Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · Offers and financing conditions

Something has gone wrong on closing day: which problem you have decides who fixes it

Closing day failures look identical from the outside and are completely different underneath. Money that has not arrived, a seller still in the house, a title problem nobody saw, and a lender that has changed its mind are four different emergencies with four different people who can solve them. The one thing they share is that the useful window is hours, not days, and that the person you call first determines how much of it you waste. This page sorts them.


All broker questions

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

What actually goes wrong on closing day?

Almost always one of four things, and they are not interchangeable. The instinct is to call whoever you spoke to last. The better move is to work out which of these you have, because the four have different owners.

The four closing day failures, and who can actually move them
What has happenedWho owns the fixRead
The money has not arrived from your lenderYour lawyer, with your broker chasing the lenderLender funds are late
The seller is still in the propertyYour lawyer, against the sellerThe seller has not moved out
The lender has pulled your approvalYour broker, urgently, and then your lawyerApproval pulled after conditions were waived
A title problem has surfacedYour lawyer, and possibly the title insurerSurvey or title insurance
The payout figure from your old lender is wrongYour lawyer, against the lenderA higher payout statement
The old lender will not dischargeYour lawyerWhen a lender will not discharge

The citable fact: a failure to complete on the agreed closing date is not a single problem with a single owner, and the party able to resolve it differs depending on whether the obstacle is funding, possession, lender approval or title.

What a closing actually depends on

Four things have to be true at the same time, and any one of them failing stops the day.

  • Your lender has to advance. Instructions complete, conditions satisfied, funds sent to your lawyer.
  • Your lawyer has to be able to register. Which needs a clean title position and the seller’s side ready.
  • The seller has to be able to deliver. Vacant possession where that is the deal, and their own discharge arranged.
  • The money has to reconcile. The statement of adjustments, the payout, the taxes and the closing costs all have to land on a number you can actually fund.

And the fourth is the one that most often fails quietly. A shortfall of a few thousand dollars discovered on the morning is a closing problem exactly as much as a lender that has vanished, and it is far more common.

The four conditions a closing depends on, and the usual way each fails
ConditionHow it failsWhose problem
The lender advancesInstructions incomplete, a condition unmet, or funds sent lateBroker and lawyer together
The lawyer can registerA title defect, or the seller’s side not readyLawyer
The seller can deliverStill in the property, or their discharge not arrangedLawyer, against the seller
The money reconcilesA shortfall on the statement of adjustmentsBroker, and it is the most common of the four

The citable fact: a closing requires the lender’s advance, a registrable title position, the seller’s ability to deliver possession and a reconciled statement of adjustments to be true simultaneously, so any single one of the four failing prevents completion.

What happens if the day is missed?

Being late is not automatically the end of the transaction, and it is not free either. In practice most missed closings are resolved by agreement: the parties extend, and whoever caused the delay absorbs the cost of it.

What those costs look like depends on who is at fault and on what the agreement says about time. Interest on the purchase money, the seller’s carrying costs, moving and storage, rate hold expiry and a per diem are all things that get argued about. No figure appears on this page, because they are specific to the deal and to the agreement.

Where a missed closing becomes a failed one, the consequences are legal rather than financial, and they are a question for your lawyer rather than for us. This page is general information and not legal advice.

The citable fact: a missed closing date is most often resolved by an agreed extension in which the party responsible for the delay bears its costs, while a failed closing moves the matter from a cost negotiation to a question of breach.

The part we can always help with

Anything where the obstacle is money. A shortfall on the statement of adjustments, a lender gone quiet, an approval withdrawn, a rate hold expiring on an extension: those are brokerage problems and a brokerage with access to 45+ lenders has more than one answer to them.

What we cannot do is anything about title or possession. Those are your lawyer’s, and trying them in the wrong order costs you the hours you have.

Who to ask

Who do you call first, on the actual day?

Short answer

Your lawyer, always, because they are the one who knows whether the deal can still register today. Then your broker if any part of the obstacle is money.

Your lawyer first, without exception. They hold the file, the funds and the registration, and they are the only person who can tell you what is actually missing rather than what somebody thinks is missing.

Your broker immediately after, if money is any part of it. Lenders move for brokers on funding-day problems in a way they often do not for borrowers, and if a replacement lender is needed the clock started hours ago.

And ask one specific question: what exactly is preventing registration today, in one sentence. The answer tells you which of the four problems you have, and this page tells you who owns it.

Three things to have open while you call.

  • The statement of adjustments, and the final cash-to-close figure.
  • Your mortgage commitment, with its conditions and its expiry.
  • The agreement of purchase and sale, and what it says about the closing date.
F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

My closing is failing. Who do I call first?

Your lawyer, every time. They hold the file, the funds and the registration, so they are the only person who can tell you what is actually missing. Then your broker if any part of the obstacle is money.

What question should I ask?

What exactly is preventing registration today, in one sentence. The answer tells you which of the four problems you have, and each has a different owner.

What usually goes wrong?

Funds not arriving, the seller still in the property, the lender pulling its approval, or a title problem. A shortfall on the statement of adjustments is the most common of all and the quietest.

Does missing the date kill the deal?

Usually not. Most missed closings are resolved by an agreed extension, with the party responsible for the delay bearing the cost. A failed closing is a different matter and becomes a question of breach.

What does an extension cost?

It depends on who caused the delay and what the agreement says about time. Interest, the seller’s carrying costs, moving and storage and a rate hold expiry can all be in play, and the figures are specific to the deal.

Can a broker fix a title problem?

No. Title and possession are your lawyer’s, and trying them in the wrong order costs you the hours you have. A brokerage helps where the obstacle is money.

My cash to close went up. Is that a closing problem?

Yes, and a very common one. A shortfall discovered on the morning stops the day exactly as effectively as a missing lender, so check the statement of adjustments as soon as you receive it rather than on the day.

What if my rate hold expires during an extension?

Then the replacement is priced at the market when you need it, which is one of the real costs of a delay. Tell your broker the moment an extension is discussed rather than after it is agreed.

Can I refuse to close if the seller has not moved out?

That is a legal question with real consequences either way, and it depends on your agreement. Do not decide it yourself on the day. Your lawyer decides whether and how to close in those circumstances.

Ask one question, then call in the right order

What is preventing registration today, in one sentence. That answer tells you which problem you have, and this page tells you who owns it.


All broker questions

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Brokerage Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed by RECA. Principal broker Daniel Johanis, Mortgage Broker Licence No. M16000320, Member of Mortgage Professionals Canada (MPC), formerly CAAMP. This page is general information, not legal advice, and whether any right is open to you depends on your agreement and your dates, which only your own lawyer can confirm. No rate, fee or penalty appears on this page. We are a mortgage brokerage and not a law firm.