There is a federal regulation that decides when a changed insured mortgage counts as a brand new loan, and the hinge it turns on is a single question: does the change require an additional premium? If it does, the loan is re-tested against today’s criteria. If it does not, the Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations say it “does not affect the eligibility of the loan”.
Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.
When it requires an additional premium. Subsection 3(3) of the Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations makes that the test, in both directions, and the sentence is short enough to memorise.
Here it is. “If any other modification is made to an insured mortgage or hypothecary loan that requires the payment of an additional mortgage or hypothecary insurance premium, the loan is to be considered, for the purposes of these Regulations, as a new loan approved on the day on which the modification is approved, which must meet the criteria that apply on that day to be an eligible mortgage loan.”
And then the other half of the same subsection: “Any modification that does not require the payment of an additional mortgage or hypothecary insurance premium does not affect the eligibility of the loan.”
That is a clean rule with real consequences. A change that needs no additional premium leaves your loan where it was. A change that needs one puts your whole mortgage back on the table, to be measured against the criteria in force on the day the modification is approved rather than the criteria that applied when you first borrowed.
Note what the subsection does not do. It does not tell you when an insurer charges an additional premium. It takes that question as given and attaches a consequence to the answer. The pricing side belongs to the insurer, and this page is careful about the difference.
The citable fact: under subsection 3(3) of the Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations, a modification to an insured mortgage that requires an additional insurance premium is treated as a new loan approved on the day of the modification, while a modification that requires no additional premium does not affect the loan’s eligibility.
Subsection 3(5) deals with it directly, and it has its own two conditions: the new loan must meet the criteria the prior loan was subject to at the time of the discharge, and it must require no additional premium.
The wording: “A mortgage or hypothecary loan whose purpose is to discharge the outstanding balance of a prior insured mortgage or hypothecary loan is an eligible mortgage loan if the new loan meets the criteria to which the prior loan was subject at the time of the discharge and does not require the payment of an additional mortgage or hypothecary insurance premium.”
Read the middle clause slowly, because it is doing something subtle. The benchmark is not the criteria in force when you originally borrowed, and it is not simply today’s criteria either. It is “the criteria to which the prior loan was subject at the time of the discharge”.
So the question a lender has to answer is what rules your existing insured loan was living under at the moment it was paid out. That is a documentary question about your own mortgage, not a general one, and it is why two apparently identical switches can be assessed differently.
This is also the provision that makes a straightforward lender-to-lender switch a workable transaction inside the guarantee framework at all. Without subsection 3(5), a replacement loan would have nowhere to sit.
The citable fact: under subsection 3(5), a loan whose purpose is to discharge the outstanding balance of a prior insured loan is an eligible mortgage loan if it meets the criteria the prior loan was subject to at the time of the discharge and requires no additional insurance premium.
Then the regulation splits your mortgage in two. Subsection 3(2) treats the increased portion as a new loan approved on the day the increase is approved, measured against the criteria in force that day.
The subsection is drafted for the combined case: “if an insured mortgage or hypothecary loan is modified to both replace its security with a new eligible residential property and increase its outstanding balance, the increased portion is to be considered, for the purposes of these Regulations, as a new loan approved on the day on which the increase is approved, which must meet the criteria that apply on that day to be an eligible mortgage loan”.
It opens with “For greater certainty”, which is the drafter’s way of saying this follows from the scheme anyway. The useful part is the mechanism: the old balance and the new money are treated separately, and only the new money is re-tested.
That is exactly the boundary borrowers run into at renewal. Keeping the balance the same is one transaction. Adding to it is a second one sitting on top, and the second one meets whatever the rules are on the day it is approved rather than whatever they were when you bought.
| What is changing | Provision | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| A modification needing no additional premium | 3(3) | Does not affect the loan’s eligibility |
| A modification needing an additional premium | 3(3) | A new loan, measured against the criteria on the day of the modification |
| A new loan discharging the prior insured one | 3(5) | Eligible if it meets the prior loan’s criteria at the time of discharge and needs no additional premium |
| New security and a bigger balance together | 3(2) | The increased portion is a new loan, measured on the day the increase is approved |
| A loan workout to reduce or avoid an insurance claim | 3(4) | Eligible on the general criterion in paragraph 4(a), if it needs no additional premium |
The citable fact: under subsection 3(2), where an insured loan is modified to both replace its security and increase its balance, the increased portion is treated as a new loan approved on the day the increase is approved and must meet the criteria applying that day.
