Ontario’s Mortgages Act s. 6(1) says insurance money payable to a mortgagor “shall, if the mortgagee so requires, be applied by the mortgagor in making good the loss or damage”. Section 6(2) goes further: a mortgagee “may require that all money received on an insurance of the mortgaged property be applied in or towards the discharge of the money due under the mortgagee’s mortgage”.
Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.
Your lender, within the limits of the statute and your own mortgage. Section 6(1) of the Mortgages Act lets the mortgagee require the money be applied to making good the loss. Section 6(2) lets the mortgagee require it be applied to discharging the mortgage instead. Those are two different outcomes and the choice is not the borrower’s.
Mortgages Act, s. 6(1): “All money payable to a mortgagor on an insurance of the mortgaged property, including effects, whether affixed to the freehold or not, being or forming part thereof, shall, if the mortgagee so requires, be applied by the mortgagor in making good the loss or damage in respect of which the money is received.”
Section 6(2): “Without prejudice to any obligation to the contrary imposed by law or by special contract, a mortgagee may require that all money received on an insurance of the mortgaged property be applied in or towards the discharge of the money due under the mortgagee’s mortgage.”
Read the two together. The first is the rebuild outcome and the second is the pay-down outcome, and in each case the operative words are “if the mortgagee so requires” and “a mortgagee may require”. The statute allocates the decision to the lender.
“Without prejudice to any obligation to the contrary imposed by law or by special contract” is the qualifier that matters. Your own mortgage document can say something different, and in practice most residential mortgages set out a process. So the statute is the floor rather than the whole answer, and the document is where to look next.
The citable fact: Mortgages Act s. 6(1) permits a mortgagee to require insurance money to be applied in making good the loss, and s. 6(2) permits a mortgagee to require it be applied towards discharging the mortgage, subject to any contrary obligation imposed by law or by special contract.
Because its security has been destroyed and a rebuild is a project with execution risk. Where the loan to value was already high, or the borrower’s income has changed, or the rebuild is uneconomic, a lender may prefer a smaller loan on a cleared lot to a larger loan on a construction project.
From the lender’s position the arithmetic is simple. A fire converts a house into an insurance claim and a lot. Rebuilding converts the claim back into a house, over months, through a builder, with cost overruns and lien risk. Paying down converts it into a reduced balance immediately.
| Factor | Points toward rebuilding | Points toward pay-down |
|---|---|---|
| Loan to value before the loss | Low, with equity to absorb overruns | High, with little room |
| Settlement amount against replacement cost | Full replacement cost settled | Actual cash value, or a shortfall |
| Borrower’s income and payment history | Strong and current | Changed, or already in arrears |
| Builder and plan | Named builder, firm price, permits in hand | No builder, no price, no permits |
| Whether the property can be rebuilt at all | Zoning and setbacks permit the same dwelling | A legal non-conforming use that cannot be reinstated |
The last row is the one owners rarely anticipate. A building that was legally non-conforming, a cottage sited closer to the water than today’s setbacks allow for instance, may not be rebuildable as it stood. That is a municipal and conservation authority question, and it changes the value of the lot and therefore the lender’s view.
The citable fact: where a destroyed dwelling was a legal non-conforming use, the right to rebuild it as it stood is a municipal planning question rather than an insurance one, and the answer affects whether a lender prefers reconstruction or pay-down.
So that the insurer pays it rather than you, to the extent of its interest. Every lender requires property insurance in force at funding with itself named, and that naming is what makes the s. 6 choice practical rather than theoretical.
Three practical consequences follow from being a named loss payee, and borrowers meet all three at the worst possible moment.
And underinsurance is the quiet problem. A policy written years ago on a replacement cost that has not been revisited can settle well below what rebuilding costs today. The shortfall lands on the borrower, and a lender facing a shortfall is a lender more likely to take s. 6(2) and reduce the loan.
Reviewing the replacement cost on your policy every few years is the cheapest risk management available to a homeowner, and it is a conversation with your insurance broker rather than with us.
The citable fact: a residential mortgage requires property insurance to be maintained with the lender’s interest noted, so a lapse in coverage is a breach of the mortgage and a settlement below the cost of rebuilding leaves a shortfall the borrower carries.
Differently, because the corporation insures the units and the common elements rather than you. Condominium Act, 1998 s. 99(1) requires the corporation to obtain and maintain insurance “on its own behalf and on behalf of the owners” for damage caused by major perils, and s. 99(4) excludes improvements made to a unit.
Section 99(2) defines major perils as “the perils of fire, lightning, smoke, windstorm, hail, explosion, water escape, strikes, riots or civil commotion, impact by aircraft or vehicles, vandalism or malicious acts.”
Section 99(3) adds a protection that is easy to miss: “An exclusion in the insurance required by this section is not effective with respect to damage resulting from faulty or improper material, workmanship or design that would be insured, but for the exclusion.”
Section 99(4) is the gap owners have to fill themselves: “The obligation to insure under subsection (1) does not include insurance for damage to improvements made to a unit.” Your renovated kitchen is an improvement, and insuring it is your job.
