Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · Commercial

The three approaches to value, and what the lender does with them

A commercial appraiser is not required to use all three approaches. The standard requires something narrower and more useful: any approach that is relevant may only be left out behind an Extraordinary Limiting Condition plus written reasons. And the number the lender lends on is not the appraised value, because three separate rules cap it.


All broker questions

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

The standard

Does the appraiser have to use all three approaches?

Short answer

No. The rule is about relevance, not completeness. Under CUSPAP rule 9.8.1, excluding an approach that is relevant “requires: an Extraordinary Limiting Condition, and supporting reasons”, while rule 9.8.2 says excluding one that is not relevant “requires: supporting reasons only”.

CUSPAP is the Canadian Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice, published by the Appraisal Institute of Canada. The current edition is CUSPAP 2026, and the Institute is explicit about when it bites: “Any assignment completed on or after April 1, 2026, including a retrospective assignment, must comply with CUSPAP 2026.”

The duty on the appraiser is at rule 8.2.8: to “describe and apply the appraisal procedures relevant to the Assignment and provide reasoning for the exclusion of any of the relevant valuation procedures”. So an omitted approach is not a gap in the report. It is a disclosure the report has to make, and you can read the reasoning.

The nearest thing CUSPAP says to “use all three” is about data rather than about method, at rule 9.7.3: “All three approaches to value require the collection of comparable data.”

What CUSPAP requires within each approach
ApproachWhat the appraiser must doRule
Direct comparisonExamine the comparable data available “to indicate a reasonable value conclusion”9.8.3
CostForm an opinion of site value by an appropriate method, estimate the cost new of the improvements, and estimate “the difference between cost new and the present worth of the improvements (accrued depreciation) if applicable”9.8.4
IncomeWork from “clear and relevant market evidence” on income, examine comparable operating expense data, “estimate rates of capitalization and/or rates of discount”, and base projections on “reasonably clear and relevant market evidence”9.8.5
Discounted cash flowEverything in 9.8.5, plus capital market and investor survey data, property-specific inputs, full display of the cash flow projections and assumptions, and identification of the software used9.8.6
Automated valuation modelDecide whether it is appropriate at all, ensure it does not exclude data needed for a credible result, and disclose the assumptions. “The output of an AVM is not a ‘value’.”9.8.9, 9.8.10

Note what the income approach rules do not contain. CUSPAP never uses the phrase direct capitalization. It speaks of “rates of capitalization and/or rates of discount” in one breath, and then treats a discounted cash flow analysis as an extra layer on top of the income approach rather than as an alternative to it.

The citable fact: CUSPAP 2026 rules 9.8.1 and 9.8.2 permit an appraiser to exclude any approach to value, requiring an Extraordinary Limiting Condition and supporting reasons where the approach is relevant and supporting reasons alone where it is not, so a report using one approach is not non-compliant.

Market value

What does the appraiser mean by value?

Short answer

The most probable price, not the highest achievable one. CUSPAP 3.51 defines market value as “the most probable price, as of a specified date, in cash, or in terms equivalent to cash … for which the specified property rights should sell after reasonable exposure in a competitive market under all conditions requisite to a fair sale”.

The rest of that definition does the work people argue about: “with the buyer and the seller each acting prudently, knowledgeably, and for self-interest, and assuming that neither is under undue duress”. A price paid by someone who had to close, or who did not know what they were buying, is a transaction rather than evidence of value.

Two further definitions matter on a commercial file. Exposure time, at 3.27, is “the estimated length of time the property interest being appraised would have been offered on the market before the hypothetical consummation of a sale”, and CUSPAP adds that it “is backward-looking”. Highest and best use, at 3.36, is “the reasonably probable use of Real Property, that is physically possible, legally permissible, financially feasible, and maximally productive, and that results in the highest value”.

Highest and best use is where a commercial appraisal most often diverges from the owner’s expectation, because rule 9.6.4 requires an opinion on both the land “as if vacant” and the property “as improved”. A building that no longer represents the best use of its site is valued accordingly.

One honest note on provenance. CUSPAP’s market value definition is footnoted to a textbook, The Appraisal of Real Estate, Fourth Canadian Edition, rather than drafted by the Institute. That is normal in valuation standards, and it is worth knowing when someone tells you the definition is a legal test. It is not.

