Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · Rural and recreational

Case study: the cheaper cottage that needed $49,900 more cash

An illustrative composite, not a real client. A $349,000 cottage on a seasonally maintained road, and a $398,000 one on a municipal road nine minutes away. The cheaper property needed $69,800 down because it could not be insured. The dearer one needed $19,900. Price is not cash, and on recreational property the gap between them is the whole decision.


All broker questions

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

The two properties

What were they choosing between?

Short answer

Two cottages in the same area, $49,000 apart on price and $49,900 apart on the cash required. The cheaper one was on a seasonally maintained road with a wood stove as its only heat. The dearer one was on a year-round municipal road with a propane furnace.

Both were in the Bancroft and Area reporting region, where CREA’s MLS Home Price Index put the composite benchmark at $420,700 in September 2026, the same figure as its single-family benchmark because CREA publishes no townhouse or apartment series for that board area. Both properties were below the composite, which is normal for a seasonal market where a great deal of the stock is older and smaller than the index’s benchmark house.

The two properties as the buyers saw them
FeatureProperty AProperty B
Asking price$349,000$398,000
AccessPrivate lane, maintained in summer onlyMunicipal road, maintained year-round
HeatWood stove onlyPropane furnace, plus a wood stove
FoundationConcrete piersFull foundation
WaterLake intake, seasonalDrilled well
LotOwn lot, deededOwn lot, deeded
FrontageBetter. The reason they liked itAdequate

Property A was the one they wanted. It was cheaper, it had more water frontage, and the dock was better. None of those are things a lender weighs.

The citable fact: on recreational property the purchase price and the cash required move independently, because insurability depends on access, heating, foundation and services rather than on value.

The rule

Why was Property A not insurable?

Short answer

It failed the occupancy and access test twice over. CMHC’s insured homeowner products require a property that is “suitable and available for full time / year round occupancy” and that has “year round access including homes located on an island (via a vehicular bridge or ferry)”. A summer-only lane and a wood stove fail both halves.

Each failure stands on its own, and either one is enough.

The access. A lane maintained in summer only is not year-round access. The insurer’s wording is explicit enough that there was nothing to argue about, and the clause about islands reached by a vehicular bridge or ferry shows how the requirement is meant to be read: the test is whether a vehicle can get there in February, not how picturesque the route is.

The heat. A wood stove as the sole heat source does not make a property suitable and available for full time, year-round occupancy. It also creates a property insurance problem, which is a separate obstacle that can stop a purchase even where the lender is comfortable, because a lender requires insurance in force on the funding date.

The foundation and the water. Concrete piers and a seasonal lake intake are not disqualifying everywhere, but stacked on top of the first two failures they put the property firmly in the recreational, uninsured category.

The citable fact: CMHC’s insured homeowner parameters require a property suitable and available for full time and year-round occupancy with year-round access, so a cottage on a seasonally maintained lane with a wood stove as its only heat source falls outside insured financing on two independent grounds.

The lane

What did the title search find about the road?

Short answer

No registered right of way, and a neighbour who had been closing the lane for one day each year. Ontario’s Road Access Act permits exactly that: a closure “for a single period of no greater than twenty-four hours in a year for the purpose of preventing the acquisition of prescriptive rights”.

That provision, s. 2(1)(d), is rarely cited and it was the decisive piece of information on this file. The neighbour was not being obstructive at random. They were doing the one thing the statute permits in order to stop long use hardening into a legal right.

The Act’s protection against being landlocked is real. Section 2(1) prohibits a person constructing, placing or maintaining “a barrier or other obstacle over an access road, not being a common road, that, as a result, prevents all road access to one or more parcels of land or to boat docking facilities therefor, not owned by that person” without a judge’s closing order on ninety days notice, a written agreement with the affected owners, or a temporary closure for repair.

But the test for granting a closing order is where it bites. Section 3(1)(b) lets a judge close a private access road where the persons served by it “do not have a legal right to use the road”. With no registered right of way and an annual closure protecting against prescription, that was precisely the position.

So the lane was protected by process and unprotected by title. A lender reading that search is not reading a technicality. It is reading a resale risk.

The citable fact: Road Access Act s. 2(1)(d) permits a landowner to close a private access road for a single period of no more than twenty-four hours in a year to prevent the acquisition of prescriptive rights, and s. 3(1)(b) lets a judge order a closure where the parcels served have no legal right to use the road.

The cash

What did each property actually require?

Short answer

Property A needed at least $69,800, being 20% of $349,000, because an uninsured purchase has no tiered minimum to fall back on. Property B needed $19,900, being 5% of $398,000. The cheaper cottage needed $49,900 more cash.

