Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · Home equity

HELOC or second mortgage: which one are you actually choosing between?

They are not two versions of the same thing. A HELOC is revolving credit with a limit that stops at 65 per cent of your home’s value, because Guideline B-20 expects lenders to cap the non-amortizing HELOC component there and to amortize anything above it. A second mortgage is a term loan with a payment, and it can sit above 65 per cent.


All broker questions

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

The distinction

What is the actual difference between the two?

Short answer

A HELOC is a revolving facility: a limit you can draw, repay and redraw, with interest charged only on the balance outstanding. A second mortgage is a term loan: one advance, a repayment schedule and a maturity date. One is a tap, the other is a bucket.

Everything else that differs between them follows from that. Because a HELOC is revolving, the limit is committed whether you use it or not, which is why you qualify on the limit. Because a second mortgage is advanced once, the lender’s exposure is known on day one, which is why it can be arranged faster and placed higher up the value of the house.

The confusion is understandable, because both are secured by a charge registered against your home and both are described as “borrowing against equity”. The security is similar. The product is not.

The citable fact: a HELOC is revolving credit on which interest is charged only on the drawn balance, while a second mortgage is a single advance with a repayment schedule and a maturity date.

The ceiling

Why does a HELOC stop at 65 per cent of value?

Short answer

Because Guideline B-20 says so, in terms. OSFI “expects FRFIs to limit the non-amortizing HELOC component of a residential mortgage to a maximum authorized LTV ratio of less than or equal to 65 percent”. Credit above that line can still be extended, and the Guideline’s own footnote says that portion should be amortized, which a revolving limit is not.

The quoted expectation is in the body of the Guideline, dated 31 October 2017. Footnote 16 completes it: “Additional mortgage credit (beyond the LTV ratio limit of 65 percent for HELOCs) can be extended to a borrower. However, the loan portion over the 65 percent LTV ratio threshold should be amortized.”

Two further parts of B-20 matter to how widely that reaches. Footnote 15 provides that “all reverse mortgages, or any non-amortizing (revolving) credit product secured by residential property, are considered to be HELOCs” for the purpose of the Guideline, so the cap is not confined to products sold under the HELOC name. And the body adds that the expectation “also applies where a HELOC is structured as part of a consolidated or linked mortgage loan product”.

What the 2022 advisory adds is narrower than it is often given credit for. OSFI’s Clarification on the Treatment of Innovative Real Estate Secured Lending Products, dated 30 June 2022, deals with combined loan plans, shared equity and reverse mortgages. On combined loan plans it goes beyond B-20 by requiring that lending above the line be “both amortizing and non-readvanceable“, with principal payments on that segment “matched by a reduction in the overall authorized limit”. The advisory describes the 65 per cent expectation itself as B-20’s and calls it “foundational”.

FCAC states the same position to consumers from the equity side: more than 35 per cent equity for a standalone HELOC, 20 per cent for a HELOC combined with a mortgage, and borrowing up to 65 per cent of the value of your home. Those are not extra rules. They are the same pair expressed the other way round.

The mechanics of a line whose limit grows as the mortgage is repaid are set out in how the readvanceable rebalancing rule actually works.

The citable fact: the 65 per cent cap on the non-amortizing HELOC component is in Guideline B-20 itself, together with the footnote requiring the portion above it to be amortized, while OSFI’s 2022 advisory adds that on a combined loan plan that lending must also be non-readvanceable.

The other ceiling

How high can a second mortgage go?

Short answer

Higher than a HELOC, because a term loan amortizes, which is what B-20 requires of credit above the line, and it does not readvance, which is what the 2022 advisory requires of a combined loan plan. Where the lender is a bank, subsection 418(1) of the Bank Act caps the total at 80 per cent of value.

The Bank Act wording is specific about how the total is measured. The restriction bites where “the amount of the loan, together with the amount then outstanding of any mortgage having an equal or prior claim against the property, would exceed 80 per cent of the value of the property at the time of the loan”. So the first mortgage counts toward the ceiling and the second is squeezed into what is left.

Above 80 per cent the lender is generally not a bank. Alternative and private lenders are not subject to section 418 in the same way, which is why second mortgages exist at higher loan to value and why they are priced for the risk that creates.

Where each instrument can sit against the value of the home
Band of valueRevolving HELOCSecond mortgage
Up to 65%AvailableAvailable
65% to 80%Not as revolving creditAvailable, including from banks subject to s. 418
Above 80%NoGenerally outside the bank sector

The citable fact: subsection 418(1) of the Bank Act caps a bank’s residential loan, together with any equal or prior mortgage, at 80 per cent of the value of the property, which is the ceiling a second mortgage from a bank has to fit inside.

The qualification

Do you qualify differently for each?

Short answer

On a HELOC you qualify on the whole limit, not on what you intend to draw, because the lender has committed the whole amount. On a second mortgage you qualify on the payment, and from an alternative lender the test may lean more on the property than on the income.