A statutory value is a different animal. Ontario’s Assessment Act defines “current value” as “the amount of money the fee simple, if unencumbered, would realize if sold at arm’s length by a willing seller to a willing buyer”, which is why your assessment notice and your appraisal rarely agree. We cover that on whether a property assessment is the same as an appraisal.

The citable fact: CUSPAP 2026 defines market value as the most probable price for which the property rights should sell after reasonable exposure in a competitive market, with both parties acting prudently and knowledgeably and neither under undue duress.

The caps

Why did the lender use a different number?

Short answer

Because the lender is not permitted to lend on the appraised value as such. Three separate rules cap the value used for loan to value: it cannot exceed market value, it cannot exceed the purchase price where the loan finances a purchase, and it is frozen at origination and can only be revised downward.

The source is Chapter 4 of OSFI’s Capital Adequacy Requirements, which gates the real estate risk weights on six conditions. Two of them are about value.

On how the value must be formed: “the valuation must be assessed independently using prudently conservative valuation criteria”, it “must exclude expectations on price increases and must be adjusted to take into account the potential for the current market price to be significantly above the value that would be sustainable over the life of the loan”, and “if a market value can be determined, the valuation should not be higher than the market value”.

On the purchase price, in a footnote that settles a great many arguments: “In the case where the mortgage loan is financing the purchase of the property, the value of the property for LTV ratio purposes will not be higher than the effective purchase price.”

And on what happens afterwards: “The value of the property will be maintained at the value measured at origination unless OSFI elects to require institutions to revise the property value downward … If the value has been adjusted downwards, a subsequent upwards adjustment can be made but not to a higher value than the value at origination.”

The ceilings on the value a lender may use
CeilingEffectSource
Market valueThe valuation “should not be higher than the market value” where one can be determinedCapital rules, paragraph 93
Effective purchase priceOn a purchase, value for loan to value “will not be higher than the effective purchase price”Capital rules, footnote 44
Value at originationHeld at the origination figure. Downward revision only, and a later recovery cannot exceed the originalCapital rules, paragraph 92
Insured multi-unit“the purchase price or lending value as determined by CMHC, whichever amount is less”CMHC multi-unit reference guide
Dependence on the borrower“the value of the property must not depend materially on the performance of the borrower”Capital rules, paragraph 90

That last row is the one commercial borrowers find hardest, and it is the honest reason a lender discounts a value built on your own tenancy or your own operating record. The capital rules require it.

So an appraisal above the purchase price does not increase the loan, and one below it does reduce the loan. The cap runs in one direction only.

The citable fact: under OSFI’s Capital Adequacy Requirements the value used for a loan to value ratio cannot exceed market value, cannot exceed the effective purchase price where the loan finances the purchase, and is maintained at the value measured at origination subject only to downward revision.

Whose report is it

Can you give the lender an appraisal you already paid for?

Short answer

Not on its own. An appraisal can only be relied on by a party named in it or added by a Letter of Reliance, and CUSPAP 3.46 says a reliance letter “may only be issued with the prior Authorized Client’s written authorization to release a copy of the report … and the Member’s agreement”.

The part that surprises people is who the client is. The Appraisal Institute’s own consumer guidance puts it plainly: “When a mortgage broker or lender requests an appraisal, they are the appraiser’s client, regardless of who pays the appraisal fee.” That guidance is dated 2014, so read it as a long-standing position rather than current drafting, but the position matches the standard.

CUSPAP builds the same wall from the other side. An Authorized User is “a party identified by name and authorized as a user of the Professional Services of the Member”, and a residential form report “cannot be copied, reprinted, or produced, or transferred to another Authorized Client or Authorized User without the authorization of the author of the report and the written authorization from the Authorized Client or Authorized User named in the report”.

On an insured multi-unit file the reliance letter is not optional. CMHC’s required documentation asks for a “current property appraisal report, accompanied by a signed reliance letter from the third-party appraiser confirming that the appraisal report can be relied upon by the Approved Lender and CMHC for the purposes of the insured loan”.