The same two properties, priced as mortgages. Our arithmetic on the published rates
ScenarioPriceDown paymentLoanLoan to valuePremium
Property A, uninsured minimum$349,000$69,800$279,20080.00%None. Uninsured
Property B, tiered minimum$398,000$19,900$378,10095.00%$15,124 at 4.00%
Property B, 10% down$398,000$39,800$358,20090.00%$11,104 at 3.10%

Three things in that table are worth saying out loud.

20% is the floor on Property A, not the expectation. Several lenders that do recreational lending want more than 20% on a seasonal property, and that is a lender-specific figure we are not going to publish. The $69,800 is the structural minimum once insurance is off the table, not a quote.

Property B’s premium is financed. The $15,124 is added to the mortgage rather than paid in cash, which is why a $19,900 down payment buys a $398,000 house. In Ontario the provincial sales tax on the premium is cash at closing and cannot be financed, and that belongs in the closing cost estimate.

The middle row and the bottom row differ by a band. Going from $19,900 to $39,800 moves the loan from 95% to 90% of value and the premium rate from 4.00% to 3.10%, saving $4,020 for $19,900 more cash.

The citable fact: on a $349,000 uninsured recreational purchase the structural minimum down payment is $69,800, while a $398,000 insurable property requires a tiered minimum of $19,900, so the cheaper property required $49,900 more cash.

What they did

Which one did they buy?

Short answer

Property B, at 10% down, because the $39,800 was within reach and the $69,800 was not. They paid $49,000 more for the property and $29,900 less in cash on the day.

The decision was not a preference. They had about $45,000 available after closing costs, and one of the two properties was financeable with that and the other was not.

They considered three routes to Property A before giving it up, and it is worth recording why each failed.

  • A larger down payment. The money did not exist. Borrowing it unsecured would have shown up as debt in the ratios and defeated the purpose.
  • Releasing equity from their city home. Arithmetically possible, and it would have added a payment to the file at exactly the moment they needed the ratios to be clean. It was priced and it did not work.
  • Buying it and upgrading the heat afterwards. This is the one people reach for and it does not solve the problem. The access was the other failure, and a wood stove replaced after closing does not change the lane.

What they did not do was make an offer on Property A and hope. The financing condition would have expired with no approval, they would have lost the deposit’s negotiating value, and they would have spent six weeks discovering what one conversation told them.

The citable fact: upgrading a heat source after closing does not make a property insurable where the access also fails the year-round requirement, because the two conditions are independent and each is sufficient to exclude insured financing.

The sequence

What did the broker do first, and why does the order matter?

Short answer

Asked about access and heat before asking about price. On a recreational property those two answers decide the product, and the product decides whether the price is affordable. Asking in the other order wastes everyone’s time.

The sequence that worked, and it took one conversation and one search:

  • Four questions on the phone. Is the road maintained year-round, is there a permanent heat source, is it on its own lot with a foundation, and who owns the lane.
  • Two answers, two products. Property A was an uninsured recreational file; Property B was an ordinary insured purchase. Two different lender lists, two different cash requirements.
  • The cash tested against both. With roughly $45,000 available, only one of the two was financeable, and that was clear before any offer was written.
  • A title search on the lane for Property A anyway, because they wanted to understand what they were giving up. That is where the annual closure turned up.
  • An offer on Property B with a normal financing condition, rather than a long condition on a property that was never going to work.

The general point is that a recreational purchase is settled by the property’s characteristics rather than by the borrower’s credit. A strong borrower cannot make a seasonal cottage insurable, and a weak one does not make a four-season house uninsurable.

The citable fact: on a recreational purchase the insurability of the property, not the strength of the borrower, determines the minimum down payment, so the access and heating questions should be asked before the price is negotiated.

The second property rule

Did it matter that this was their second property?

Short answer

Not for the down payment, and yes for the qualifying. CMHC’s Second Home parameters allow a one-unit second home up to 95% loan to value with the same tiered minimum, and the product is limited to “2 properties per borrower/co-borrower at any given time”. What bound them was the ratios on both properties together.

This surprises people who assume a cottage carries a penalty simply for being a second place. On CMHC’s published parameters it does not, provided it is intended for homeowner occupancy and is available for full time, year-round occupancy.

What does bind is debt service. Both properties’ mortgage payments, property taxes and heating costs were counted, and the stress test applied to the new mortgage. That calculation, not the down payment, set the ceiling on what they could buy.

The two-property limit matters to anyone thinking further ahead. The product is for a second property, and the count follows the borrower rather than the property, so a third recreational purchase is a different conversation.

The citable fact: CMHC’s Second Home product permits a one-unit second home up to 95% loan to value with the ordinary tiered minimum equity and is limited to two properties per borrower or co-borrower at any given time.

