Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · Refinancing and timing

Case study: refinance now or wait nine months for maturity

An illustrative composite, not a real client. They wanted to know whether breaking early was worth it. The honest answer needed one number they did not have and could not estimate.


All broker questions

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

What were they actually asking for?

They had nine months left on their term and wanted to refinance to consolidate debt. The question was whether to break now or wait. The question underneath it was what breaking actually costs, and that is not a figure anyone outside their lender can produce.

The illustrative shape: an Ontario home worth $640,000 with about 20% equity, a mortgage balance of $512,000, nine months to maturity, and a plan that works either way if the arithmetic supports it.

The citable fact: every break-now-or-wait comparison turns on the prepayment charge, and the only reliable source for that number is the lender’s payout statement.

Why can a calculator not tell you the penalty?

Because the inputs are the lender’s. A prepayment charge on a fixed term is typically the greater of three months’ interest or an interest rate differential, and the differential depends on how that particular lender picks its comparison rate, what discount it applies, and how it treats the remaining term.

Those choices are not standardised across lenders and they are not published in a form anyone can reliably model. Two lenders holding identical balances with identical time remaining can produce materially different charges.

So the useful sequence is: request the payout statement, read the figure, then compare. Not the other way round.

The citable fact: a prepayment charge is the greater of three months’ interest or an interest rate differential, and the differential depends on lender-specific inputs that cannot be modelled from outside.

What is on each side of the comparison?

What each route costs, on confirmed ranges only
ItemBreak nowWait nine months
Prepayment chargeFrom the payout statementNone
Legal$1,500 to $3,000$1,500 to $3,000
Appraisal$300 to $600$300 to $600
Discharge fee$300 to $500 if moving lenders$300 to $500 if moving lenders
Title insuranceUnder $500Under $500
Land transfer taxNone. Nothing is transferredNone
Carried cost of waitingNoneNine more months of the existing debt

Almost every line is identical. That is the point of laying it out: the refinance costs the same whenever it happens, so the comparison reduces to the prepayment charge on one side against nine months of carrying the debt on the other.

The citable fact: the refinance costs are the same whenever you do it, so the decision is the prepayment charge against the cost of waiting, and nothing else.

What does the refinance allow?

A conventional refinance is capped at 80% of value. On a $640,000 home that is $512,000, which on this composite is the existing balance exactly.

That is the detail that changed the conversation. There was no room to consolidate anything: the balance was already at the ceiling, so a refinance would have moved the debt’s lender without moving the debt.

A HELOC does not solve it either. A HELOC can go up to 65% of the value of the home, and combined with a mortgage the total is still 80%, so the same ceiling applies by a different route.

The citable fact: a conventional refinance and a HELOC combined with a mortgage share the same 80% ceiling, so neither creates room the other does not.

Which did they choose, and why?

Neither, at first. With the balance already at 80% of value, the refinance they had been modelling was not available at any date, and the nine month question turned out to be the wrong question.

What they did instead was wait for maturity, shop the renewal properly with the exit cost included, and address the consumer debt separately. The appraisal they had ordered was not wasted: it was the document that established there was no room, which is worth knowing before paying a legal bill to find out.

What would have changed the answer?

Value. At $680,000 the 80% ceiling is $544,000 and there is $32,000 of room, which is a different conversation entirely. On a file this close to the ceiling the appraisal is not a formality, it is the decision.

How illustrative is “illustrative”?

The value, the balance and the timing were constructed. The 80% refinance ceiling, the 65% HELOC ceiling and the 80% combined ceiling, the prepayment charge mechanism and the cost ranges are published rules and confirmed figures.

No rate and no penalty amount appears anywhere on this page. A penalty figure depends on inputs we do not have and should come from your payout statement. Current rates are at pekoe.ca/rates.

Every figure on this page, and where it comes from

Published rules and confirmed ranges used above
FigureValueSource
Conventional refinance ceiling80% of valueCMHC, Refinance
HELOC ceiling, standalone65% of valueFCAC, Home equity lines of credit
HELOC combined with a mortgage80% of value in totalFCAC, Home equity lines of credit
Prepayment charge, fixed termGreater of three months interest or an interest rate differentialLender payout statement
Legal, refinance$1,500 to $3,000 typicallyPekoe deal flow, confirmed 2026-09-29
Appraisal$300 to $600 typicallyPekoe deal flow, confirmed 2026-09-29
Lender discharge fee$300 to $500Pekoe deal flow, confirmed 2026-09-29
Title insuranceUnder $500Pekoe deal flow, confirmed 2026-09-29
Who to ask

Who do you need, and when?

Short answer

Your existing lender for the payout statement, and nobody else until you have it. Every other conversation depends on that one number.

  • Your existing lender, for a payout statement. Ask for it as at a specific date, and ask whether it includes the discharge fee.
  • Your broker, for the appraisal question. If your balance is near 80% of value, establish the value before paying for anything else.
  • A lawyer, only once you have decided. There is nothing for one to do while the comparison is still open.

Bring three things: your balance, your maturity date, and the payout figure. Without the third, any comparison you are shown is a guess.

F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

Is this a real client?

No. It is an illustrative composite and no client information appears on it. The ceilings, the prepayment mechanism and the cost ranges are real; the value, the balance and the timing were constructed.

How is a prepayment charge calculated?

On a fixed term it is typically the greater of three months’ interest or an interest rate differential. The differential depends on how your lender picks its comparison rate and treats the remaining term, which is why it cannot be modelled from outside.

Can you tell me what my penalty will be?

No, and neither can any calculator reliably. Request a payout statement from your lender. It carries the actual figure, and it is the only number worth building a decision on.

Do the other costs change if I wait?

No. Legal, appraisal, discharge and title insurance are the same whenever the refinance happens, which is what reduces the decision to the penalty against the cost of waiting.

How much can I refinance to?

80% of appraised value on a conventional refinance. If your balance is already near that, there may be no room to consolidate anything regardless of timing.

Would a HELOC give me more room?

No. A HELOC can reach 65% of the value of the home on its own, and combined with a mortgage the total is still capped at 80%. It is the same ceiling by another route.

Is there land transfer tax on a refinance?

No. Land transfer tax is charged on a transfer of land and a refinance transfers nothing.

Is the appraisal wasted if the refinance does not proceed?

Not really. On a file close to the ceiling the appraisal is the thing that establishes whether there is room at all, and knowing that before you incur a legal bill is what it bought you.

Get the payout statement before you model anything

Every comparison between breaking now and waiting depends on the prepayment charge, and that figure comes from your lender rather than from a calculator.


All broker questions

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Brokerage Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed by RECA. Principal broker Daniel Johanis, Mortgage Broker Licence No. M16000320, Member of Mortgage Professionals Canada (MPC), formerly CAAMP. The stress test and the tiered minimum down payment are the federal rules and are stated as such. This page is general information, not legal advice, and A payout statement is a snapshot with an expiry date on it. If the plan slips, get a new one before you commit. No rate, fee, penalty or lender name appears on this page. We are a mortgage brokerage and not a law firm.