And the independence requirement runs the other way too. The capital rules say “the valuation must be done independently from the institution’s mortgage acquisition, loan processing and loan decision process”, and Guideline B-20 says appraisers “should be designated, licensed or certified, and meet qualification standards” and “should be independent from the mortgage acquisition, loan processing and loan decision process”.

Which means the person who cannot direct the appraisal is not only you. It is also the person deciding your loan.

The citable fact: under CUSPAP the lender requesting an appraisal is the appraiser’s client regardless of who pays for it, and an appraisal can only be relied on by another party through a Letter of Reliance issued with the client’s written authorization and the appraiser’s agreement.

Disputing it

Can you appeal a commercial appraisal?

Short answer

There is no appeal. CUSPAP contains no appraisal appeal process at all. What exists instead are two different things: a Review, which is a separate paid assignment, and a complaint to the Institute, which is expressly barred from commenting on the value.

The word appeal does appear in CUSPAP, eleven times, and every one of them is about a property tax assessment appeal in the Mass Appraisal standard. That is a different process under provincial assessment legislation and it has nothing to do with a lender’s appraisal.

A Review is defined at 3.71 as “the act or process of developing and communicating an opinion about all or part of a Report prepared by a Member or non-member”. Rule 11.1.2 says it “is performed by an independent and competent Member for the purpose of forming an opinion as to whether the analysis, opinions, and conclusions in the Report under Review are appropriate and reasonable”, and 11.1.3 confirms “the reviewer does not sign/co-sign the Report that is under Review”.

A review may or may not produce its own number. Rule 11.2.1 asks the reviewer to establish whether the assignment is a review with or without an opinion of value, and 11.2.2 says that where it includes one, “that opinion is an Appraisal Assignment that must comply with the Real Property Appraisal Standard”.

Here is the limit that stops a review being a second bite with better comparables. Rule 11.6.2 says data “that could not have been available for the Report under Review on the date of that Report … must not be used by a reviewer in the development of a Review”, unless the purpose of the review includes developing an opinion of value.

A complaint to the Institute is a different route again, and the Institute is unusually clear about what it will not do. Its own published limits say the process cannot “perform technical Appraisal Reviews”, cannot “provide an opinion on the final opinion of value”, cannot award compensation, cannot order a refund and cannot “act as a court of law”. It also says it is not available to support your position in another process, naming financing among the examples.

So the realistic route is a review, commissioned by whoever is the client. Since the lender is usually the client, you generally cannot commission a review of the lender’s appraisal without the lender releasing it to you first.

The citable fact: CUSPAP provides no appeal of an appraisal, and the Appraisal Institute of Canada’s published complaint limits state that its process cannot provide an opinion on the final opinion of value or be used to support a position in a financing.

Proposed buildings

How is a value reported on a building that is not finished?

Short answer

As a Prospective Value Opinion resting on a Hypothetical Condition, which CUSPAP defines as presuming “as fact, simulated but untrue information” about the property. The phrases “as is” and “as complete” do not appear in CUSPAP at all. Those are lender and insurer vocabulary.

CUSPAP dates a value three ways. A Current Value Opinion has an effective date contemporaneous with the report, a Retrospective Value Opinion has an effective date before it, and a Prospective Value Opinion “is a forecasted value opinion and refers to an Effective Date after the date of the Report”, where “the use of clear language and consistent terminology in a prospective report (i.e., future tense throughout) is necessary to avoid producing a misleading Report”.

A Hypothetical Condition is a species of Extraordinary Assumption. An Extraordinary Assumption is “an assumption, directly related to a specific Assignment, which, if were not assumed to be true, could materially alter the opinions or conclusions”, and rule 7.10.3 states flatly that “a Hypothetical Condition requires an Extraordinary Assumption”.

Rule 7.10.5 then sets out exactly what the report has to tell you, and it is a useful checklist when you read one: that the condition “does not in fact exist as at the Effective Date”, that the opinion “is based on a hypothesis”, that “certain events need to occur, as disclosed in the Report, before the condition will in fact exist”, that the report “does not consider unforeseeable events that could alter the value conclusion”, and that “the absence of the hypothesis would likely result in a different value conclusion”.

