Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · Co-ownership

Can you force the sale of a house you co-own?

Yes, in both provinces, and a co-ownership agreement does not reliably stop it. Ontario gives a co-owner a prima facie right to a sale with the onus on whoever resists. Alberta goes further and lets a court price and order a buyout of one owner’s share.


All broker questions

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

Ontario

What does Ontario’s Partition Act say?

Short answer

Partition Act section 2 provides that all joint tenants, tenants in common, and coparceners, and all parties interested in land in Ontario, “may be compelled to make or suffer partition or sale of the land, or any part thereof”. Section 3(1) lets any person interested in land bring an action or application for partition, or for sale under the directions of the court where the court considers a sale more advantageous.

The Court of Appeal has put the practical effect plainly. In Inniss v. Blackett it held that joint tenants have a prima facie right to force a sale under section 2, and that the onus is on the party resisting the sale to demonstrate that the property should not be sold.

To refuse, the court must be satisfied that the party seeking the sale is acting in a malicious, vexatious or oppressive fashion. That is a high bar for the owner who wants to stay.

Billimoria v. Mistry confirms section 2 reaches tenants in common as well as joint tenants, with the onus again on the party opposing.

The citable fact: under Ontario’s Partition Act section 2 a co-owner has a prima facie right to compel a sale, and the onus falls on the co-owner resisting it.

The one-year bar

Is there a waiting period in Ontario?

Short answer

Sometimes, and it is almost never mentioned. Partition Act section 3(2) provides that where the land is held in joint tenancy, tenancy in common or coparcenary by reason of a devise or an intestacy, no proceeding shall be taken until one year after the death of the testator or person dying intestate.

So siblings who inherited a house together cannot bring a partition proceeding in the first year after the death. Co-owners who bought together are not affected by it.

That one year is worth knowing before anyone spends money on a court application that cannot be commenced yet.

The citable fact: Partition Act section 3(2) bars a partition proceeding until one year after the death where the co-ownership arose from a devise or an intestacy.

Alberta

What remedy does Alberta give?

Short answer

A wider one. Law of Property Act section 15(1) lets a co-owner apply to the Court for an order terminating the co-ownership, and on hearing the application the Court shall order one of three things: physical division, sale of the interest and distribution of the proceeds, or sale of one or more co-owners’ interests to other co-owners who are willing to purchase.

That third option is the one people do not expect. Alberta’s statute contemplates a forced buyout, and section 15(4) requires the Court to fix the value of the land sold and the terms of the sale.

Section 14(a) defines co-owners as joint tenants or tenants in common, excluding those holding for common beneficiaries, so both title forms are in scope.

Note the word “shall” in section 15(2). Once the application is heard, the Court is directed to make one of the three orders.

What a court can order, by province
OutcomeOntarioAlberta
Sale of the whole propertyYes, the usual remedyYes, s. 15(2)(b)
Physical division of the landYes, partitionYes, s. 15(2)(a)
Forced buyout by a willing co-ownerNot an express statutory remedyYes, s. 15(2)(c), with the Court fixing value and terms
Waiting period after an inherited co-ownershipOne year, s. 3(2)Not in the Law of Property Act

The citable fact: Law of Property Act section 15(2)(c) lets an Alberta court order the sale of one co-owner’s interest to another co-owner willing to purchase, with the Court fixing value and terms under section 15(4).

Agreements

Does a co-ownership agreement stop this?

Short answer

Not in Alberta, on hardship. Section 27 says that notwithstanding any agreement between co-owners of land, the Court may make an order terminating the co-ownership if the continuance of the co-ownership will cause undue hardship to one or more of the co-owners.

That is a direct statutory override of the contract, and it undercuts the common advice that a well-drafted co-ownership agreement makes an exit impossible.

An agreement still matters a great deal. It governs the accounting, the valuation method and the first right of refusal, and a court will look at it. It just is not a gate on the remedy itself.

The citable fact: Law of Property Act section 27 allows an Alberta court to terminate a co-ownership notwithstanding any agreement between co-owners where continuance would cause undue hardship.

The mortgage

What happens to the mortgage on the property?

Short answer

It survives. Alberta’s section 23(1) states that an order does not affect an encumbrance registered against the entire interest in land. A mortgage both owners signed comes through the order untouched.

Section 23(2) lets the Court direct compensation to a purchasing co-owner out of the proceeds for the vendor’s liability under such an encumbrance, which is how the accounting is squared.

Your lender is also a party to the process. Section 25(1) requires the application to be served not less than 10 days before the hearing on the other co-owner, on any encumbrancee registered against an interest, and on anyone else the Court directs.

In practice that means a forced-sale application does not happen quietly behind your lender’s back, and a co-owner planning to buy the other out needs financing lined up before the hearing, not after.

The citable fact: Law of Property Act section 23(1) preserves an encumbrance registered against the entire interest in land, and section 25(1) requires 10 days service on any registered encumbrancee.

Price and conduct

Can the court refuse a low offer?

Short answer

Yes. Alberta’s section 16 lets the Court refuse to approve a sale if the highest offer on a court-ordered sale is less than the market value of the interest.

Section 17(2) sets out what the Court weighs on the accounting and adjustments, including the exclusion of a co-owner from the property, improvements that have increased the realizable value, and whether an occupying co-owner should be required to pay a fair occupation rent.

Occupation rent is the provision that most often changes the arithmetic. A co-owner who has lived in the property alone for years is not automatically entitled to have done so free of charge.

