Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · Offers and financing conditions

The appraisal came in below what you agreed to pay. What happens now?

Your lender is not being difficult. A federal regulation defines the value it may lend against, and that definition contains a sentence most borrowers never see: where the loan is for a purchase, “the value must not exceed the purchase price of the property”. There is a ceiling and no floor, which is exactly why a low appraisal costs you cash and a high one gives you nothing.


All broker questions

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

The sentence that decides it

Why can the lender not simply use the price you agreed?

Short answer

Because the regulation that defines what it may lend against caps that figure at the purchase price and sets no floor under it. The number the lender works from is the lower of the appraised value and the price, every time.

The Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations define the “value of the eligible residential property” as “the value that is ascribed to an eligible residential property by a mortgage or hypothecary lender or a mortgage insurer for the purpose of granting or insuring a mortgage or hypothecary loan and that is verified using a method that is generally accepted by prudent lenders, insurers or professional residential property appraisers”.

Then the sentence that answers the question: “If the purpose of the loan includes the purchase of the property, the value must not exceed (a) the purchase price of the property; or (b) the purchase price of the property plus the estimated cost to the borrower of planned improvements to the property, if the purpose of the loan also includes those improvements.”

Read it as a pair of brackets with only one side built. The purchase price is a ceiling on value. Nothing in the definition says value may not fall below the price. So an appraisal above the price is discarded, and an appraisal below it becomes the operative number.

That asymmetry is not your lender’s choice and it is not negotiable at the branch. It is how the instrument is drafted, and it applies across the lenders inside the framework.

The citable fact: the Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations provide that where the purpose of a loan includes the purchase of the property, the value of the property must not exceed the purchase price, so the operative figure is the lower of the appraised value and the price.

The Act agrees

Does the Bank Act say price or value?

Short answer

Value, and it says so twice in one sentence. The statutory lending restriction is expressed as a percentage of “the value of the property at the time of the loan”. The purchase price does not appear in it.

Section 418(1) of the Bank Act provides that a bank “shall not make a loan in Canada on the security of residential property in Canada for the purpose of purchasing, renovating or improving that property, or refinance such a loan, if the amount of the loan, together with the amount then outstanding of any mortgage having an equal or prior claim against the property, would exceed 80 per cent of the value of the property at the time of the loan“.

Subsection 418(2)(b) is the exception everybody actually uses: the restriction does not apply where repayment of the amount above that ceiling “is guaranteed or insured by a government agency or a private insurer approved by the Superintendent”.

So the chain is complete. The Act measures the loan against value. The Regulations define value and cap it at the purchase price on a purchase. There is no point in the chain where the price you negotiated raises the number.

Why that matters practically: the shortfall is not a lender’s opinion you can argue with, and it is not a problem that a different bank solves by being friendlier. Every participant is working from the same definition.

The citable fact: subsection 418(1) of the Bank Act expresses the residential lending restriction as 80 per cent of the value of the property at the time of the loan, and subsection 418(2)(b) excepts amounts above that where repayment is insured or guaranteed.

Who looked at the house

Why was there no interior inspection?

Short answer

Because the Regulations list four acceptable ways to verify value and only one of them involves a person walking through the property. A drive-by appraisal is named in the instrument by that term.

Subsection 1(2) is explicit: “generally accepted methods of verifying value include (a) the use of a statistically reliable and up-to-date valuation model that assesses the value’s reasonableness; (b) a fair-market-value appraisal by a professional residential property appraiser who is independent of the borrower; (c) a drive-by appraisal; or (d) a review of the value of comparable properties.”

The four methods of verifying value named in subsection 1(2)
MethodWhat it involvesWhen it tends to be used
Automated valuation modelA statistical model assessing the reasonableness of the valueStrong files on common property types in active markets
Full appraisalA fair-market-value appraisal by an appraiser independent of the borrowerUnusual properties, refinances, files where the model declines
Drive-by appraisalAn exterior inspection, named in the regulation by that termWhere the exterior and comparables are enough to confirm the range
Comparables reviewA review of the value of comparable propertiesSupporting or testing another method’s number

Two things worth noticing in paragraph (b). The appraiser must be “independent of the borrower”, which is why you cannot commission your own appraiser and expect the number to be accepted, and why the report usually belongs to the lender rather than to you.

