Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · What ranks ahead of a mortgage

Case study: a $19,400 tax arrears certificate that only surfaced at renewal

An illustrative composite, not a real client. An inherited rental property, four years of tax bills going to an address no longer occupied, and a tax arrears certificate registered against title. The existing lender renewed without asking a question. The switch to a better lender died at the title search, because Municipal Act, 2001 s. 349(3) puts the municipality ahead of every claim except the Crown.


All broker questions

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

The situation

How does anyone miss four years of tax bills?

Short answer

By inheriting a property and never changing the mailing address on the assessment roll. The bills went to the deceased owner’s former address for four years. The mortgage payments came out of a bank account by direct debit, so nothing else ever failed.

The composite is a rental duplex inherited in an estate, with a mortgage already on it that the beneficiary assumed responsibility for and continued to pay. The tenant paid rent. The mortgage payment left the account every month. Nothing in the owner’s daily experience signalled a problem.

What the owner had not done was tell the municipality where to send the tax bill. The assessment roll still carried the deceased owner’s old address, and the property taxes had not been paid since the year of the death.

Four years, as the municipality saw them
YearTaxes leviedPaidCumulative arrears with interest and penalties
Year 1, the year of death$4,100Partly, by the estate$1,900
Year 2$4,200No$6,600
Year 3$4,350No$11,600
Year 4$4,500No$17,000
Cancellation price when it was finally quoted$19,400

The gap between the $17,000 of arrears and the $19,400 cancellation price is the municipality’s costs. Section 371(1) defines the cancellation price to include “all reasonable costs incurred by the municipality after the treasurer becomes entitled to register a tax arrears certificate”, and it “may include, (a) legal fees and disbursements”.

The citable fact: the cancellation price under Municipal Act, 2001 s. 371(1) exceeds the arrears themselves, because it includes all current taxes owing, interest and penalties, and the municipality’s reasonable costs incurred after the treasurer became entitled to register a tax arrears certificate.

The renewal that said nothing

Why did the existing lender not notice?

Short answer

Because a renewal with the same lender does not require a title search. The arrears were visible on title and no search was run, because there was no occasion to run one. The owner signed the renewal letter and carried on.

This is the structural point of the composite. An existing lender can renew a maturing mortgage without re-qualifying the borrower and without re-searching title. That is ordinarily an advantage to the borrower. Here it was the reason a serious problem went undetected for another two years.

A switch to a different lender is the opposite. It is a new charge, so there is a new title search, and a tax arrears certificate on title is found immediately. That is what happened on the second renewal, when the owner shopped the mortgage for the first time.

So the owner’s instinct that signing the renewal letter was the easy option had been correct about effort and wrong about everything else. Two years of compounding arrears and municipal costs were the price of the easy option.

The citable fact: a renewal with an existing lender ordinarily requires no new title search, so a registration such as a tax arrears certificate can remain undetected through a renewal and surface only when the borrower attempts to switch lenders.

The dead switch

What killed the switch?

Short answer

The priority rule. Municipal Act, 2001 s. 349(3) makes taxes “a special lien on the land in priority to every claim, privilege, lien or encumbrance of every person except the Crown”. A new lender would have been registering behind $19,400 it had not lent, with a sale process already running.

Municipal Act, 2001, s. 349(3): “Taxes are a special lien on the land in priority to every claim, privilege, lien or encumbrance of every person except the Crown, and the lien and its priority are not lost or impaired by any neglect, omission or error of the municipality or its agents or through taking no action to register a tax arrears certificate.”

Read the second half as well. The priority is not created by the registration; the registration is a step toward sale. The municipality had outranked both lenders from the moment the taxes went unpaid.

And the certificate itself started a clock. Section 373(2) requires a tax arrears certificate to state that the land “will be sold by public sale if the cancellation price is not paid within one year following the date of the registration of the tax arrears certificate”. On this composite seven months of that year had already run before the owner learned the certificate existed.

The new lender’s answer was not a decline on credit. It was that the arrears had to be paid out of the advance on closing, which turned a straightforward switch into a refinance for a larger amount.