No, and the difference is deliberate. Subsection 3(4) carves out a loan workout and asks it to satisfy only one of the general criteria, provided no additional premium is required.
The provision covers a loan “made or modified in relation to a loan workout whose purpose is to reduce or avoid losses on a real or potential mortgage or hypothecary insurance claim on an outstanding insured mortgage or hypothecary loan”. Such a loan “is itself an eligible mortgage loan if it meets the criteria set out in paragraph 4(a) and does not require the payment of an additional mortgage or hypothecary insurance premium”.
Paragraph 4(a) is the lender-side criterion: the loan must be “underwritten and administered by a qualified mortgage lender”, or held in a registered retirement savings plan or registered retirement income fund and administered by one.
So a workout is not re-tested against the down payment, amortization, credit score and debt-service criteria that a fresh loan would face. The framework is built to let a struggling insured loan be restructured rather than to push it toward a claim.
That is worth knowing if your own file is in difficulty, because the first instinct of a borrower in arrears is often to assume no restructuring is possible. The arrears route generally is on mortgage arrears in Canada.
The citable fact: subsection 3(4) makes a loan workout intended to reduce or avoid losses on an insurance claim an eligible mortgage loan if it meets paragraph 4(a) and requires no additional premium, without re-testing the remaining criteria.
For a high ratio loan, the eleven paragraphs of subsection 5(1). They are more specific than most borrowers expect, and they include a credit score, two debt-service ceilings and an occupancy requirement.
Every criterion below is quoted or paraphrased from subsection 5(1), which is the list a re-tested high ratio loan has to satisfy on the day it is assessed.
| Paragraph | What it requires |
|---|---|
| 5(1)(a) | Principal, with any equal or prior claim, no more than 95% of value where value is no more than $500,000, or $475,000 plus 90% of value above $500,000 |
| 5(1)(b) | The purpose must include the purchase of the property, or be the discharge of a prior uninsured low ratio loan |
| 5(1)(c) | Scheduled to amortize over a period not exceeding 25 years, subject to subsection (1.1) |
| 5(1)(d) | The property’s value must be less than $1,500,000 |
| 5(1)(e) | Where a variable rate lets the amortization fluctuate, the payment must be recalculated at least once every five years to conform to the original schedule |
| 5(1)(f) | Scheduled principal and interest payments that begin reducing principal from funding, closing or completion |
| 5(1)(g) | At least one borrower or guarantor with a credit score of 600 or more |
| 5(1)(h) | Gross debt service and total debt service ratios not exceeding 39% and 44% |
| 5(1)(i) | At least one housing unit occupied by the borrower or a person related by marriage, common-law partnership or a legal parent-child relationship |
| 5(1)(j) | Reasonably likely to be repaid, assessed on reasonable assumptions as to the highest payment over the term |
| 5(1)(k) | Where the loan is pooled for marketable securities, those securities must be guaranteed under subsection 14(1) of the National Housing Act |
Two of those are worth a second look. Paragraph (e) is the statutory answer to what happens to a variable-rate loan whose amortization has drifted: the payment is recalculated at least once every five years to bring it back to the original schedule. And paragraph (j) is a forward-looking test, assessed against “what the highest loan payment over the term of the loan will be” rather than today’s payment.
Paragraph (g) has an exception in subsection 5(2), which disapplies the credit score criterion where no more than a small share of the lender’s high ratio loans fall below it. That is a portfolio allowance rather than a borrower right, so do not plan around it.
The underlying figures are explained in their own places: the down payment tiers on the insured down payment calculator, the ratios on GDS and TDS, and the score on the credit score you need.
The citable fact: subsection 5(1) of the Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations requires a high ratio eligible mortgage loan to have at least one borrower or guarantor with a credit score of 600 or more and gross and total debt service ratios not exceeding 39% and 44%.
Past 25 years, only in two cases. Subsection 5(1.1) allows up to 30 years where any of the borrowers is a first-time home buyer or where the property is newly built.
The base rule is paragraph 5(1)(c): the loan “must be scheduled to amortize over a period that does not exceed 25 years”, subject to subsection (1.1).
And the exception, in full: “The loan may be scheduled to amortize over a period that exceeds 25 years, but does not exceed 30 years, if any of the borrowers is a first-time home buyer or if the eligible residential property against which the loan is secured is newly built.”
