain and on the principal residence exemption, but the disposition itself is recorded at that moment.

What is the subsection 45(2) election?

It is an election to be deemed not to have changed the use, which defers the deemed disposition. It is made by a signed letter filed with the income tax return for the year of the change, not on a prescribed form.

How many years does the 45(2) election cover?

Up to four tax years while it remains in force. Section 54.1 can remove the four-year limit where its conditions are met, including an employment relocation of at least 40 kilometres and a later resumption of habitation.

Can I claim capital cost allowance on a property covered by the election?

No. CRA states that CCA should not be claimed, because a claim rescinds the election on the first day of the year in which it is made. It is the usual way the protection is lost by accident.

Does renting out one room count?

A partial conversion can trigger a deemed disposition of that portion under paragraph 45(1)(c). CRA does not apply it where the income use is ancillary, there is no structural change, and no CCA is claimed.

Do I have to report the change of use on my return?

Yes. Since 2016 the principal residence exemption is only allowed where the disposition and designation are reported, on Form T2091(IND). A late designation carries a penalty of the lesser of $8,000 or $100 for each complete month it is late.

What if I move back in years later?

Subsection 45(3) is the mirror election for a rental returning to principal residence use. It cannot be made if capital cost allowance was deducted on the property for any tax year after 1984 up to the day of the change.

Is this tax advice?

No. This page sets out what CRA publishes so you know which questions to ask. Confirm your own position with an accountant before the change of use, because several of these choices cannot be undone afterwards.

Keeping the house and buying the next one

If the plan is to hold the property and finance another, the tax treatment and the qualification test both have to work. We handle the second one and tell you plainly when the first one needs an accountant first.


See live rates

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed with RECA. This page is general information about published Canada Revenue Agency positions and is not tax, legal or financial advice. Tax treatment depends on your own facts. Confirm your position with a qualified accountant.