Who to ask

Who do you need, and what should you ask?

Short answer

Your broker with the four property questions before you negotiate, your lawyer on the lane and the lot, your insurance broker on the heat source, and the municipality on whether the road is maintained.

  • Your broker, the four questions. Year-round road, permanent heat, own lot with a foundation, who owns the lane. Those four answers decide the product.
  • The municipality, on the road. Is it a public highway, is it maintained year-round, and has public money been spent on it.
  • Your lawyer, on the lane. Is there a registered right of way, and has anyone been closing the road annually. The second question is not standard and it is worth asking.
  • Your insurance broker, before your financing condition expires. A wood stove as the sole heat source can be an insurance problem even where a lender is comfortable, and the lender needs coverage in force at funding.
  • Your broker, on the ratios. Give both properties’ numbers. On a second purchase the debt service calculation usually binds before the down payment does.
  • No adviser at all, for the insurer’s wording. It is published and quoted above. What needs a person is which lenders will consider an uninsured recreational file and on what terms.

Bring three things: the listing, an honest description of the access, and the cash you actually have after closing costs. The third is the number that settled this composite.

The citable fact: the four property questions that determine whether a recreational purchase can be insured are year-round road maintenance, a permanent heat source, a freehold lot with a foundation, and who owns and maintains the access.

F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

Is this a real client?

No. It is an illustrative composite built to show the arithmetic and the published rules. No client information appears on this page.

How can the cheaper cottage need more cash?

Because it could not be insured. An uninsured purchase has no tiered minimum, so the floor is 20%, which on $349,000 is $69,800 against $19,900 on an insurable $398,000 property.

Why was the first cottage uninsurable?

Two independent failures. A lane maintained in summer only is not year-round access, and a wood stove as the sole heat source does not make a property suitable and available for full time, year-round occupancy.

Could they have replaced the wood stove after closing?

It would not have helped. The access failed as well, and the two conditions are independent. A furnace installed later does not change the lane.

What did the title search find?

No registered right of way, and a neighbour closing the lane for one day a year. The Road Access Act permits a closure for a single period of no more than twenty-four hours in a year to prevent prescriptive rights.

Does the Road Access Act not protect them?

It gives process rather than title. Section 3(1)(b) lets a judge close a private access road where the parcels served have no legal right to use it, which was the position here.

Is 20% enough on a seasonal cottage?

It is the structural floor once insurance is unavailable. Several lenders doing recreational lending want more, which is a lender-specific figure we are not going to publish.

Is the premium paid in cash?

No, it is added to the mortgage. In Ontario the provincial sales tax on the premium is cash at closing and cannot be financed, so it belongs in the closing cost estimate.

Why go from 5% to 10% down?

Because 90% of value is a band boundary. The premium rate falls from 4.00% to 3.10%, cutting the premium from $15,124 to $11,104, a saving of $4,020.

Does a cottage cost more because it is a second property?

Not on CMHC’s published parameters. A one-unit second home intended for homeowner occupancy can go to 95% loan to value with the ordinary tiered minimum, subject to a limit of two properties per borrower or co-borrower.

What actually limited what they could buy?

Debt service. Both properties’ mortgage payments, taxes and heating were counted and the stress test applied to the new mortgage, and that set the ceiling rather than the down payment.

Would releasing equity from their city home have worked?

It was priced and it did not. The released equity adds a payment to the file at exactly the point where the ratios need to be clean.

Can an island property be insured?

It can, where there is year round access “including homes located on an island (via a vehicular bridge or ferry)”. Access by private boat alone does not satisfy it.

What should I ask before making an offer?

Four things: is the road maintained year-round, is there a permanent heat source, is it a freehold lot with a foundation, and who owns and maintains the access.

Ask the four questions before you fall in love with the view

Year-round road, permanent heat, own lot with a foundation, and who owns the lane. Four questions, one phone call, and they decide whether a cottage is a mortgage or a cash purchase.


Insured down payment calculator

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed with RECA. This page is an illustrative composite and not an account of a real client, property or transaction. No client information appears on it. CMHC’s occupancy and access requirements and the premium bands are quoted from CMHC’s own product pages, read 7 November 2026; CMHC does not date those pages. Road Access Act provisions are quoted from the Ontario e-Laws consolidation, consolidation period to 15 December 2009, currency date 4 November 2026. Benchmark prices are CREA’s MLS Home Price Index for Bancroft and Area, September 2026. Every dollar figure is our arithmetic on the published rates, not a quote. No interest rate appears anywhere on this page, deliberately: a worked example carrying a rate is out of date within a week. Live rates are at pekoe.ca/rates.