For a proposed building, rule 7.10.2 requires the appraiser to have, and keep available for examination, plans and specifications, “evidence indicating the probable time of completion”, and “reasonably clear and appropriate evidence supporting development costs, anticipated earnings, occupancy projections, and the anticipated competition at the time of completion”.

There is also a defined follow-up step, and it is the one that catches construction draws. A Recertification of Value, at 3.67, is “an inspection performed to confirm whether the Hypothetical Conditions applied in a Report have occurred as assumed”. If your lender advances against a prospective value, expect that inspection before the money moves.

The citable fact: CUSPAP reports a value on an unfinished building as a Prospective Value Opinion supported by a Hypothetical Condition and an Extraordinary Assumption, and requires the report to state that the condition does not exist at the effective date and that its absence would likely change the value conclusion.

Licensing

Who regulates appraisers in Ontario and Alberta?

Short answer

They are regulated very differently, and the usual summary is wrong about Alberta. Alberta has a statutory prohibition with an offence attached. Ontario, so far as we could establish, has no appraiser licensing statute at all, and practice is governed by the Institute’s designations and CUSPAP.

Section 17.1 of Alberta’s Real Estate Act reads: “No person shall act as a real estate appraiser or advertise himself or herself as, or in any way hold himself or herself out as, a real estate appraiser in Alberta unless the person is a member in good standing of the Appraisal Institute of Canada, the Alberta Assessors’ Association or the Canadian National Association of Real Estate Appraisers.”

That is backed by section 81(1), which makes a contravention of section 17.1 an offence liable to a fine of not more than $25,000. The Act defines a real estate appraiser at section 1(u.1) to include a person who, for consideration, estimates the defined value of an identified interest in real estate, or signs such a report prepared by another person and accepts responsibility for it.

Section 2(4) carves out four groups: government and municipal employees acting in the regular course of employment, a person appraising “solely for the internal purposes of the person’s employer and in circumstances under which it is not intended that the activities of the person will be relied on by third parties”, a licensed real estate broker estimating value for the purposes of a trade, and anyone exempted by regulation.

An Alberta appraiser is not a RECA licensee, and that distinction is easy to get wrong. The Act defines “industry” as “the real estate broker industry, the property manager industry and the mortgage broker industry”, and defines a licensee by reference to those three. Appraisers sit outside that scheme and are caught by the membership requirement in section 17.1 instead.

How an appraiser’s standing is established in each province
OntarioAlberta
Licensing statute for appraisersNone foundReal Estate Act s. 17.1
What establishes standingInstitute designation, AACI or CRA, and CUSPAP complianceMembership in good standing of one of three named bodies
Consequence of practising without itProfessional, through the InstituteAn offence, fine of not more than $25,000, s. 81(1)
Regulator of mortgage brokersFSRARECA
Is the appraiser regulated by that body?NoNo. Appraisers sit outside the licensee definition

Two limits on what we are claiming. The Ontario negative is bounded rather than exhaustive: we read the Mortgage Brokerages, Lenders and Administrators Act, the Trust in Real Estate Services Act, the Assessment Act and the Fair Access to Regulated Professions and Compulsory Trades Act, 2006, and found no reference to an appraiser in any of them. That last Act names fifteen regulated professions in Schedule 1, including engineers, land surveyors, architects and accountants, and no appraiser body. There is no e-Laws endpoint that lists every statute, so treat this as four statutes checked rather than a census.

And a contradiction worth naming. The Institute’s own frequently asked questions say only two provinces require an appraiser to hold a licence, naming Nova Scotia and New Brunswick. That is defensible only on a narrow reading of the word licence, and it is misleading in Alberta, where practising outside those three bodies is an offence. We did not check the Nova Scotia or New Brunswick statutes, so we make no claim either way about them.

If you are checking an appraiser’s scope rather than their standing, CUSPAP 5.4.6 limits a CRA designation to a site or dwelling of not more than four self-contained family housing units, and 5.4.8 requires an AACI member to co-sign anything beyond that. So on a commercial file, the AACI designation is the one to look for.

