Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · Commercial

The lender wants a Phase 1 environmental. Is that the law?

No. No Ontario or Alberta statute or regulation requires an environmental site assessment as a condition of mortgage financing. A lender’s Phase 1 is policy, and policy is negotiable on scope, on timing and on who gets to rely on the report. What the law does require is something else entirely, and it is triggered by what you do with the land, not by who lends on it.


All broker questions

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

What the law actually requires

So what triggers a Phase 1 by statute?

Short answer

In Ontario, a change of use. The Environmental Protection Act section 168.3.1(1) prohibits changing a property’s use “from industrial or commercial use to residential or parkland use” unless a record of site condition has been filed, and the record requires that “a qualified person has certified … that a phase one environmental site assessment of the property has been conducted”.

Read the chain carefully, because the order matters. The statute does not say “get a Phase 1”. It prohibits the change of use, offers the record of site condition as the way through, and the Phase 1 is a component of that record.

So the Ontario trigger is conversion. An industrial building becoming lofts needs one. The same building refinanced and left industrial does not, as a matter of law.

Alberta works differently, and here the common advice is simply wrong. Its Remediation Regulation section 2.2(1) requires that on becoming aware of a release, the person responsible must “submit a Phase 2 environmental site assessment to the Director” or complete remediation and report.

That is a Phase 2, not a Phase 1, and it is triggered by a known release rather than by a transaction. Alberta’s regulation requires a Phase 1 in only two places, both regulatory instruments a landowner chooses to seek: a Tier 2 compliance letter, and a site-based remediation certificate.

The citable fact: Ontario’s statutory Phase 1 trigger is a change of use requiring a record of site condition, while Alberta’s Remediation Regulation requires a Phase 2 on a known release and requires a Phase 1 only for a compliance letter or a remediation certificate.

The paper trail

Then why is it in my commitment?

Short answer

Because it is the lender’s own condition, and on insured multi-unit files it traces to CMHC documents rather than to any statute. Which means the honest answer to “is this required” is “by whom”, and the answer changes the conversation from compliance to negotiation.

Here is the part worth knowing before you argue it. Two CMHC documents currently in circulation disagree with each other, and we are not going to pretend otherwise by picking the one that suits.

The multi-unit reference guide, footer code 66800 20201207-001, requires before first advance a “standardized letter from the lender confirming the Phase I Environmental Site Assessment for the subject property (building types with 7+ units) conforms to CMHC policy relating to environmental risks”.

The standalone Required Documentation Guide, same publication number at a later revision, 66800 20251029-009A, carries no Phase 1 requirement at all. Its only environmental line applies to new construction and is conditional: “In the case of confirmed soil or ground water contamination”, the assessment report and a reliance letter are required.

Both are served live. Both carry the same publication number at different revisions. Both carry the same warning to “verify with CMHC that you have the most up to date information before the loan is processed”, which is as close as a document gets to telling you it may not be the current one.

The current MLI Select product sheet, 66792 20251029-008AM, is silent on site assessments entirely. Its only environmental mention is that a borrower “remains liable under a limited recourse loan for fraud and environmental liability in all cases”.

What each live CMHC document says about a Phase 1, as of November 2026
DocumentRevision codePhase 1 position
Multi-unit reference guide66800 20201207-001Required before first advance, 7+ unit building types, via a lender letter
Required Documentation Guide66800 20251029-009ANo Phase 1 requirement. Assessment only where contamination is confirmed, and only on new construction
MLI Select product sheet66792 20251029-008AMSilent on site assessments

The citable fact: two CMHC multi-unit documents sharing publication number 66800 at different revisions are both served live as of November 2026, one requiring a Phase 1 before first advance on 7+ unit buildings and the other requiring no Phase 1 at all.

If the site is dirty

Who has to clean it up?

Short answer

In Alberta, a longer list of people than most buyers expect, and the list reaches backwards. EPEA section 107(1)(c) defines the person responsible to include “the owner of the contaminated site” and “any previous owner of the contaminated site who was the owner at any time when the substance was in, on or under the contaminated site”.

