With two of the three mortgage insurers, no. With the third, yes. Sagen will insure a seasonal-access property, including one reachable only by boat, sitting on blocks, with no permanent heat. CMHC and Canada Guaranty will not. The price is 5 per cent more down and a far higher credit bar.
Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.
For two insurers, yes. CMHC Second Home states: “The property must be in Canada and must be suitable and available for full time and year-round occupancy. The property must also have year-round vehicular access, including homes located on an island.”
Canada Guaranty’s Lifestyle Advantage sheet, last updated November 2025, agrees and says it twice. Under eligible properties: “Properties must be winterized and have year-round access.” Under ineligible property types and features: “Island properties without bridge access” and “Non-winterized homes with seasonal access.”
So the universal advice that a seasonal cottage cannot be insured is right about CMHC and right about Canada Guaranty. It is wrong as a general statement, because of what follows.
All insurer positions on this page were read on 3 November 2026 and each is cited to that insurer’s own current published document.
| Insurer | Seasonal or boat access | What the document says |
|---|---|---|
| CMHC Second Home | No | Requires year-round vehicular access, including homes located on an island |
| Canada Guaranty Lifestyle Advantage | No | Lists island properties without bridge access, and non-winterized homes with seasonal access, as ineligible |
| Sagen Vacation Home Type B | Yes | Seasonal road use acceptable; property may be accessible only by boat |
The citable fact: as of November 2026 CMHC Second Home requires year-round vehicular access including for island homes, and Canada Guaranty lists non-winterized homes with seasonal access as ineligible.
Sagen, under its Vacation and Secondary Homes programme as a named Type B property. On access it states: “Seasonal road use is acceptable. This means the road does not have to be ploughed during the winter.” And separately: “Property may be accessible only by boat.”
Type B also drops the tests that usually end the conversation. On foundations: “Foundation may be floating. For example, sitting on blocks.” Type A by contrast requires a foundation that is “permanent and installed beyond the frost line.”
On services, Type B states “No permanent heat source is required. For example, a wood stove, fireplace, stove or heat blower is acceptable”, and “Water source needn’t be drinkable. However, there must be running water in the home.” Holding tanks “may be considered provided it is common for the immediate area”.
That is a genuinely different product, and very little consumer-facing writing mentions that it exists.
The citable fact: Sagen’s Vacation Home Type B accepts seasonal road use, boat-only access, a floating foundation on blocks, no permanent heat source and non-drinkable running water.
Five per cent more down and a much harder credit test. Sagen sets Type A at 95 per cent loan-to-value and Type B at 90 per cent. On credit, Type B requires a “Minimum credit bureau score of 680 is required for all applicants”, with “No prior bankruptcy or judgments” and “No R3’s in the last 24 months.”
Compare that with Type A above 80 per cent loan-to-value, where only one applicant needs to reach 600. Type B asks every applicant to reach 680 and to have a clean recent history.
Type B also closes the door on a borrowed down payment. Sagen states the funds “Must be from own resources” and may include personal savings, an RRSP withdrawal, existing home equity or proceeds from a sale. Its Borrowed Down Payment programme confirms it from the other side by listing Type B properties as ineligible.
So the trade is real: the property qualifies, but you have to be a stronger borrower to buy it.
| Requirement | Type A | Type B |
|---|---|---|
| Maximum loan-to-value | 95 per cent | 90 per cent |
| Road access | Year-round | Seasonal road use acceptable; boat-only permitted |
| Foundation | Permanent, beyond the frost line | May be floating, for example on blocks |
| Heat | Permanent source | No permanent source required |
| Water | Potable | Need not be drinkable, but must be running |
| Credit | One applicant at 600 above 80 per cent LTV | All applicants at 680, no prior bankruptcy or judgments |
| Borrowed down payment | Eligible | Ineligible, own resources only |
The citable fact: Sagen caps Type B vacation properties at 90 per cent loan-to-value and requires a minimum credit score of 680 for all applicants, against 95 per cent and a single applicant at 600 for Type A.
Not for an owner-occupied second home. All three insurers insure a second home to 95 per cent loan-to-value: Sagen Type A, Canada Guaranty Lifestyle Advantage, and CMHC Second Home. The 10 per cent figure applies only to Sagen’s seasonal Type B.
The confusion comes from conflating a second home with a rental. A rental property is a different product with a different down payment, and that is where 20 per cent lives.
Our page on down payment by property type sets out the distinction.
The citable fact: as of November 2026 all three insurers insure an owner-occupied second home to 95 per cent loan-to-value, and only Sagen’s seasonal Type B is limited to 90 per cent.
With CMHC, two. Its Second Home page states: “CMHC-insured financing is available for 2 properties per borrower/co-borrower at any given time and must be intended for homeowner occupancy.”