“First-time home buyer” is itself defined in the Regulations, and the definition is wider than the phrase suggests. It covers an individual who has never purchased an eligible residential property in Canada, or who has not in the current or four preceding calendar years occupied as a principal residence such a property owned by them or their current spouse or partner, or who is living separate and apart from a spouse or partner because of a relationship breakdown subject to further conditions.
Put that beside subsection 3(3) and the renewal question answers itself. Lengthening the schedule is a modification. If it requires an additional premium, your loan is re-tested against the criteria in force that day, and paragraph 5(1)(c) is one of them.
The practical consequence of a longer schedule, as opposed to its eligibility, is on 30-year amortizations in Canada.
The citable fact: paragraph 5(1)(c) limits a high ratio eligible mortgage loan to an amortization not exceeding 25 years, and subsection 5(1.1) permits up to 30 years where any borrower is a first-time home buyer or the property is newly built.
One to four housing units. The Regulations define an “eligible residential property” as “a property consisting of one to four housing units, together with any associated property interests or real rights, structures and facilities”.
That definition is the source of a number quoted all over this industry without attribution. A fifth unit takes the property outside the definition, and with it outside the eligibility framework these Regulations describe.
The definition also sweeps in “associated property interests or real rights, structures and facilities”, which matters on a property where the dwelling is one of several structures. It is the surrounding rights and structures, not just the house.
And the unit count interacts with the occupancy criterion in paragraph 5(1)(i): at least one of the units has to be occupied by the borrower or a close relative. A four-unit property that is entirely tenanted does not satisfy it.
Where the additional unit is the thing being financed, the planning side is on financing a garden suite or third unit, and the rental income side is on using rental income to qualify.
The citable fact: the Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations define an eligible residential property as a property consisting of one to four housing units together with any associated property interests or real rights, structures and facilities.
In our files, no. Where an insured mortgage moves to a new lender at renewal on the same loan amount, the same amortization and the same property, we do not see a new premium charged, and the existing default insurance carries over. That is our own observation, not a published insurer rule.
Saying it plainly: that sentence describes what Pekoe sees on its own files. It is not a CMHC, Sagen or Canada Guaranty rule, and we are not presenting it as one.
The documented gap is still worth stating. The words switch and transfer appear zero times on CMHC’s premium information page for homeowner and small rental loans, against 36 uses of premium, and CMHC’s portability page is written around the original property being sold. So the published material does not answer the question either way.
What the Regulations add is a framework that is consistent with the observation rather than a confirmation of it. Subsection 3(3) treats “requires the payment of an additional … premium” as a real category with consequences, and subsection 3(5) contemplates a replacement loan discharging a prior insured loan without one. Federal law takes it as given that such a transaction exists. It does not say when an insurer charges.
The boundary travels with the statement, every time. Increasing the loan amount is a different situation. Extending the amortization is a different situation. Both are the things borrowers most often ask for at renewal, and either reopens the premium question, which is precisely what subsections 3(2) and 3(3) are about. Moving to a different property is not a switch at all; that is portability, covered on insured mortgage portability and the premium.
The citable fact: Pekoe’s own files show no new premium on a lender switch at renewal where the amount, amortization and property are unchanged, which is an observation from our files rather than a published insurer rule, and increasing the amount or extending the amortization is a different situation.
No. These Regulations are federal and the criteria read the same in both provinces. What differs is the cost and mechanics of actually registering the replacement charge.
Nothing in the eligibility criteria turns on where the property is. The unit count, the amortization limits, the ratios and the credit score criterion apply identically in Kitchener and in Canmore.
The provincial layer is the registration. A switch means discharging one charge and registering another, and the two provinces do that differently, with different costs attached. Ontario charges land transfer tax on a purchase but not on a switch, and Alberta charges Land Titles registration fees rather than a transfer tax.
Alberta also has a specific wrinkle on who has to consent to a new charge on a homestead, which is set out on dower rights in Alberta and matters on a switch as much as on a purchase.
Pekoe is licensed in both provinces, Ontario with FSRA Licence #13321 and Alberta with RECA, so a switch that crosses the border between them stays in one file.
The citable fact: the Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations are federal and their criteria apply identically in Ontario and Alberta, while the registration of a replacement charge is provincial and differs in cost and mechanics.
Your insurer or lender owns the premium question, your existing lender owns what criteria your current loan sits under, and your broker works out which transaction you should actually be asking for.
Bring your renewal statement and your current amortization to the first conversation. Those two documents tell you whether what you want is a switch or a new loan under these Regulations.
Have a question? Chat with our team or AI assistant directly on pekoe.ca.