It also reaches sideways, to “a successor, assignee, executor, administrator, receiver, receiver-manager or trustee” of those people, and to anyone acting as their principal or agent.

Note the qualification on previous owners. It is not every former owner, only one who owned while the substance was present. That is a real limit and it is often quoted away.

There is one carve-out worth knowing if you are the one commissioning the report. Section 107(1)(viii) excludes “a person who investigates or tests a parcel of land for the purpose of determining the environmental condition of that parcel”, unless the testing itself releases something new.

So in Alberta, looking does not make you responsible. That answers the question people are usually too nervous to ask out loud.

The citable fact: Alberta’s EPEA section 107(1)(c) captures the current owner, any previous owner who owned while the substance was present, and their receivers and trustees, while expressly excluding the person who investigates the parcel’s environmental condition.

The provinces diverge

Is a lender protected if it forecloses?

Short answer

In Ontario, partly, and with four qualifications. In Alberta, there is no equivalent provision at all. This is the single largest difference between the two provinces on this subject and it shapes how cautious a lender is on an Alberta file.

Ontario gives it expressly. EPA section 168.18(1) provides that where a secured creditor becomes owner by foreclosure, no order shall be issued to it under the Act for a defined period unless the order arises from “the gross negligence or wilful misconduct” of the creditor or prescribed circumstances.

Now the qualifications, because “five years” on its own is not accurate. The period ends on the earlier of the fifth anniversary of becoming owner or the day the creditor ceases to own the property. The Director may extend it. It is lost for gross negligence or wilful misconduct. And section 168.20(1) overrides it entirely where the Director has reasonable grounds to believe there is “danger to the health or safety of any person” or “impairment or serious risk of impairment of the quality of the natural environment”.

It is also narrower than it sounds in kind, not just in time. The protection is against orders under that Act, not against liability generally.

Alberta’s section 107(1) contains no secured creditor exclusion. A lender that takes title on foreclosure lands in paragraph (c)(iii) as the owner, with no time-limited shield.

Secured creditor position on a contaminated site
 OntarioAlberta
Protection before enforcementYes, EPA s. 168.17, for listed actions including investigationNo equivalent provision
Protection after foreclosureYes, EPA s. 168.18No equivalent provision
How long it lastsThe earlier of the fifth anniversary or ceasing to own, extendable by the DirectorNot applicable
What defeats itGross negligence, wilful misconduct, prescribed circumstances, or a s. 168.20 health or environment findingNot applicable
Receivers and trusteesProtected under s. 168.19 with no time limitCaptured as persons responsible under s. 107(1)(c)(v)
The investigating consultantAn investigation is a protected action for a secured creditor under s. 168.17(2)Expressly excluded by s. 107(1)(viii)

The citable fact: Ontario’s EPA gives a secured creditor a time-limited shield from orders after foreclosure, ending on the earlier of the fifth anniversary or ceasing to own, while Alberta’s EPEA contains no secured creditor exclusion.

What you can do about it

If it is policy, what is negotiable?

Short answer

Three things, and they are worth asking for in this order: who the report is addressed to, what the scope covers, and whether a Phase 1 is needed at all on this building type. A requirement sourced to policy can be discussed. A requirement sourced to statute cannot.

Start with reliance. A report addressed to you is not automatically a report the lender may rely on, and a report commissioned for the lender may not be one you can use later. CMHC’s own newer document asks for “a signed reliance letter from the third-party assessor” in the contamination case, which tells you reliance is a separate thing from the report.

Then scope. A Phase 1 is a records and interview exercise. It does not involve drilling. If a lender is asking for sampling, that is a Phase 2 and it is a different cost and a different timeline, so establish which one is actually being required.

Then the threshold. The requirement in the older CMHC guide is tied to “building types with 7+ units”, so on a smaller building it is worth asking which document the condition came from.

What we are not going to do is tell you the condition will be waived. Lenders set their own environmental policy, they do not publish it, and we have no document to cite for what any individual lender will accept.