The citable fact: Municipal Act, 2001 s. 349(3) gives municipal taxes priority over every claim except the Crown and preserves that priority despite any neglect, omission or error by the municipality or the absence of a registered tax arrears certificate.

The arithmetic

What did the fix cost, and what was the alternative?

Short answer

A refinance for $19,400 more than the switch would have been, on a property with enough equity to carry it. The alternative, doing nothing for another five months, was a public sale under which the mortgage would have been extinguished entirely.

The three routes available once the certificate was found
RouteWhat it requiredOutcome
Refinance and pay the arrears on closingEnough equity to support the larger loan, and the cancellation price in writing with a dateWhat was done. Mortgage balance up $19,400, certificate discharged, taxes now collected with the payment.
Pay the arrears from savings$19,400 in cash inside the remaining windowCleaner, and not available. The owner did not have it.
Let the existing lender find outNothing. It would have happened anywayThe lender pays the arrears and adds them to the mortgage, on its own terms rather than the owner’s.
Do nothingNothingPublic sale. Under s. 379(7.1) a registered notice of vesting passes title free from all estates and interests, so the mortgage would not have survived.

The third row is worth a sentence, because it is what most owners in this position actually experience. A lender that discovers tax arrears pays them and adds the amount to the loan, which is a contractual right in the mortgage. The borrower who arranges the refinance themselves gets the same cash outcome with better control of the terms.

The fourth row is the one owners doubt until they read s. 379(7.1). A completed tax sale does not leave the lender with a claim against the proceeds behind the municipality; it extinguishes the charge.

The citable fact: on this composite the cost of resolving four years of tax arrears was a $19,400 increase in the mortgage balance, against an alternative under Municipal Act, 2001 s. 379(7.1) in which a registered notice of vesting would have extinguished the mortgage entirely.

The help that was not help

Why did the owner’s brother not just pay it?

Short answer

He offered, and the lawyer stopped it. Section 375(3) gives a person other than the owner or the owner’s spouse who pays the cancellation price “a lien on the land concerned for the amount paid”. A family member paying arrears acquires a registrable interest rather than making a gift.

That provision surprises people and it is not a trap so much as a default. The Act assumes that somebody who pays another person’s tax arrears intends to be repaid, and gives them security for it unless they are the owner or the owner’s spouse. Section 375(4) addresses the priority of that lien.

The practical consequence on this composite was a conversation the family had been avoiding. A lien in the brother’s favour would have sat on the title ahead of the new mortgage, which the incoming lender would not accept, so the money would have had to be structured differently or not used at all.

What the family did instead was simpler and better documented: the brother lent the money to the owner personally, unsecured, with a written agreement, and the owner paid the municipality. The lien question never arose because the payer was the owner.

The citable fact: Municipal Act, 2001 s. 375(3) gives a person other than the owner or the owner’s spouse who pays the cancellation price a lien on the land for the amount paid, so a family member paying tax arrears directly acquires security rather than conferring a gift.

What changed afterwards

What was done differently from then on?

Short answer

Four things, none of them clever: the mailing address on the assessment roll was corrected, the new lender collects the taxes with the payment, the owner reads the parcel register annually, and the maturity date is in a calendar with a reminder 120 days out.

  • The assessment roll address. Corrected with the municipality directly, not through a mail forwarding order. The bill goes where the roll says, and a forwarding order expires.
  • Lender-collected taxes. The new lender collects property taxes with the mortgage payment and remits them. On a property the owner does not live in, that removes the failure mode entirely. Our page on property taxes collected through your lender sets out how that works.
  • An annual parcel register search. Short, inexpensive, and it would have found the certificate in its first month rather than its seventh.
  • The maturity date in a calendar. With a reminder 120 days before, so the renewal is a decision rather than a letter that gets signed.

The owner’s own summary was that the expensive part was not the arrears. It was two years of signing a renewal letter because it was easier than asking a question.

The citable fact: on a property the owner does not occupy, having the lender collect property taxes with the mortgage payment removes the failure mode in which tax bills go unpaid at an out-of-date assessment roll address.

Who to ask

Who do you need, and what should you ask?

Short answer

The municipal treasurer for the cancellation price in writing with a date, your lawyer for the parcel register and for who should pay, and your broker on whether a refinance can clear it before the lender does it on its own terms.