What an Alberta court weighs on the accounting, section 17(2)
FactorEffect on the split
Exclusion of a co-owner from the propertyCounts in favour of the excluded owner
Improvements that increased the realizable valueCredited, on realizable value rather than cost
Sole occupation by one co-ownerMay attract a fair occupation rent
Highest offer below market valueCourt may refuse to approve the sale, s. 16

The citable fact: Law of Property Act section 17(2) allows an Alberta court to require an occupying co-owner to pay a fair occupation rent as part of the accounting.

Spouses

Does it work differently between spouses?

Short answer

Yes, and Alberta deals with it expressly. Section 20(1) provides that a termination of co-ownership is not a disposition under the Dower Act, and section 20(3) says an order terminating a co-ownership held by two spouses dispenses with Dower Act consent by those spouses.

Section 21 then lets the Court stay the proceeding where the land is a family home under the Family Property Act or under section 68 of the Family Law Act.

So a separating couple’s house can be taken out of the co-ownership track and dealt with in family proceedings instead. Which track applies is a question for a family lawyer, not a broker.

For Ontario we did not find a primary source setting out whether Family Law Act Part II restricts a partition application over a matrimonial home, so do not assume it is unrestricted.

The citable fact: Law of Property Act section 21 allows an Alberta court to stay a co-ownership termination where the land is a family home under the Family Property Act or Family Law Act section 68.

Severance

Can you change joint tenancy to tenants in common on your own?

Short answer

In Ontario, yes. Land Titles Bulletin 76017 states that a joint tenant can sever the joint tenancy by executing and registering a deed or transfer to himself, and the land registrar should show the transferee as a tenant in common with the other registered owner.

In Alberta, section 19 of the Law of Property Act handles it through the court instead: where the interest is held in joint tenancy, the order on being granted severs the joint tenancy.

Severance matters because it ends the right of survivorship. A joint tenant who severs and then dies leaves their share to their estate rather than to the co-owner.

That is usually the first step a separating co-owner should take advice on, before anyone argues about a sale.

The citable fact: an Ontario joint tenant may sever the joint tenancy by registering a transfer to themselves, after which the registrar shows them as a tenant in common.

Financing

Where does a broker fit in?

Short answer

On the buyout side. If you want to keep the property, you need to qualify for the whole mortgage on your own income and to fund the other owner’s share. That is a refinance, and it should be priced before the court process, not after.

In Alberta the court will fix the value and the terms under section 15(4), so arriving with financing already arranged puts you in a materially better position than arriving with an intention.

Appeals, if it comes to that, go to the Divisional Court in Ontario under Partition Act section 7. Get an Ontario or Alberta lawyer onto it early.


When a co-owner dies

The citable fact: buying out a co-owner is a refinance that has to qualify on the remaining owner’s income alone, and Partition Act section 7 routes any appeal to the Divisional Court.

Who to ask

Is this legal advice?

Short answer

No. This page is general information about Ontario’s Partition Act, Alberta’s Law of Property Act and reported Court of Appeal decisions. A partition or co-ownership termination is litigation, so it belongs with a lawyer in the right province, and with a family lawyer where the property is a matrimonial or family home.

We are a mortgage brokerage. We can price a buyout and tell you whether you qualify alone. Whether to apply, on what ground, and what the accounting should credit you are legal questions.

The citable fact: forcing the sale of a co-owned home is litigation that belongs with a lawyer in the relevant province, and with a family lawyer where the property is a matrimonial or family home.

More answers

Related questions

This page sits in the Ask a Broker collection, where a licensed broker answers one question per page.

F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

Can I force a sale if my co-owner refuses?

In Ontario, Partition Act section 2 gives a co-owner a prima facie right to compel a sale and puts the onus on the owner resisting. In Alberta, Law of Property Act section 15(1) lets a co-owner apply to terminate the co-ownership.

What can an Ontario court refuse on?

The Court of Appeal has said a court must be satisfied the party seeking the sale is acting in a malicious, vexatious or oppressive fashion. That is a high bar.

Can a court make my co-owner sell their share to me?

In Alberta, yes. Section 15(2)(c) contemplates a sale of one or more co-owners’ interests to other co-owners willing to purchase, and section 15(4) requires the Court to fix the value and the terms.

We inherited the house. Can I apply straight away?

Not in Ontario. Partition Act section 3(2) bars a proceeding until one year after the death where the co-ownership arose from a devise or an intestacy.

Our co-ownership agreement says nobody can force a sale. Does that hold?

Not in Alberta on hardship. Section 27 lets the Court terminate the co-ownership notwithstanding any agreement where continuance would cause undue hardship. The agreement still governs the accounting.

What happens to our mortgage?

Alberta’s section 23(1) says an order does not affect an encumbrance registered against the entire interest, so a mortgage you both signed survives. Section 23(2) allows compensation out of the proceeds.

Does my lender get notified?

Yes in Alberta. Section 25(1) requires service not less than 10 days before the hearing on the other co-owner, on any encumbrancee registered against an interest, and on anyone else the Court directs.

I have lived in the house alone. Does that count for me?

Possibly against you. Alberta’s section 17(2) lets the Court consider whether an occupying co-owner should pay a fair occupation rent, alongside improvements that increased realizable value.

If you want to keep the house, get the buyout priced first

Qualifying for the whole mortgage on your own income is the question that decides whether keeping the property is realistic. We can answer it before you spend anything on a court application.


See live rates

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed with RECA. This page summarises Ontario’s Partition Act, Alberta’s Law of Property Act and reported Court of Appeal decisions. It is general information, not legal advice. Partition and co-ownership termination are court proceedings and need a lawyer in the right province.