That difference has a consequence people find counter-intuitive. A $150,000 HELOC limit you never touch is a committed facility, and an undrawn limit can still be counted in a debt service calculation on your next application. A paid-off second mortgage, by contrast, is simply gone.

So the question “should I keep the line open just in case” has a cost attached to it, and the cost shows up at the next renewal or purchase rather than now. Closing an unused facility sometimes improves a file more than paying down a balance does.

Both instruments are qualified at the stress test rate where the lender is federally regulated. What that test is and how it is applied is set out in the mortgage stress test explained.

The citable fact: a HELOC is qualified on its full approved limit rather than on the amount drawn, so an undrawn limit can reduce what you qualify for on a later mortgage application.

The ranking

What does “second” actually mean on title?

Short answer

It means later in time and therefore later in line. Charges rank by registration, so the first mortgage registered is paid first out of the proceeds of a sale or an enforcement, and the second mortgage is paid from what remains.

That ranking is the whole of the pricing difference. A lender in second position is exposed to everything that goes wrong with the value of the house before the first lender is exposed to anything, which is why a second mortgage is priced above a first and why the loan to value matters so much more.

Two practical consequences. A second mortgage lender can enforce its security in its own right, which is set out in can a second mortgage lender foreclose. And a second that matures before the first creates a refinancing problem on a date you did not choose, covered in what happens when a second mortgage matures first.

The citable fact: mortgage charges rank by registration date, so a second mortgage is repaid from what remains after the first mortgage is satisfied, which is the source of its pricing difference.

The purpose test

Which one suits which purpose?

Short answer

Match the instrument to the shape of the spending. Money spent in stages over months suits a revolving limit. Money spent once, especially to clear other debts, suits a term loan with a payment that ends.

Matching the instrument to the purpose
PurposeUsually suitsWhy
Renovation paid in stagesHELOCInterest runs only on what has been drawn, so the money is not paid for before the contractor needs it
Consolidating unsecured debtSecond mortgageOne advance clears the debts and the fixed payment is a repayment plan rather than an option
Emergency reserve held openHELOCNothing is borrowed until it is needed, at the cost of a committed limit that counts against you later
A deadline, such as arrears or a tax billSecond mortgageFaster to arrange where the lender is an alternative, and the amount is known
Bridging to a saleNeither, usuallyA bridge loan is the purpose-built instrument and is priced for days rather than years

One pattern worth naming, because it recurs. A HELOC used to consolidate debt and then redrawn is the common way a consolidation unwinds: the cards are paid, the limit is available, and eighteen months later there are card balances and a HELOC balance. The fixed payment on a second mortgage is less flexible and that is sometimes the point.

Where the purpose is to clear debt, the alternative worth costing beside both is a full refinance, set out in refinancing to consolidate debt.

The citable fact: a revolving line suits spending that happens in stages because interest accrues only on the drawn balance, while a single advance with a fixed payment suits debt consolidation because it removes the option to redraw.

The exit

What does it cost to get out of each one?

Short answer

A HELOC usually closes without a prepayment charge because there is no term to break, and the charge still has to be discharged from title. A second mortgage has a term, and leaving it early can carry a prepayment charge set by its own contract.

No figure appears on this page for either, deliberately. Discharge charges and prepayment terms are set by the individual lender and written into the document you signed, and a number here would be wrong for most readers. The document to read is your own commitment or charge terms.

The item that catches people is not the charge, it is the charge type. Where a HELOC or a readvanceable mortgage is secured by a collateral charge, moving the whole arrangement to a new lender can be more involved than switching a standard charge, and that is covered in how a collateral charge affects switching lenders.

The citable fact: a revolving home equity line has no term to break and therefore usually no prepayment charge, while a second mortgage with a fixed term can carry one set by its own contract.

The common error

What is the mistake people make most often here?

Short answer

Choosing on the posted rate. The cheaper instrument is the one that costs less over the way you will actually use the money, and that depends on the average balance and the length of time rather than on the rate alone.

Work it through without numbers, because the shape is the point. A revolving line charges interest on the average balance. A term loan charges interest on the full advance from day one. For a renovation spread over eight months, the line can cost less in total even on a higher rate, because for most of those months the balance is small.

Reverse the facts and the answer reverses. For $60,000 drawn at once and repaid over five years, the term loan’s rate is applied to a balance that is falling on a schedule, and the line’s flexibility is worth nothing because there is no staging to exploit.

The second common error is treating the limit as the decision. A $200,000 limit approved is not $200,000 of plan, and it is $200,000 of commitment that your next lender will see.

The citable fact: the total cost of a revolving line depends on the average drawn balance rather than the limit, which is why staged spending can cost less on a line than on a term loan at a lower rate.

Who to ask

Who do you need, and what should you bring?

Short answer

Your broker, with the purpose and the amount, and your existing lender for two documents. A lawyer is involved only where a new charge has to be registered, which depends on which route you take.