And the four methods are listed as examples, introduced by “include”. A method not on the list is not automatically excluded, provided it is generally accepted by prudent lenders, insurers or professional appraisers.

The citable fact: subsection 1(2) of the Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations names an automated valuation model, a fair-market-value appraisal by an appraiser independent of the borrower, a drive-by appraisal and a review of comparable properties as generally accepted methods of verifying value.

The arithmetic

How much more cash does a low appraisal cost you?

Short answer

The whole gap, plus the share of the gap your down payment percentage would have covered. The shortfall lands on you in cash, not on the loan, because the loan is a percentage of the lower number.

Work it as percentages rather than guessing. The loan is capped at a percentage of value. Value has fallen to the appraised figure. The price you owe the seller has not moved. The difference between what you owe and what can be advanced is cash you have to find.

Two consequences follow, and the second one surprises people.

First, the gap itself is yours. If the appraisal lands below the price, you make up that difference on top of the down payment you had already planned for.

Second, your down payment percentage is now measured against a smaller number, so the dollar amount the lender requires from you changes too. A file that was comfortably inside an insured tier can land outside it, and the tiers are set out in paragraph 5(1)(a) and on our insured down payment calculator.

One detail that works in your favour, from subsection 1(3): “the principal amount of a loan does not include any mortgage or hypothecary insurance premiums.” A financed premium does not count against the principal for these purposes.

The citable fact: because the loan is capped at a percentage of the lower of appraised value and purchase price, an appraisal shortfall is funded by the buyer in cash, and subsection 1(3) provides that the principal amount of a loan does not include any insurance premiums.

No condition

What if you already waived the financing condition?

Short answer

Then the shortfall is a contract problem rather than a mortgage problem, and it belongs with a real estate lawyer the same day. A firm agreement does not become conditional because the appraisal disappointed you.

We are going to be careful here, because this is the part of the question where bad advice is expensive. A waived financing condition means you have agreed to complete without a financing escape. The appraisal coming in low does not reopen that.

What a brokerage can do is work the financing side hard and fast: a different lender with a different verification method, a larger down payment if funds exist, a co-signer, or alternative lending to complete and refinance later. Each of those is a real route and each has a cost.

What a brokerage cannot do is tell you what happens to your deposit or what the seller may claim if you do not close. That is a legal question about your agreement and your province, and it needs a lawyer rather than a web page. Get one on the phone the day you learn the number.

The better version of this problem is the one you avoid. The length and drafting of a financing condition is the most useful lever a buyer controls, and it is covered on how long a financing condition should run and extending a financing condition.

The citable fact: a low appraisal does not revive a waived financing condition, and the consequences of failing to complete a firm agreement are a matter for a real estate lawyer rather than a mortgage brokerage.

Pushing back

Can you challenge the appraisal?

Short answer

You can ask for a review, and what gets one reconsidered is a factual error rather than a difference of opinion. Commissioning your own appraiser is usually wasted money, because the regulation requires independence from the borrower.

Paragraph 1(2)(b) is the reason. The accepted method is “a fair-market-value appraisal by a professional residential property appraiser who is independent of the borrower“. An appraisal you order and pay for is, on its face, not that.

What can move a number is information the appraiser did not have. A comparable sale that closed after the report date. A finished basement or an addition recorded nowhere. A comparable the report used that is materially different from the subject in a way that can be shown rather than argued. Put it in writing, through your broker, to the lender.

What will not move a number is your view that the market is stronger than the report says, or the fact that you are prepared to pay more. The second one in particular is already accounted for: the price you agreed is the ceiling on value, so your willingness to pay cannot raise it.

And the other lever is a different lender with a different method. Subsection 1(2) permits four, so a file declined on an automated model is not necessarily declined on a full appraisal.

The citable fact: an appraisal is only accepted where the appraiser is independent of the borrower, so a review succeeds on factual corrections rather than on an opposing opinion, and a different lender may verify value by one of the other methods in subsection 1(2).

The other direction

Does a high appraisal ever help you?