The citable fact: section 17.1 of Alberta’s Real Estate Act prohibits acting as a real estate appraiser unless the person is a member in good standing of the Appraisal Institute of Canada, the Alberta Assessors’ Association or the Canadian National Association of Real Estate Appraisers, with a fine of not more than $25,000 under section 81(1).

The regulator

What does OSFI actually require on a commercial file?

Short answer

An independent valuation, not an appraisal. OSFI’s 2024 notice on commercial real estate lending never uses the word appraisal once. And Guideline B-20, the document most often quoted at commercial borrowers, excludes commercial lending by its own footnote.

B-20’s footnote on scope is explicit: the guideline covers a loan to an individual secured by residential property of one to four units, including “an individual borrower, personal investment company, personal holding company, or personal trust”, and “this does not include commercial loans, such as loans to entities engaged in residential real estate investments or transactions where a residential property is used in support of a commercial credit application”.

So the five unit apartment building, the corporate borrower and the house pledged behind a business loan are all outside B-20. The document that does reach them is OSFI’s Revised Regulatory Notice on Commercial Real Estate Lending, dated 21 November 2024, whose definition includes “loans for residential real estate with 5 or more units where repayment depends on sale or rental income”.

What that notice asks for on valuation: “Rigorous initial and ongoing valuation risk assessments of the underlying collateral are crucial for prudent CRE lending”, with ongoing reviews that “critically assess the borrower’s current circumstances (e.g., capitalization rates, lease rates, tenancy, revenue and expenses)”. And the consequence: “where current information implies a meaningful decline in property valuation, adjustments to the collateral value and LTV ratio should be made as part of the ongoing credit risk assessment”.

On the income side it asks institutions to assess “the borrower’s net operating income (NOI), global financial condition …, equity at risk … and track record operating similar properties or completing similar projects”, and warns that “any adjustments made to future earnings (e.g., ‘add backs’) should be carefully evaluated using the institution’s documented underwriting criteria”.

No OSFI instrument we read tells a commercial lender to order a third-party appraisal. We checked rather than assumed: the word appraisal appears zero times in that notice, against nine occurrences of valuation, and the capital rules chapter uses appraiser zero times against hundreds of uses of valuation. The regulator regulates the valuation, not the appraiser.

Where a commercial loan lands in the capital rules is worth knowing, because it explains why your lender cares so much about the tenancy. A loan is treated as materially dependent on the property’s cash flows if “more than 50% of the borrower’s income” used in assessing the ability to service the loan comes from that property, and the income-producing risk weights step up by loan to value band, which is the mechanical reason a lower value costs you more than just loan size. We go through the ratio side on what DSCR is and how it is calculated.

The citable fact: OSFI’s Revised Regulatory Notice on Commercial Real Estate Lending, dated 21 November 2024, requires rigorous initial and ongoing valuation risk assessments of the collateral and contains no requirement to obtain a third-party appraisal.

Insured multi-unit

Who values the property on an insured multi-unit file?

Short answer

The lender forms a valuation and recommends a value, a third-party appraiser provides a report the lender and the insurer can rely on, and then CMHC determines something of its own called lending value. The borrower is not in that chain.

CMHC’s required documentation for a multi-unit application asks for an “actual or projected income/expense analysis including an explanation of the income, expenses, vacancy rate and capitalization rate used in Approved Lender’s valuation”, a “recommendation on property value, with market data to support”, the third-party appraisal with its reliance letter, and a current or pro forma rent roll identifying “any vacant and/or unauthorized or non-compliant units”.

Then CMHC decides. Its reference guide expresses every loan to value limit against “lending value as determined by CMHC”, and on a purchase against “the purchase price or lending value as determined by CMHC, whichever amount is less”. The phrase “as determined by CMHC” is attached to lending value throughout.

Three other figures from that guide that bear on value. The non-residential component must not exceed 30 percent of gross floor area nor 30 percent of total lending value, and the loan on that component must not exceed 75 percent of its lending value. Replacement reserves are set “at a minimum of 2% effective gross income (EGI)”. And “the amortization period must not exceed the remaining economic life of the property, as determined by CMHC”.