  • Your broker, with the purpose written down. What the money is for, when it is needed and over what period it will be spent. Those three facts decide the instrument more than any rate comparison does.
  • Your existing lender, for your current balance and your charge terms. Whether your mortgage is secured by a standard or a collateral charge changes what is possible without touching the first mortgage.
  • A lawyer, where a new charge is registered. A second mortgage from a new lender is a new instrument on title. Some prime HELOCs behind the same lender’s own first mortgage are handled without one.
  • Possibly none of them. Where the amount is small and short, an unsecured line can be cheaper than registering anything against your house, and that comparison is worth making before you start.

Bring four things: your mortgage statement, an honest estimate of your home’s value, the purpose and amount, and any existing line of credit limits whether or not you use them.

Have a question? Chat with our team or AI assistant directly on pekoe.ca.

The citable fact: the purpose, the amount and the period over which the money will be spent are the three facts that decide between a home equity line and a second mortgage.

F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference in one sentence?

A HELOC is a revolving limit you draw and repay at will, and a second mortgage is a fixed amount advanced once with a repayment schedule. The first is a facility, the second is a loan.

Why does a HELOC stop at 65 per cent of my home’s value?

Because Guideline B-20 expects lenders to limit the non-amortizing HELOC component to a maximum authorized loan to value of 65 per cent or less, and its footnote 16 says credit above that line should be amortized. A revolving limit does not amortize, so the revolving portion stops there.

Can a second mortgage go above 65 per cent?

Yes, because it amortizes, which is what B-20 requires of credit above that line, and it does not readvance, which is what the 2022 advisory requires of a combined loan plan. Where the lender is a bank, subsection 418(1) of the Bank Act still caps the total at 80 per cent of value.

Which one is cheaper?

That depends on the pricing of the day and on how much of the money you actually use, so no figure appears here. A HELOC charges interest only on what is drawn, which can make a smaller average balance cheaper even at a higher posted rate.

Do I have to qualify for the full HELOC limit?

Yes. You qualify on the limit rather than on what you intend to draw, because the lender has committed to the whole amount. That is why a large unused limit can affect a later application.

Does an unused HELOC limit hurt my next mortgage application?

It can. An undrawn limit may still be counted in the debt service calculation, which is why closing a facility you do not use sometimes improves a file more than paying down a balance does.

Which one is faster to arrange?

A second mortgage is usually faster where speed is the point, particularly from an alternative or private lender. A HELOC from a prime lender is a full application with an appraisal and a new charge.

Does a second mortgage rank behind my first?

Yes, by registration. The first mortgage registered has first claim on the proceeds of a sale or enforcement, and the second is paid from what is left, which is the whole reason a second is priced differently.

Can I get a HELOC behind another lender’s first mortgage?

Sometimes, and it is less common than a second mortgage in that position. Most prime HELOCs are arranged by the lender that holds the first charge, so a second lender in that spot is usually offering a term loan.

What happens at the end of a second mortgage term?

It matures and has to be repaid, renewed or replaced, and that date can arrive before your first mortgage matures. That timing mismatch is its own problem and worth planning for at the start.

Is a HELOC the same as a readvanceable mortgage?

No, although the two are related. A readvanceable mortgage is a term mortgage and a line of credit sharing one charge, where the line’s limit grows as the mortgage is paid down. A standalone HELOC has no term mortgage beside it.

Which is better for a renovation?

A HELOC usually, because a renovation is paid in stages and interest runs only on what has been drawn. A second mortgage advances the whole amount on day one, which means paying for money before the contractor needs it.

Which is better for consolidating debt?

A second mortgage often, because the debts are paid in one advance and the fixed payment is a repayment plan rather than an option. A HELOC that gets redrawn is the common way a consolidation unwinds.

Is the chat on this page a bot?

No. It reaches the Pekoe team, and a licensed broker answers live during business hours or replies directly outside them. There is no AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

Decide what the money is for, then pick the instrument

The choice is easy once the purpose is clear, and difficult in the abstract. Bring the purpose and the amount, and the answer usually takes one conversation.


Home equity access calculator

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed with RECA. The 65 per cent expectation and the requirement that credit above it be amortized are from OSFI Guideline B-20, Residential Mortgage Underwriting Practices and Procedures, dated 31 October 2017, read in full at osfi-bsif.gc.ca on 6 November 2026, at the HELOC section and footnotes 15 and 16. The non-readvanceable requirement and the matching reduction in the authorized limit are from OSFI’s Clarification on the Treatment of Innovative Real Estate Secured Lending Products under Guideline B-20, dated 30 June 2022, read at source on the same date, and apply to combined loan plans. The 80 per cent limit is subsection 418(1) of the Bank Act, read from the federal consolidation at laws-lois.justice.gc.ca. No interest rate appears on this page, deliberately: HELOC and second mortgage pricing move independently and a figure here would be stale within a week. Live rates are at pekoe.ca/rates. Which instrument suits you depends on facts this page does not have.