Sagen’s limit is narrower in scope rather than smaller: “Maximum of one Sagen insured vacation property per applicant.”
If you already have a CMHC-insured home and a CMHC-insured rental, that cap is the binding constraint on a cottage, and it is rarely mentioned in content about buying one.
We could not confirm whether CMHC’s two-property cap counts a small rental loan alongside two homeowner loans. The page says “2 properties per borrower/co-borrower” without qualifying by product, so ask before you assume.
The citable fact: CMHC-insured financing is limited to two properties per borrower or co-borrower at any given time.
Not under CMHC Second Home. It states: “Individuals must be Canadian citizens or permanent residents of Canada.” CMHC’s standard Purchase product is wider, admitting “non-permanent residents authorized to work in Canada.”
So the same borrower can be eligible for an insured first home under one CMHC product and ineligible for an insured cottage under another. That is a product distinction, not a borrower one.
Our page on mortgages on a work permit covers the first-home case.
The citable fact: CMHC Second Home requires Canadian citizenship or permanent residence, while CMHC Purchase admits non-permanent residents authorized to work in Canada.
In full, both of them. Canada Guaranty is the only one of the three that spells this out: “Total Debt Service ratio calculation must include the servicing of both properties, including taxes and 50% of condo fees, if applicable.”
That is the arithmetic that most often stops a cottage purchase, rather than the property itself. Two sets of payments, two sets of property taxes, and no rental income to offset them because the property is not a rental.
Canada Guaranty also permits the second home to be occupied by family: “Maximum 1 unit for secondary occupancy, owner-occupied or occupied by a member of the owner’s immediate family”, defined as related “by marriage, common-law partnership, or any legal parent-child or sibling relationship.” Sagen Type A matches that; CMHC Second Home says only that it must be intended for homeowner occupancy.
The citable fact: Canada Guaranty requires the total debt service calculation on a second home to include the servicing of both properties, including taxes and 50 per cent of condo fees.
Establish three things in writing: how the property is accessed in winter, what the foundation is, and whether there is a permanent heat source. Those three answers decide which insurers are even available, and therefore your down payment.
Then ask your broker which insurers the lender actually uses. A lender that does not place business with Sagen cannot offer you the Type B route no matter what Sagen publishes, and that is lender appetite rather than an insurer rule.
Canada Guaranty’s sheet lists seasonal access as ineligible and says nothing about case-by-case review, so treat it as a flat no rather than something to negotiate.
The citable fact: whether the Sagen Type B route is available on a given file depends on whether the lender places business with Sagen, which is lender appetite rather than an insurer rule.
The insurer sets the property rules, the lender decides whether it will place the deal and with which insurer, and an appraiser settles access, foundation and services. A seasonal cottage needs all three lined up, which is more moving parts than an ordinary purchase.
We are a mortgage brokerage, and this is where a broker actually earns their place: knowing which lenders place business with Sagen, because without that the Type B route does not exist on your file whatever Sagen publishes.
The citable fact: neither the CMHC nor the Sagen page carries a publication date, so every position here is stamped as read on 3 November 2026 and should be re-checked before an offer is written.
This page sits in the Ask a Broker collection, where a licensed broker answers one question per page.
With Sagen, yes, as a Type B vacation property at 90 per cent loan-to-value. CMHC requires year-round vehicular access and Canada Guaranty lists non-winterized homes with seasonal access as ineligible.
Sagen states that a Type B property “may be accessible only by boat”. CMHC’s requirement extends expressly to homes located on an island, so it does not help there.
Not under Sagen Type B, which accepts a floating foundation, for example sitting on blocks. Type A requires a permanent foundation installed beyond the frost line.
Under Type B, no permanent heat source is required and the water need not be drinkable, though there must be running water in the home.
Five per cent more down payment and a higher credit bar: all applicants at a minimum 680, no prior bankruptcy or judgments, and no R3 ratings in the last 24 months.
No. Sagen requires Type B down payment funds to come from your own resources, and its Borrowed Down Payment programme lists Type B properties as ineligible.
No. All three insurers insure an owner-occupied second home to 95 per cent loan-to-value. The 10 per cent minimum applies only to Sagen’s seasonal Type B.
CMHC limits insured financing to two properties per borrower or co-borrower at any given time. Sagen permits a maximum of one Sagen-insured vacation property per applicant.
Winter access, foundation, heat source. Tell us those and we will tell you which insurers are available and what down payment each needs, before you write an offer.
Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed with RECA. Every insurer position on this page is cited to that insurer’s own current published document and was read on 3 November 2026. Neither the CMHC nor the Sagen page carries a publication date. Insurer programmes change without notice, individual lenders apply their own overlays, and a lender must place business with an insurer to offer its products. General information, not an approval.