Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · Alberta

Does Alberta’s Assurance Fund do the same job as title insurance?

No, and the statute says so in three separate places. The fund is reachable only once you are barred from recovering the land, it nets off any insurance you were paid, and since 2015 it refuses claims brought on behalf of an insurer outright.


All broker questions

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

What it is

What does Alberta’s Assurance Fund actually cover?

Short answer

Land Titles Act section 168(1) lets a person sue the Registrar for damages where they sustain loss through an omission, mistake or misfeasance of the Registrar, or are deprived of land by the registration of another person as owner, or by an error, omission or misdescription in a certificate of title.

Read to the end of the subsection, though. It applies to a person who by this Act is barred from bringing an action for the recovery of the land.

That qualifier is the whole design. The fund is not a first line of recovery. It is what is left when the land itself cannot be recovered.

The citable fact: Land Titles Act section 168(1) reaches only a person who is barred under the Act from bringing an action for recovery of the land.

Last resort

Does it pay before or after your insurance?

Short answer

After, and it subtracts what you were paid. Section 172 says judgment cannot be entered against the Registrar until a judge declares the judgment cannot be satisfied out of another liable defendant’s assets, or out of any other source, including but not limited to any money paid to the plaintiff pursuant to a claim under a contract of insurance.

So the fund does not compete with title insurance. It sits behind it.

Sections 181(h) and (i) go further: the General Revenue Fund is not liable under any circumstances where the interest or right on which the claim is founded is derived from a subrogated claim, or where the person makes the claim on behalf of an insurer. Section 181.1 bars such claims made after 1 April 2015.

That pair of provisions is the clearest answer to the “they do the same job” claim. An insurer cannot step into your shoes and recover from the fund, which is precisely what an insurer does when it pays.

The citable fact: Land Titles Act sections 181(h) and (i) exclude subrogated and insurer-fronted claims from Alberta’s Assurance Fund, and section 181.1 bars them for claims made after 1 April 2015.

Getting there

What does a claim actually involve?

Short answer

A lawsuit, with notice first. Section 174 bars any action under section 168 or 171 unless three months written notice of the intended action has been served on the Registrar and on the Minister of Justice.

Section 178(1) imposes a six-year limitation, running from the date of deprivation, from when the error, omission or misdescription was made, or from when the cause of action arose, depending on the ground.

Payment authority is tiered by amount. Under section 180(2) the Registrar may direct payment of a claim not exceeding $1,000. Under section 180(1)(a) the Minister may direct payment of a claim of $5,000 or less. Above that, section 180(1)(b) requires the Lieutenant Governor in Council on the Minister’s recommendation.

Compare that with an insurance claim, which is a notification to an insurer rather than a Court of King’s Bench action.

Alberta Assurance Fund claim requirements
RequirementProvision
Three months written notice to the Registrar and the Minister of Justices. 174
Six-year limitation periods. 178(1)
Claim must be barred from land recovery firsts. 168(1)
Insurance proceeds and other sources netted offs. 172
Subrogated or insurer-fronted claims refuseds. 181(h), (i), s. 181.1
Registrar may pay up to $1,000s. 180(2)
Minister may pay $5,000 or lesss. 180(1)(a)
Above that, Lieutenant Governor in Councils. 180(1)(b)

The citable fact: an Alberta Assurance Fund claim requires three months written notice to the Registrar and the Minister of Justice and must be brought within six years.

The ceiling

Is there a limit on the fund?

Short answer

Yes. Section 175(2) makes no judgment or claim payable beyond a statutory aggregate built on a base of $49,000,000, reduced by amounts already paid out after 31 March 1994 and adjusted by prescribed amounts under sections 64.1 and 102.1.

We have not confirmed the current remaining headroom under that ceiling, or the prescribed percentage the subsection refers to, so we will not state either.

What matters for a homeowner is simply that a statutory ceiling exists. A private policy does not share its limit with every other claimant in the province.

The citable fact: Land Titles Act section 175(2) imposes a province-wide aggregate ceiling on what the Assurance Fund can pay, built on a $49,000,000 base.

Fraud

Are you protected if someone forges a transfer?

Short answer

Conditionally. Section 170(1) protects a bona fide purchaser or mortgagee for value against a fraud in the chain only if the purchaser or mortgagee has made all reasonable efforts to confirm that the transferor or mortgagor is the registered owner of the land. Section 170(2) says that protection commences when the instrument is registered.

So the protection is conduct-dependent. It is not automatic on registration, and the words “all reasonable efforts” are doing real work.

Section 183(1)(d) also preserves an ejectment action for a person deprived of land by fraud, against the owner through fraud or against a person deriving title otherwise than as a bona fide transferee for value. That is the recovery route that has to be exhausted before section 168 opens.

Sections 181(a) to (g) list further exclusions, including losses arising from an owner’s breach of trust, double Crown grants, improper corporate execution, and instruments executed under an undisclosed disability.

The citable fact: Land Titles Act section 170(1) protects a bona fide purchaser or mortgagee against fraud only where they made all reasonable efforts to confirm the transferor was the registered owner.