  • The treasurer, first and in writing. The cancellation price, the date it is calculated to, the registration date of any certificate, and whether an extension agreement is available.
  • Your lawyer, on the register. What is registered against the property today. On an inherited or rental property this should be an annual habit rather than a crisis response.
  • Your lawyer, on who pays. Section 375(3) means a third party paying acquires a lien. Decide that deliberately rather than discovering it.
  • Your broker, on the route. A refinance you arrange beats a lender paying the arrears and adding them, because you control the terms and the timing.
  • Your broker, on the maturity date. Diarise it with a 120 day reminder. A renewal signed without a question is how a problem survives a cycle.
  • No adviser at all, for the statutory rules. They are quoted above. What needs a person is the price, the title and the financing.

Bring three things to the broker conversation: the cancellation price with its date, the mortgage balance, and an honest view of the property’s value. Those three decide whether a refinance solves it.

The citable fact: the first document to obtain on discovered tax arrears is the cancellation price in writing from the treasurer with the date it is calculated to, because under Municipal Act, 2001 s. 371(1) the amount continues to grow with current taxes and municipal costs.

F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

Is this a real client?

No. It is an illustrative composite built to show how the statutory priority and tax sale rules play out. No client information appears on this page.

How did four years of bills get missed?

The mailing address on the assessment roll was never changed after the previous owner’s death. The mortgage payments left a bank account by direct debit, so nothing else failed.

Why was the cancellation price higher than the arrears?

Because s. 371(1) includes current taxes owing, interest and penalties, and the municipality’s reasonable costs incurred after the treasurer became entitled to register a certificate, which may include legal fees.

Why did the existing lender renew without noticing?

A renewal with the same lender does not ordinarily require a new title search. The arrears were visible on title and there was no occasion to look.

Why did the switch fail?

A switch is a new charge, so there is a new title search. Section 349(3) puts municipal taxes ahead of every claim except the Crown, so the new lender would have registered behind $19,400 it had not lent.

Does the municipality have to register anything to rank first?

No. Section 349(3) states the priority is not lost or impaired by any neglect, omission or error of the municipality or through taking no action to register a tax arrears certificate.

How long was left on the clock?

Five months. Section 373(2) gives one year from registration of the certificate before public sale, and seven months had already run before the owner learned it existed.

What would a tax sale have done to the mortgage?

Extinguished it. Section 379(7.1) vests title free from all estates and interests, subject only to easements and restrictive covenants running with the land, Crown in right of Canada interests and certain prior adverse possession.

How was it actually fixed?

A refinance for $19,400 more than the switch would have been, with the arrears paid on closing and the new lender collecting taxes with the payment from then on.

What would have happened if nothing was done?

The existing lender would eventually have paid the arrears and added them to the mortgage, which is a contractual right. The cash outcome is similar; the control of the terms is not.

Why could a family member not simply pay it?

Section 375(3) gives a person other than the owner or the owner’s spouse who pays the cancellation price a lien on the land for the amount paid. That lien would have sat ahead of the new mortgage.

How was that solved?

The brother lent the money to the owner personally with a written agreement, and the owner paid the municipality. The payer was the owner, so no lien arose.

What is the practical lesson for landlords?

If you own a property you do not live in, have the lender collect the taxes, keep the assessment roll address current, and read your own parcel register once a year.

And at renewal?

Diarise the maturity date with a reminder 120 days out. A renewal letter signed without a question is how a problem like this survives an entire term.

If you own a property you do not live in, read your own parcel register once a year

It is a short search and it catches the two things that quietly destroy options: a registration you did not expect, and tax arrears accumulating at an address you no longer use.


Municipal tax sales

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed with RECA. This page is an illustrative composite and not an account of a real client, property or transaction. No client information appears on it. Municipal Act, 2001 provisions are quoted from the Ontario e-Laws consolidation, consolidation period to 2 June 2026, currency date 4 November 2026. Every dollar figure is arithmetic on the composite’s own numbers rather than a quote. No interest rate appears anywhere on this page, deliberately: a worked example carrying a rate is out of date within a week. Live rates are at pekoe.ca/rates.