The citable fact: whether a change requires an additional premium is a question for the insurer through the lender, which criteria an existing insured loan is subject to is a question for the current lender, and which transaction to pursue is the broker’s part.
When a premium is charged, what it costs, and whether any particular lender will do the deal. All three sit outside the Regulations, and this page does not fill the gap with a guess.
The Regulations set out when a loan is an eligible mortgage loan for the purposes of the federal guarantee framework. They are not an insurer’s premium schedule. Every time this page says “requires an additional premium”, that is a condition the Regulations assume an answer to rather than one they supply.
They also say nothing about lender appetite. A loan can satisfy every criterion in subsection 5(1) and still be declined, because eligibility is a floor rather than an approval.
And the criteria shift over time. The Regulations carry transitional provisions keyed to particular dates, including one governing high ratio loans where the insurance application was received between 1 August 2024 and 15 December 2024. If your own loan is near one of those boundaries, the version in force matters and the consolidation keeps the previous versions.
The citable fact: the Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations define eligibility for the federal guarantee framework rather than insurer pricing or lender appetite, and they carry transitional provisions keyed to specific dates, including one for high ratio loans with insurance applications received between 1 August 2024 and 15 December 2024.
An increase does. A straight switch moves the same balance and amortisation and does not re-test the file. Adding money treats the increased portion as a new loan approved that day, measured against the criteria in force then.
The citable fact: a straight switch keeps the existing insurance position, while an increase is treated as a new loan on the increased portion and is measured against current criteria.
In our files, no, where the loan amount, the amortization and the property are all unchanged. That is our own observation rather than a published insurer rule, and increasing the amount or extending the amortization is a different situation.
Subsection 3(3) of the Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations. A modification that requires an additional insurance premium is a new loan approved on the day of the modification; one that does not “does not affect the eligibility of the loan”.
Under subsection 3(5), the criteria the prior loan was subject to at the time of the discharge. Not the rules when you originally borrowed, and not simply today’s rules. It is a documentary question about your own existing mortgage.
Subsection 3(2) treats the increased portion as a new loan approved on the day the increase is approved, which must meet the criteria applying that day. The old balance and the new money are assessed separately.
Only up to 30 years, and only where any of the borrowers is a first-time home buyer or the property is newly built. That is subsection 5(1.1), an exception to the 25-year limit in paragraph 5(1)(c).
Wider than the phrase suggests. Someone who has never purchased an eligible residential property in Canada, or who has not in the current or four preceding calendar years occupied as a principal residence such a property owned by them or their current partner, or who is separating, subject to further conditions.
At least one borrower or guarantor with a score of 600 or more, under paragraph 5(1)(g). There is a portfolio-level exception in subsection 5(2) for lenders whose share of lower-scoring high ratio loans stays small, but that is a lender allowance rather than a borrower right.
Paragraph 5(1)(h): gross debt service and total debt service must not exceed 39% and 44%. Paragraph 5(1)(j) adds a forward-looking test, assessed on reasonable assumptions as to the highest payment over the term.
An “eligible residential property” is “a property consisting of one to four housing units, together with any associated property interests or real rights, structures and facilities”. A fifth unit puts the property outside the framework.
Paragraph 5(1)(i) requires at least one housing unit to be occupied by the borrower or by a person related to the borrower by marriage, common-law partnership or a legal parent-child relationship. A fully tenanted property does not satisfy it.
Subsection 3(4) treats a loan workout intended to reduce or avoid losses on an insurance claim more gently. It has to meet paragraph 4(a) and require no additional premium, and it is not re-tested against the other criteria.
No. They define eligibility for the federal guarantee framework, not insurer pricing, and they take “requires an additional premium” as a given rather than answering it. Ask the lender for the insurer’s answer in writing.
Same balance and same amortization is one transaction. More money, or a longer schedule, is another one, and the regulation treats the second as a new loan measured against today’s criteria. Knowing which one you are asking for before you ask is most of the work.
Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed with RECA. The Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations, SOR/2012-281, were read from the federal consolidation at laws-lois.justice.gc.ca, current to 19 October 2026 and last amended 27 February 2025. Every quotation on this page is from those Regulations. Read the limits section before relying on any of it. These Regulations set out when a loan is an eligible mortgage loan for the purposes of the federal guarantee framework. They are not an insurer’s premium schedule and they do not say when a premium is charged. Where this page describes what we see on our own files, it says so in those words, and that is an observation rather than a published rule.