Commercial mortgages

The citable fact: because a lender’s Phase 1 requirement is policy rather than statute, its scope, its reliance wording and its application to a given building type are all open to discussion, while individual lender environmental policy is unpublished.

Timing

When should it be ordered?

Short answer

Before the condition period is set, not after. A Phase 1 is the item most likely to decide how long a commercial financing condition needs to be, and ordering it after the offer is firm removes the only exit you had.

If a release turns up, Alberta’s clock starts from awareness rather than from any filing. Section 2.2(1) obliges the person responsible to act “as soon as possible” once they become aware or ought to have become aware.

Section 2.2(2) then gives the outer limit: if the site cannot be remediated to the Director’s satisfaction “within a 2-year period after a person responsible becomes aware of or ought to have become aware of the release”, a remedial action plan must be submitted immediately.

So on an Alberta file, discovering something is not a neutral event. It engages an obligation with its own timetable, independent of the mortgage.

The citable fact: Alberta’s Remediation Regulation runs its remediation timetable from when the person responsible becomes aware or ought to have become aware of a release, with a two-year outer limit before a remedial action plan is required.

Who to ask

Is this legal advice?

Short answer

No. Environmental liability is a lawyer’s subject, and on a commercial file with any contamination history it is specialist work. Reliance wording and indemnities in particular are drafted, not chosen from a menu.

We are a mortgage brokerage. We can tell you which document a condition is sourced to, push back where it is policy rather than law, and set a condition period that is long enough to actually get the report. We cannot advise you on liability or clean-up obligations.

The citable fact: two live CMHC documents sharing one publication number give contradictory Phase 1 requirements, so the page reports both rather than choosing, and your own file may have been underwritten against either.

More answers

Related questions

This page sits in the Ask a Broker collection, where a licensed broker answers one question per page.

F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

Is a Phase 1 environmental legally required to get a mortgage?

No. No Ontario or Alberta statute or regulation requires an environmental site assessment as a condition of mortgage financing. Where a Phase 1 is required by law, the trigger is a land use or remediation instrument the owner is seeking, not a loan.

What does trigger one in Ontario?

A change of use from industrial or commercial to residential or parkland. That needs a record of site condition, and the record requires a qualified person to certify that a Phase 1 has been conducted.

What does Alberta require?

On becoming aware of a release, a Phase 2, not a Phase 1. Alberta’s Remediation Regulation requires a Phase 1 only for a Tier 2 compliance letter or a site-based remediation certificate.

Does CMHC require a Phase 1 on a multi-unit file?

Its own live documents disagree. The multi-unit reference guide requires one before first advance on 7+ unit building types; the later-revised Required Documentation Guide carries no Phase 1 requirement at all. Both are published, so ask which one your condition came from.

Who is responsible for cleaning up contamination in Alberta?

The current owner, any previous owner who owned while the substance was present, and their successors, receivers and trustees. The person who investigates the parcel’s environmental condition is expressly excluded.

Is my lender protected if it forecloses on a contaminated site?

In Ontario, partly. Orders under the Act cannot issue for a period ending on the earlier of the fifth anniversary of taking ownership or ceasing to own, subject to gross negligence, wilful misconduct and a health or environment override. Alberta has no equivalent provision.

Does commissioning a report expose me to liability for what it finds?

In Alberta the investigator is expressly carved out of the persons responsible definition, unless the testing itself releases something new. In Ontario, investigation is one of the listed protected actions for a secured creditor.

What is actually negotiable about the condition?

Who may rely on the report, whether the scope is a Phase 1 or a Phase 2, and whether the building type falls inside the threshold the requirement came from. What a specific lender will accept is unpublished, so we will not predict it.

Find out which document your condition came from

That one question changes a compliance problem into a negotiation. Send us the commitment wording and we will tell you what it is sourced to.


Commercial mortgages

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed with RECA. Ontario provisions were read from the consolidated Environmental Protection Act, Alberta provisions from the King’s Printer consolidated EPEA and Remediation Regulation, and the CMHC positions from the three documents named above, all on 3 November 2026 and current as of that date. Statutory and regulatory requirements change. General information, not legal advice.