Short answer

Not on a purchase, by the terms of the definition. On a refinance it is the whole ballgame, because there is no purchase price to cap it.

The cap in the definition is conditional: it bites “if the purpose of the loan includes the purchase of the property”. A refinance of a property you already own does not include a purchase, so no price ceiling applies and value is whatever is properly verified.

That single difference explains a great deal of borrower confusion. The same appraisal that is useless on a purchase, because it exceeds the price, is the number that decides how much equity you can access a year later.

Which number governs, by purpose of the loan
Purpose of the loanWhich figure governsEffect of a high appraisal
PurchaseThe lower of appraised value and the purchase priceNone. The price is the ceiling
Purchase plus planned improvementsThe price plus the estimated cost of the planned improvements, as a ceilingRaises the ceiling only by the estimated improvement cost
Refinance of a property you ownThe verified value, with no price ceilingRaises the amount available

The improvements limb of the definition is worth knowing before you make an offer on a property you intend to renovate, because it changes what can be financed at the outset. The access side on a property you already own is on how much you can borrow against your home.

The citable fact: the purchase price ceiling in the value definition applies only where the purpose of the loan includes the purchase of the property, so on a refinance the verified value governs with no price cap.

Ontario and Alberta

Does the province change any of this?

Short answer

Not the valuation rule, which is federal and identical. What differs is the agreement you signed and what happens if you cannot complete, and that difference is large.

The Bank Act and the Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations apply the same way in Kitchener and in Canmore. The definition of value, the price ceiling, and the four verification methods do not vary by province.

The provincial layer is the contract and the remedy. The standard form agreement differs, the conveyancing differs, and the consequences of a failed closing differ. Alberta transactions also commonly turn on a Real Property Report with a municipal compliance stamp, which is a separate document from the appraisal and a separate way for a closing to go wrong: see the Real Property Report and compliance.

Pekoe is licensed in both provinces, Ontario with FSRA Licence #13321 and Alberta with RECA, so a file that moves between them stays with the same broker.

The citable fact: the federal valuation rule is identical in Ontario and Alberta, while the agreement of purchase and sale and the consequences of failing to complete are provincial.

Who to ask

Who do you call, in what order?

Short answer

Your broker first, because the financing options are time-sensitive. Your lawyer the same day if the condition is already waived. The appraiser’s review process only if you have a factual correction.

  • Your broker, first and immediately. Whether another lender would verify value differently, whether the file works with more down payment or a co-signer, and whether an alternative lender can complete it are all questions with a clock on them. Day one beats day five.
  • A real estate lawyer, the same day, if you waived the condition. What your agreement says about failing to close, and what exposure that creates, is legal advice. It should not be given to you informally, by us or anyone else.
  • The lender’s appraisal review, only with facts. A comparable that closed late, an unrecorded addition, a measurement error. Submit it in writing through your broker. An opinion that the number is too low will not be reconsidered.

Bring three things to the first call: the appraised figure, the agreed price, and the date your financing condition expires. Those three numbers determine which routes are still open.

Have a question? Chat with our team or AI assistant directly on pekoe.ca.

The citable fact: the financing routes after a low appraisal are time-limited and belong with a broker, the consequences of a waived condition belong with a real estate lawyer, and an appraisal review succeeds only on a factual correction.

Limits

What this page does not tell you

Short answer

What an appraisal costs, which lenders use which method, and what happens to your deposit. The first is a charge we do not publish, the second is lender policy, and the third is law about your contract.

Everything above comes from two federal instruments and describes how value is defined and verified. It does not describe any individual lender’s practice, and lenders differ markedly in when they order a full appraisal rather than relying on a model.

Nor have we put a figure on an appraisal. It is a charge, it varies by property and province, and a page explaining a rule is the wrong place for a price.

And the deposit question is the one to take seriously. A failed closing on a firm agreement can have consequences well beyond the deposit, and the answer depends on your agreement, your province and the seller’s position. That is a lawyer’s answer.

The citable fact: this page sets out the definition and verification of value in the Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations and the lending restriction in section 418 of the Bank Act, and does not address appraisal costs, individual lender practice or the consequences of a failed closing.

