Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · Property tax and your mortgage

Your assessment is wrong: the deadline that decides whether you can do anything about it

Ontario’s Assessment Act gives a homeowner one route and it has to be taken first. Section 39.1(1.1) sets the request for reconsideration deadline at 31 March of the taxation year, and section 40(3) bars an appeal to the Assessment Review Board by anyone in the residential class who did not make that request in time. Miss the first date and the second door is closed.


All broker questions

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

What it decides

What does the assessment actually control?

Short answer

The tax, not the mortgage. The assessed current value is one half of the municipal tax calculation and the council’s rate is the other, and the tax figure is what a lender collects with your payment where taxes are included, and what the municipality can eventually recover ahead of your mortgage if they go unpaid.

So an assessment you think is too high is not an abstract grievance. It is a monthly number and, left alone, a priority claim against the property.

Two things follow for anyone with a mortgage.

If the lender collects your taxes, the collected amount follows the bill. A reassessment that raises the tax raises what the lender needs to collect, and the adjustment usually arrives as a change to the payment rather than as a letter explaining it.

If you pay the taxes yourself, the lender still cares. Unpaid municipal taxes rank ahead of a mortgage in Ontario, which is why most charge terms require the borrower to keep them current and allow the lender to pay them and add the amount to the loan.

The citable fact: an Ontario property assessment determines the tax rather than the mortgage, but because unpaid municipal taxes rank ahead of a registered mortgage, an assessment dispute is a mortgage question as soon as the bill goes unpaid.

The first door

What can you ask MPAC to reconsider, and by when?

Short answer

Anything that could ground an appeal. Assessment Act s. 39.1(1) lets the owner “request the assessment corporation to reconsider” any matter that could form the basis of an appeal under s. 40(1) or an application under s. 46, and s. 39.1(1.1) sets the deadline: “no later than March 31 of the taxation year in respect of which the request is made.”

Three variations on that deadline matter, and each is in the Act rather than in practice.

The request for reconsideration deadlines, Assessment Act s. 39.1
SituationDeadlineProvision
An ordinary taxation year31 March of that taxation years. 39.1(1.1)
The first year a general reassessment applies120 days after the issuance date on the notice of assessments. 39.1(1.2)
An omitted or supplementary assessment120 days after the issuance date on the notice of assessments. 39.1(3)
Where the time to return the roll was extended120 days after the return of the rolls. 39.1(2)

The request has a content requirement. Section 39.1(4): “The request must set out the basis for the person’s request and all relevant facts.” A request that says only that the number looks high has not met it.

And there is a clock on the answer, not only on the asking. Section 39.1(7) requires notice of the result “no later than 180 days after the request is made”, and where the assessment corporation gives notice inside those 180 days that it needs an extension, “no later than 240 days after the request is made.”

The citable fact: Assessment Act s. 39.1(1.1) sets the request for reconsideration deadline at 31 March of the taxation year, with a 120 day alternative in a general reassessment year under s. 39.1(1.2) and for an omitted or supplementary assessment under s. 39.1(3).

The precondition

Can a homeowner go straight to the Board?

Short answer

No. Section 40(3) says that for property in the residential, farm or managed forests property class, “no appeal may be brought to the Assessment Review Board under subsection (1) by a person who is entitled to make a request for reconsideration under section 39.1 in respect of the property, if the person has not made the request within the time required under that section.”

That is the sentence most worth reading twice, because it is the one that ends most arguments before they start. The reconsideration is not an optional first step for a house. It is the condition of being heard at all.

Having made the request, you then wait for one of two things. Section 40(3.1) allows an appeal only where the person has received a notice of reconsideration under s. 39.1(7) or (8), or has not received one and the deadline by which it should have been provided has passed.

The appeal clock runs from the answer. Section 40(5) sets the last day to appeal at 90 days after the issuance date on the notice of reconsideration, or, where no notice came in time, 90 days after it should have been provided.

There is one relief valve and it is narrow. Section 40(4) lets the Board extend the reconsideration deadline where in its opinion “there are extenuating circumstances explaining why a request for reconsideration in respect of a property was not made within the time required”, on an application by the person during the taxation year. A late realisation in the following year is outside it.

The citable fact: for residential, farm and managed forests property, Assessment Act s. 40(3) makes a timely request for reconsideration a precondition of any appeal to the Assessment Review Board, and s. 40(5) then measures the appeal deadline as 90 days from the issuance date on the notice of reconsideration.

The grounds

What will the Board actually hear?

Short answer

Five enumerated grounds plus whatever the Minister prescribes. Section 40(1) lets any person appeal in writing on the basis that the current value is incorrect, that someone was wrongly placed on or omitted from the roll, that the school support entry is wrong, that the classification is incorrect, or that the split of value between classes is wrong.