Stabilization has an operational meaning rather than a valuation one. The guide requires the borrower’s covenant for the full outstanding amount “until stabilized rents have been achieved for 12 consecutive months”, at which point the additional guarantee required may be reduced, and says construction advances beyond a point are “subject to rental achievement”.

Now a date problem you should know about, because it changes what you are told to produce. CMHC publishes two live multi-unit documents whose file dates are about five years apart, and they state the appraisal requirement differently. The older reference guide gates it on size: “a property appraisal report is required for properties with 24-units or less, and may also be required in other situations”. The newer required documentation guide lists a current appraisal with a reliance letter and no unit threshold. Neither document prints a date on its face.

So if someone quotes you the 24-unit rule, ask which document it came from. We date every CMHC claim retrieved rather than as of, for exactly this reason. We cover the insured multi-unit angle further on mixed-use property mortgages.

The citable fact: on an insured multi-unit file the Approved Lender submits a valuation and a recommendation on value with supporting market data, the third-party appraisal must carry a reliance letter naming both the lender and CMHC, and the loan to value limits run against lending value as determined by CMHC.

What we will not define

Which appraisal terms have no published definition?

Short answer

More than you would expect. Going-in and terminal capitalization rate, stabilized value, external or economic obsolescence, insurable value and economic rent appear nowhere in CUSPAP, in OSFI’s guidance or in CMHC’s multi-unit guides. They are industry shorthand, and we are not going to invent definitions for them.

This is not pedantry. If a term has no definition in the standard the appraiser must follow, two people using it can mean different things, and on a commercial file that difference is money.

Terms that are defined, and where: market value, exposure time and highest and best use in CUSPAP’s definitions; current value in Ontario’s Assessment Act; the three approaches in the international valuation glossary.

Terms that are used but never defined by the body using them: net operating income, which OSFI requires lenders to evaluate without defining; capitalization rate, which OSFI, CUSPAP and CMHC all refer to without defining; and effective gross income, which CMHC sets a reserve against without defining.

Terms with a published operational meaning rather than a valuation definition: stabilized, which CMHC ties to twelve consecutive months of achieved rents; and as is and as improved, which CMHC uses as loan to value bases without definition.

On obsolescence specifically, the only occurrence we found in CUSPAP is in the machinery and equipment standard, listing obsolescence among the attributes of an item of equipment. The familiar triad of physical, functional and external obsolescence is not in CUSPAP, not in B-20 and not in the commercial real estate notice. Insurable value is the same story: CUSPAP governs a replacement cost estimate that may be undertaken “for insurance, taxation, and other matters” without defining an insurable value basis.

If your appraiser uses one of these terms, ask them to define it in the report. CUSPAP already requires the report to display the data and assumptions behind a discounted cash flow, so asking what a rate means is not an unusual request.

The citable fact: going-in and terminal capitalization rate, stabilized value, external obsolescence, insurable value and economic rent have no definition in CUSPAP 2026, in OSFI’s residential or commercial real estate guidance, or in CMHC’s multi-unit guides.

Who to ask

What should you actually do about a value you disagree with?

Short answer

Read the report before you argue with the number. The reasoning for excluding an approach, the assumptions and limiting conditions, and the analysis of your own purchase contract are all required to be in there, and that is where a real disagreement is either found or dissolved.

Three things worth checking in order.

Which approaches were used, and what the report says about the ones that were not. An exclusion needs reasons, and a relevant exclusion needs an Extraordinary Limiting Condition as well. If the reasoning is thin, that is a specific thing to put to your lender rather than a complaint about the total.

What the report says about your own transaction. CUSPAP requires an agreement for sale, option, offer or listing within the year before the effective date to be examined and reported, any sale of the property within three years to be dealt with, and, at 9.14.3, “any impact on the price paid for the subject property or any effect on value under known undue stimulus must be reported”. That rule is the answer to “but someone agreed to pay that”.

Whether the number you are arguing about is the one that matters. If the value exceeds the purchase price, the capital rules cap it at the price anyway, so a higher appraisal changes nothing. That is worth establishing before paying for a review.

Have a question? Chat with our team or AI assistant directly on pekoe.ca.