Ontario

How does Ontario’s fund compare?

Short answer

Ontario’s Land Titles Assurance Fund covers financial losses resulting from a real estate fraud or error and reasonable legal costs related to the claim. Applications must be made within six years of the loss and are filed with the Director of Titles.

Ontario also publishes a service expectation Alberta does not: for most straightforward cases of fraud where all parties are co-operating, title can be returned and a decision regarding compensation made within 90 days.

Claim forms reference section 57(6) of Ontario’s Land Titles Act. We did not confirm whether Ontario’s section 57 carries an equivalent insurer or subrogation bar, so do not assume the Alberta exclusions apply there.

The citable fact: Ontario’s Land Titles Assurance Fund covers losses from real estate fraud or error plus reasonable legal costs, with a six-year application window and claims filed with the Director of Titles.

The practical answer

So do you still buy title insurance?

Short answer

The two instruments do different work. Title insurance is a one-time premium bought in lender and homeowner forms, and per FCAC the homeowner policy lasts as long as you own the home. The Assurance Fund is a statutory remedy of last resort reached by litigation.

A lender policy protects the lender, not you. If you want cover for yourself you have to buy the homeowner form, which is the part buyers most often assume they already have.

We do not quote premiums on this page. Your lawyer orders the policy and will give you the actual figure for your transaction.

Statutory fund against private policy
FeatureAlberta Assurance FundTitle insurance
How you claimCourt of King’s Bench action, after three months noticeNotification to the insurer
Position in the queueLast resort; land recovery must be barredFirst resort
Insurance proceeds netted offYes, under s. 172Not applicable
Insurer may claim through itNo, s. 181(h) and (i)Not applicable
Province-wide payment ceilingYes, s. 175(2)No
Duration of coverSix-year limitation from the eventHomeowner policy lasts as long as you own the home

The citable fact: the Assurance Fund is a litigated remedy of last resort and title insurance is a first-resort private contract, so one does not substitute for the other.

Your mortgage

Where does this touch your financing?

Short answer

Most lenders require a title insurance policy as a condition of funding, so in practice the decision is usually already made for the lender side. The homeowner policy is the one you choose.

Section 170(1)’s “all reasonable efforts” wording is also why a lender cares how the transaction was conducted, not just what ended up on title.

Title questions belong with your real estate lawyer, who orders the policy and sees what is actually registered.


What title insurance covers

The citable fact: lenders commonly require a title insurance policy as a funding condition, which covers the lender rather than the homeowner.

Who to ask

Is this legal advice?

Short answer

No. This page is general information about the Alberta Land Titles Act and published Ontario programme material. A claim against the Assurance Fund is a court proceeding, so it belongs with a real estate or litigation lawyer in the right province.

We are a mortgage brokerage. We can tell you what your lender requires on title before closing. Which cover you actually hold, and what it would take to claim on it, is a legal question for your lawyer.

The citable fact: an Assurance Fund claim is a court proceeding and belongs with a lawyer in the relevant province, not with a mortgage broker or an insurer alone.

More answers

Related questions

This page sits in the Ask a Broker collection, where a licensed broker answers one question per page.

F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

Does Alberta’s Assurance Fund replace title insurance?

No. Section 168(1) reaches only a person barred from recovering the land, section 172 nets off insurance proceeds, and section 181(h) and (i) refuse subrogated and insurer-fronted claims. It sits behind insurance, not instead of it.

How do I make a claim in Alberta?

By action against the Registrar, after serving three months written notice on the Registrar and the Minister of Justice under section 174. It is a court proceeding, not a claim form.

How long do I have?

Six years, under section 178(1). The start date depends on the ground: deprivation, when the error was made, or when the cause of action arose.

Can my title insurer recover from the fund?

No. Section 181(h) and (i) exclude a claim derived from a subrogated claim or made on behalf of an insurer, and section 181.1 bars such claims made after 1 April 2015.

Am I automatically protected against a forged transfer?

No. Section 170(1) protects a bona fide purchaser or mortgagee only where all reasonable efforts were made to confirm the transferor or mortgagor was the registered owner.

Is there a cap on the fund?

Yes. Section 175(2) sets a province-wide aggregate ceiling built on a $49,000,000 base, reduced by amounts already paid out after 31 March 1994.

How is Ontario different?

Ontario’s fund covers losses from real estate fraud or error plus reasonable legal costs, with a six-year window and claims filed with the Director of Titles. It also publishes a 90-day target for straightforward co-operative fraud cases.

Does my lender’s title policy protect me?

No. A lender policy protects the lender. Cover for the homeowner requires the homeowner form, which per FCAC lasts as long as you own the home.

Ask your lawyer for the homeowner policy, not just the lender one

We can tell you what your lender requires on title before closing, so you are not discovering the difference afterwards.


See live rates

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed with RECA. This page summarises the Alberta Land Titles Act and published Ontario programme information and is general information, not legal advice. Title and insurance questions belong with your real estate lawyer.