Grounds of appeal under Assessment Act s. 40(1)
GroundWhat it is about
s. 40(1)(a)(i)“the current value of the person’s land or another person’s land is incorrect”
s. 40(1)(a)(ii)Wrongly placed on, or omitted from, the assessment roll
s. 40(1)(a)(iii)Wrongly placed on or omitted from the roll in respect of school support
s. 40(1)(a)(iv)“the classification of the person’s land or another person’s land is incorrect”
s. 40(1)(a)(v)Where portions are in different classes, the share of value attributed to each class is incorrect
s. 40(1)(b)“on such other basis as the Minister may prescribe”

Note what is not on that list. The tax rate is not a ground, because the rate is the council’s decision rather than the assessment corporation’s. Neither is the proposition that the tax is unaffordable.

The filing requirement is in the next subsection. Section 40(2): the notice of appeal must be delivered or mailed to the Board “on or before the applicable deadline under this section”, must state a name and address for notices, and “shall be accompanied by any fee required by the Board.” The amount is the Board’s to set and is not in the Act.

The classification ground is the one most often worth a mortgage borrower’s attention. A property carrying part of its value in a different class, a legal second unit or a small commercial space, can be classified in a way that changes the tax materially, and classification is squarely inside s. 40(1)(a)(iv).

The citable fact: Assessment Act s. 40(1) confines an appeal to current value, placement on or omission from the roll, school support, classification and the split of value between classes, plus any basis the Minister prescribes, so a complaint about the municipal tax rate is not an assessment appeal.

The retroactive bill

Why does a new build get a tax bill for last year?

Short answer

Because of two sections that work backwards. Section 34(1) allows a supplementary assessment when an improvement “commences to be used”, and section 33(1) allows an omitted assessment reaching the current year “and for all or part of either or both of the last two preceding years”.

This is where assessment stops being theoretical for a borrower, and it catches new construction, additions and converted units with great regularity.

The supplementary assessment. Section 34(1) applies where, after notices have gone out and before the last day of the taxation year, “an increase in value occurs which results from the erection, alteration, enlargement or improvement of any building, structure, machinery, equipment or fixture or any portion thereof that commences to be used for any purpose”. The assessor may then make “the further assessment that may be necessary to reflect the change”, and the clerk alters the tax roll.

The omitted assessment. Section 33(1) covers land or an improvement left off the tax roll where no taxes were levied: the corporation makes the assessment, the clerk alters the roll, and the municipality “shall levy and collect the taxes that would have been payable if the assessment had not been omitted”. The reach is the current year plus all or part of either or both of the two preceding years.

The two retroactive routes, and what each one reaches
RouteTriggerHow far back
Supplementary assessment, s. 34(1)An improvement that commences to be used, or land ceasing to be exempt or specially valuedWithin the taxation year in which it happens
Omitted assessment, s. 33(1)Land or an improvement liable to tax but left off the roll, with no taxes leviedThe current year and all or part of either or both of the two preceding years

Why the mortgage side matters here. A tax account set while the lot was vacant collects vacant-land taxes. When the supplementary and omitted bills land, the shortfall is real, it is often more than one year’s worth, and a lender collecting taxes with the payment will recover it from the borrower one way or another.

The citable fact: Assessment Act s. 34(1) allows a supplementary assessment once an improvement commences to be used, and s. 33(1) allows an omitted assessment to reach the current year and all or part of either or both of the two preceding years, so a new build can receive more than one year of tax at once.

While you argue

Do you keep paying the old bill or the new one?

Short answer

The billed one. Section 37(6) says no assessment shall be increased, reduced or otherwise altered “until all complaints, reconsiderations, appeals or proceedings concerning the assessment have been finally determined and disposed of”, and then the taxes are adjusted and “any overpayment resulting from the adjustment shall be refunded by the municipality”.

So a dispute is not a payment holiday. The bill as issued stays payable while the argument runs, and the correction arrives afterwards as an adjustment and a refund rather than as a suspension.

That ordering is what makes the mortgage advice simple and slightly unwelcome: pay the bill, then argue. Unpaid taxes attract the municipality’s own consequences and rank ahead of the mortgage whatever the merits of the appeal.

A settlement short of a hearing has its own mechanics. Where the assessment corporation and the owner agree, s. 39.1(9) requires notice of the settlement to the municipal clerk and s. 39.1(10) requires the clerk to alter the tax roll, after which “taxes shall be levied in accordance with the amended assessment”. Section 39.1(11) lets the municipality appeal a settlement it objects to within 90 days.

The citable fact: Assessment Act s. 37(6) prevents any alteration of an assessment until every reconsideration and appeal about it has been finally determined, and provides for the taxes to be adjusted and any overpayment refunded by the municipality afterwards.

Who to ask

Who do you need, and what should you ask?