And the proceeds route depends on the size of the loss. Section 100(1): “Despite anything contained in an insurance trust agreement that the corporation has entered into with an insurance trustee, if the proceeds of an insurance policy issued under section 99 are less than 15 per cent of the replacement cost of the property covered by the policy, the insurer shall pay the proceeds to the corporation or the person whom the corporation specifies.” Larger losses run through the insurance trust arrangement instead, and s. 100(2) governs the use of the proceeds once available.
| Property type | Who insures the building | Who receives the proceeds | Provision |
|---|---|---|---|
| Freehold house | The owner, with the lender’s interest noted | The insurer pays the lender to the extent of its interest; application is the mortgagee’s choice | Mortgages Act s. 6(1) and (2) |
| Condominium unit and common elements | The corporation, on its own behalf and on behalf of the owners | The corporation, where proceeds are under 15% of replacement cost; otherwise through the insurance trust | Condominium Act, 1998 ss. 99(1), 100(1) |
| Improvements made to a unit | The owner. The corporation’s obligation does not extend to them | The owner’s own policy | Condominium Act, 1998 s. 99(4) |
| The corporation’s deductible | Shared as a common expense, or charged to the unit | Charged to the owner’s unit where the damage came from the owner, a lessee or a permitted resident | Condominium Act, 1998 s. 105(1) and (2) |
Our page on the common expense lien covers what happens to the deductible, which is the part of a condominium loss most likely to land on an individual owner.
The citable fact: Condominium Act, 1998 s. 99(1) requires the corporation to insure the units and common elements against major perils on its own behalf and on behalf of the owners, while s. 99(4) excludes damage to improvements made to a unit, which the owner must insure.
Report the claim, call the lender, keep paying the mortgage, and make no commitment to a builder until the lender has said in writing whether the proceeds are going to a rebuild or to the loan.
Where the lender does fund a rebuild, expect it to be administered like a construction loan: draws against progress, inspections, and a holdback. Our construction lien page explains why the holdback exists and why a lender stops advancing on notice of a lien.
The citable fact: because Mortgages Act s. 6 allocates the choice between rebuilding and discharging the mortgage to the mortgagee, a homeowner should obtain the lender’s written position on the application of insurance proceeds before entering into a construction contract.
Your insurance broker on the settlement and the replacement cost, your lender on which way the proceeds go, your municipality on whether you can rebuild as it was, and your broker on what a reduced balance or a rebuild does to your mortgage.
Bring three things to the lender conversation: the adjuster’s file number, the settlement figure if known, and a straight answer on whether you intend to rebuild. The third is what the lender is deciding around.
The citable fact: whether a policy settles on replacement cost or actual cash value determines the size of any shortfall after a total loss, and a shortfall makes a lender more likely to exercise the Mortgages Act s. 6(2) right to apply proceeds to the mortgage debt.
The mortgagee, within the statute and your own mortgage. Section 6(1) lets it require the money go to making good the loss; s. 6(2) lets it require the money go towards discharging the mortgage.
Section 6(2) permits a mortgagee to require that all money received on an insurance of the mortgaged property be applied in or towards discharging the money due under its mortgage.
It can. Section 6(2) is expressed “without prejudice to any obligation to the contrary imposed by law or by special contract”, so your document is where to look next.
Because a rebuild carries execution risk. A high loan to value, a settlement below replacement cost, changed income, or no builder and no permits all push toward pay-down.
Then the rebuild option may not exist. A legal non-conforming building, for instance one sited closer to water than current setbacks allow, is a municipal planning question rather than an insurance one.
So the insurer pays it, to the extent of its interest. That naming is what makes the statutory choice practical, and it means the cheque is not simply yours to direct.
Yes. A loss does not suspend the obligation. If the payment is going to be difficult, ask for relief before the payment date rather than after.
That is a breach of the mortgage. A lender that discovers it will usually place its own coverage and charge you for it, and the cost is not competitive.
Underinsurance. A replacement cost set years ago and never revisited can settle well below today’s rebuild cost, and the shortfall lands on the borrower.
The corporation insures the units and common elements against major perils, on its own behalf and on behalf of the owners, under Condominium Act, 1998 s. 99(1).
Section 99(2): fire, lightning, smoke, windstorm, hail, explosion, water escape, strikes, riots or civil commotion, impact by aircraft or vehicles, vandalism or malicious acts.
No. Section 99(4) excludes insurance for damage to improvements made to a unit. Insuring those is the owner’s job.
Where the proceeds are less than 15 per cent of the replacement cost of the covered property, s. 100(1) requires the insurer to pay them to the corporation or whom it specifies. Larger losses run through the insurance trust arrangement.
Report the claim, call your lender the same week, keep paying the mortgage, and sign no construction contract until the lender has confirmed in writing where the proceeds are going.
The statute gives the mortgagee the choice between rebuilding and paying down, and a contractor engaged before that conversation is a commitment made on an assumption. One call settles which it will be.
Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed with RECA. Statutory wording is quoted from the Mortgages Act and the Condominium Act, 1998 (Ontario, e-Laws, consolidation periods to 1 January 2022 and 31 December 2025 respectively, currency date 4 November 2026). Your own mortgage and your own policy may say more than the statute does, and both govern on their own terms. This is a mortgage page and not insurance advice. No interest rate appears on this page. Live rates are at pekoe.ca/rates.