Worked example

What happens when the appraisal comes in $35,000 low?

Short answer

The lender sizes the loan on the lesser of the price and the appraised value, so the gap is yours in cash on top of your down payment. On a $700,000 agreement appraising at $665,000, a buyer planning 20% down finds $28,000 more is needed.

Show the math: $700,000 agreed, $665,000 appraised, 20% planned

Agreed purchase price$700,000
Appraised value$665,000
Planned down payment, 20% of price$140,000
Maximum lending, 80% of the appraised value$532,000
Extra cash the buyer must find$28,000

The citable fact: a lender lends against the lesser of price and appraised value, so a $35,000 shortfall on a $700,000 purchase costs the buyer $28,000 in additional cash at 80% lending.

F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

The appraisal came in low. Which number does the lender use?

The lower of the two. The Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations define the value of the property and provide that where the loan’s purpose includes a purchase, “the value must not exceed the purchase price”. The price is a ceiling on value, and nothing puts a floor under it.

Can I just put more money down?

That is usually the fastest route, where the funds exist. The loan is a percentage of the lower figure, so the gap is funded in cash. Bear in mind your down payment percentage is now measured against the smaller number, which can move the file between insured tiers.

Why did no inspector come inside?

Because three of the four methods the regulation names do not require it. Subsection 1(2) lists an automated valuation model, a full appraisal by an appraiser independent of the borrower, a drive-by appraisal, and a review of comparable properties.

Can I order my own appraisal and use that?

Generally no. The accepted method is an appraisal “by a professional residential property appraiser who is independent of the borrower”, and one you commission is not that. A factual correction submitted through your broker is the route that works.

What actually gets an appraisal reconsidered?

Information the appraiser did not have: a comparable sale that closed after the report date, an unrecorded addition or finished space, a measurement error, or a comparable that is materially different in a demonstrable way. Not a difference of opinion about the market.

I waived my financing condition. Can I get out of the deal?

Not because of the appraisal. A low appraisal does not revive a waived condition. Call a real estate lawyer the same day, because what happens if you cannot complete depends on your agreement and your province, and that is legal advice rather than mortgage advice.

Would a different lender give me a different number?

Possibly, because the regulation permits four verification methods and lenders differ in which they use and when. A file declined on an automated model is not necessarily declined on a full appraisal. That is worth exploring on day one of the condition.

Does an appraisal above the purchase price help me?

Not on a purchase. The price is the ceiling on value, so the excess is discarded. The only exception in the definition is where the loan also funds planned improvements, in which case the ceiling is the price plus their estimated cost.

So when does a high appraisal matter?

On a refinance. The price ceiling applies only where the purpose of the loan includes the purchase of the property, so on a refinance of a home you already own the verified value governs with no cap.

Does the insurance premium count against the loan amount?

No. Subsection 1(3) provides that “the principal amount of a loan does not include any mortgage or hypothecary insurance premiums” for the purposes of these Regulations.

Where does the 80 per cent come from?

Subsection 418(1) of the Bank Act, which restricts a residential loan to 80 per cent of “the value of the property at the time of the loan”. Subsection 418(2)(b) excepts amounts above that where repayment is insured or guaranteed.

Is this different in Ontario and Alberta?

The valuation rule is federal and identical. What differs is the agreement you signed, the conveyancing, and what happens if you cannot complete. In Alberta a Real Property Report with a compliance stamp is a separate document that can derail a closing for unrelated reasons.

If the number came back low, phone before you sign anything else

There are usually more options on day one of a financing condition than on day five, and more on day five than on the day the condition expires. The regulation does not move, but what can be arranged around it does.


Down payment calculator

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed with RECA. The Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations, SOR/2012-281, were read from the federal consolidation at laws-lois.justice.gc.ca, current to 19 October 2026 and last amended 27 February 2025. The Bank Act was read from the same consolidation. Every quotation on this page is from one of those two instruments. What this page is not. It is not advice about your own agreement of purchase and sale, and the consequences of failing to close are a question for a real estate lawyer rather than a brokerage. We have also not stated what an appraisal costs or what any lender will accept, because the first is a fee and the second is policy, and neither belongs on a page that is explaining a rule.