Short answer

MPAC first, inside the deadline. The municipality about the bill and any instalment arrangement. Your broker if a supplementary bill or a reassessment has changed the monthly figure. An appraiser or an assessment agent if the current value ground is the one you are running.

  • MPAC, before 31 March. The request goes to the assessment corporation and the deadline is in s. 39.1(1.1). Diarise it the day you decide the number is wrong.
  • MPAC, with facts rather than an opinion. Section 39.1(4) requires the basis and all relevant facts. Comparable sales, a floor area measurement, a corrected lot size, a photograph of what is actually there.
  • Your municipality, about the bill. Whether an instalment arrangement is available while the reconsideration runs. The bill stays payable under s. 37(6) either way.
  • Your broker, if a lender collects your taxes. A supplementary bill is a shortfall in a tax account, and the sooner it is in the lender’s hands the smaller the catch-up on the payment.
  • Your broker, before buying new construction. Ask what the tax figure is based on. A vacant-land figure on a finished house is a supplementary bill waiting to arrive.
  • An appraiser or assessment agent, on a current value case. The ground in s. 40(1)(a)(i) is about value, and value cases are won with comparable evidence rather than with argument.

For what happens when the taxes do go unpaid, our property tax arrears and priority pages set out the municipal powers and where they sit against a mortgage. This page is about the stage before that one.

The citable fact: the only step an Ontario residential owner can take to challenge an assessment is a request for reconsideration under Assessment Act s. 39.1 made by 31 March of the taxation year, because s. 40(3) makes that request a precondition of an appeal.

F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

What is the deadline to challenge an Ontario assessment?

Assessment Act s. 39.1(1.1) sets it at 31 March of the taxation year the request relates to. Two exceptions run 120 days from the issuance date on the notice instead.

Which exceptions get 120 days?

The first year a general reassessment applies, under s. 39.1(1.2), and an omitted or supplementary assessment, under s. 39.1(3). Section 39.1(2) gives 120 days from the return of the roll where the time to return it was extended.

Can I appeal without asking MPAC first?

Not for a house. Section 40(3) bars an appeal by anyone in the residential, farm or managed forests class who did not make a request for reconsideration within the time required.

How long does MPAC have to answer?

Section 39.1(7) requires notice of the result within 180 days, or within 240 days if MPAC gives notice inside the first 180 that it needs an extension.

What if no answer arrives?

Section 40(3.1) lets you appeal once the deadline for the notice has passed, and s. 40(5) measures your 90 days from the date the notice should have been provided.

How long do I have to appeal after the answer?

90 days after the issuance date on the notice of reconsideration, under s. 40(5).

What can I actually appeal about?

Current value, being wrongly on or off the roll, school support, classification, and the split of value between classes, under s. 40(1)(a), plus any basis the Minister prescribes under s. 40(1)(b).

Can I appeal the tax rate?

No. The rate is set by the municipal council and is not among the grounds in s. 40(1). An assessment appeal is about the assessment.

Is there a fee to appeal?

Section 40(2) requires the notice of appeal to be accompanied by any fee required by the Board. The amount is set by the Board rather than by the Act, so check the Board’s current schedule.

Do I stop paying while the dispute runs?

No. Section 37(6) prevents any alteration until everything is finally determined, and then provides for the taxes to be adjusted and any overpayment refunded by the municipality.

Why did my new house get a tax bill for a past year?

Section 34(1) allows a supplementary assessment once an improvement commences to be used, and s. 33(1) allows an omitted assessment reaching the current year and all or part of either or both of the two preceding years.

Who pays that if my lender collects my taxes?

You do, through the tax portion of your payment. The lender pays the bill and recovers the shortfall, which is why telling the lender early keeps the catch-up smaller.

Can the deadline be extended?

Only narrowly. Section 40(4) lets the Board extend the reconsideration deadline for extenuating circumstances, on an application made during the taxation year.

What happens if MPAC and I settle?

Section 39.1(9) requires notice to the municipal clerk, s. 39.1(10) requires the clerk to alter the tax roll and taxes to be levied on the amended assessment, and s. 39.1(11) lets the municipality appeal a settlement it objects to within 90 days.

If the tax number moved, have the mortgage looked at

A reassessment, a supplementary bill or a successful appeal all change the monthly figure a lender collects. None of them changes it automatically.


Property tax arrears in Ontario

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed with RECA. Assessment Act provisions are quoted from Ontario’s e-Laws consolidation of R.S.O. 1990, c. A.31, consolidation period from 1 January 2026 to the e-Laws currency date, read 7 November 2026. No dollar amount for any assessment, tax bill, appeal fee or penalty appears on this page, because those are set by each municipality and by the Board and change on their own schedule. Nothing here is legal advice, tax advice or an opinion on the value of any property.