The citable fact: CUSPAP requires an appraisal report to disclose the reasoning for excluding any relevant approach to value and to report any effect on value from known undue stimulus, so a borrower’s first step on a disputed value is the report’s own disclosures rather than a complaint.

F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

Must a commercial appraisal use all three approaches to value?

No. CUSPAP 2026 rules 9.8.1 and 9.8.2 allow any approach to be excluded, requiring an Extraordinary Limiting Condition plus supporting reasons where the approach is relevant, and supporting reasons alone where it is not. The report must state the reasoning.

Does the lender take the lowest of the three approaches?

No, and no source says so. The appraiser reconciles the approaches by their applicability and reliability, and the lender then applies caps: market value, the effective purchase price on a purchase, and the value measured at origination.

Does the cost approach set a floor on value?

No. It can be excluded altogether under CUSPAP 9.8.1, and where it is used, rule 9.8.4 requires accrued depreciation to be deducted from cost new. An approach that may lawfully be omitted cannot be setting a minimum.

Can I use an appraisal I paid for myself?

Only through a Letter of Reliance. CUSPAP 3.46 requires the client’s prior written authorization and the appraiser’s agreement, and the Appraisal Institute’s consumer guidance says the lender who requests the appraisal is the client regardless of who pays for it.

Can I appeal a commercial appraisal?

There is no appeal process in CUSPAP. The alternatives are a Review, which is a separate assignment by an independent appraiser, or a complaint to the Institute, which is expressly barred from giving an opinion on the value.

Will a review use fresher comparables than the original?

Not unless the review includes its own opinion of value. CUSPAP 11.6.2 says data that could not have been available on the date of the original report must not be used in developing a review.

If the appraisal comes in above my purchase price, can I borrow more?

No. OSFI’s capital rules say that where the loan finances the purchase, the value used for loan to value will not be higher than the effective purchase price. A low appraisal reduces the loan; a high one does not raise it.

Can the lender revalue my building upward later?

Not above the origination figure. The value is maintained at the value measured at origination, may be revised downward, and a later upward adjustment cannot exceed the original value. Improvements that unequivocally increase value can be considered.

Does Guideline B-20 apply to my commercial mortgage?

No. B-20 covers loans to individuals secured by one to four unit residential property, and its own footnote excludes commercial loans and transactions where residential property supports a commercial credit application. The 2024 commercial real estate notice is the relevant one.

Do appraisers need a licence in Ontario and Alberta?

In Alberta, section 17.1 of the Real Estate Act bars anyone from acting as a real estate appraiser unless they are a member in good standing of one of three named bodies, with a fine of up to $25,000. In Ontario we found no appraiser licensing statute, and practice runs on the Institute’s designations and CUSPAP.

Read the report, then argue with the right number

Most disputes about a commercial appraisal are really disputes about which value the lender is allowed to use. Establish that first, because if the appraisal already exceeds your purchase price, a higher number buys you nothing.


See live rates

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed with RECA. CUSPAP references are to the 2026 edition, which the Appraisal Institute of Canada states applies to any assignment completed on or after 1 April 2026; quotations were checked against both the web edition and the published PDF. OSFI Guideline B-20 is dated 31 October 2017 and last modified 30 March 2023. The Revised Regulatory Notice on Commercial Real Estate Lending is dated 21 November 2024. The capital rules quoted are the 2026 edition of Chapter 4, dated 11 September 2025, and the valuation provisions quoted appear unchanged in the 2027 edition dated 10 September 2026. Alberta’s Real Estate Act was read from the King’s Printer and is current as of 1 September 2026. Ontario statutes were read through the e-Laws API, which returns no currency date in its payload, so those are dated retrieved 4 November 2026; the Ontario finding that no appraiser licensing statute exists is bounded to the four statutes we read and is not a census. CMHC publishes no date on either multi-unit document and the two differ on when an appraisal report is required, so both are dated retrieved 4 November 2026 and the newer one is preferred. The Appraisal Institute’s consumer guidance is dated 12 February 2014 and its frequently asked questions and complaint-limits pages carry no date. International valuation glossary definitions are from a glossary stating it was updated March 2020. General information, not legal or valuation advice. An opinion of value on your property is a question for a designated appraiser instructed on your own facts.