Alberta puts hard numbers on it. The use dies if it stops for 6 consecutive months or more, and the building cannot be rebuilt if it is damaged to the extent of more than 75% of the value of the building above its foundation. Ontario’s Planning Act contains neither number. Its protection lasts “so long as it continues to be used for that purpose”, and the words damaged, destroyed and discontinued appear in the Act zero times.
Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.
A use that was lawful before the bylaw changed and is allowed to continue afterwards. Ontario’s Planning Act section 34(9)(a) says no zoning bylaw applies “to prevent the use of any land, building or structure for any purpose prohibited by the by-law if such land, building or structure was lawfully used for such purpose on the day of the passing of the by-law, so long as it continues to be used for that purpose“.
Notice what the Ontario Act does not do. It never defines “non-conforming use”, and it never uses the phrase “legal non-conforming” at all. The term appears three times in the whole Act, every one of them in a marginal heading.
Alberta goes the other way and defines both halves. Section 616 of the Municipal Government Act defines a non-conforming use as “a lawful specific use being made of land or a building or intended to be made of a building lawfully under construction at the date a land use bylaw affecting the land or building becomes effective” that does not comply with that bylaw.
And separately a non-conforming building, which is “lawfully constructed or lawfully under construction at the date a land use bylaw affecting the building or the land on which the building is situated becomes effective” and does not comply.
The use and the building are two different protections, which matters more than it sounds. A legal non-conforming corner store in a residential block is a use question. A house that sits too close to the lot line is a building question. One property can have both, or either.
Ontario has a parallel protection for work already permitted. Section 34(9)(b) protects a building for which a building permit had been issued before the bylaw passed, “so long as the building or structure when erected is used and continues to be used for the purpose for which it was erected” and the permit has not been revoked. Alberta’s equivalent is section 643(1): a development permit issued before the bylaw comes into force “continues in effect in spite of the coming into force of the bylaw”.
The citable fact: Alberta’s Municipal Government Act defines both non-conforming use and non-conforming building in section 616, while Ontario’s Planning Act never defines either term and protects a prior lawful use only so long as it continues to be used for that purpose.
In Alberta, six months. Section 643(2): a non-conforming use “may be continued but if that use is discontinued for a period of 6 consecutive months or more, any future use of the land or building must conform with the land use bylaw then in effect”. Ontario sets no period at all.
We checked that Ontario silence rather than assuming it. Over the full consolidated text of the Planning Act, the word discontinued appears zero times, abandon zero times, destroyed zero times and damaged zero times. The only condition anywhere in section 34(9) is the continuity clause.
That is not as generous as it sounds, because it leaves the question to be fought out on the facts rather than settled by a number. A municipality’s own guidance captures the position: “If the use is eventually discontinued, or changes to another use, you would lose the non-conforming rights”, though “a temporary cessation in a use does not necessarily result in the loss of the non-conforming right”.
Alberta’s six-month rule is more rigid and more predictable, and predictability cuts both ways. A seasonal operation that closes for seven months is in difficulty in Alberta in a way it is not in Ontario. A property sitting empty between tenants can run the clock down without anyone noticing.
One protection both provinces share, and it is worth knowing before a purchase: the status does not die on a sale. Alberta section 643(7): “The land use or the use of a building is not affected by a change of ownership or tenancy of the land or building.”
| Ontario | Alberta | |
|---|---|---|
| Statutory definition of the term | None | MGA s. 616(q) and (r) |
| Discontinuance period | No period stated. “so long as it continues to be used for that purpose” | “6 consecutive months or more”, s. 643(2) |
| Destruction threshold | None in the Act | “more than 75% of the value of the building above its foundation”, s. 643(6) |
| Enlargement of the building | Committee of adjustment may permit it, s. 45(2)(a)(i) | Barred by statute, s. 643(3) and (5) |
| Change to a similar use | Committee may permit a similar or more compatible use, s. 45(2)(a)(ii) | No equivalent provision |
| Survives a sale | Yes, the protection attaches to the use | Yes, expressly, s. 643(7) |
The citable fact: Alberta terminates a non-conforming use that has been discontinued for six consecutive months or more, while Ontario’s Planning Act states no discontinuance period and contains the words discontinued, abandon, damaged and destroyed zero times.
In Alberta, only below the line. Section 643(6): if a non-conforming building “is damaged or destroyed to the extent of more than 75% of the value of the building above its foundation, the building may not be repaired or rebuilt except in accordance with the land use bylaw”. Ontario’s Act sets no threshold.
Read the measuring stick carefully, because it is unusual. It is not 75 per cent of the property value and not 75 per cent of the replacement cost of the whole structure. It is the value of the building above its foundation. A surviving foundation does not help you, because it was never in the denominator.
This is the single most expensive sentence in either province’s zoning legislation for an owner, and it is the one an insurance payout cannot fix. The money rebuilds a house. It does not rebuild the right to put that house in that spot.
Alberta also bars the ordinary improvements that owners assume are available. Section 643(5): a non-conforming building “may continue to be used but the building may not be enlarged, added to, rebuilt or structurally altered”, with three exceptions: to make it a conforming building, for routine maintenance “if the development authority considers it necessary”, or under a bylaw that gives the development authority minor variance powers for this purpose.
And the use cannot be spread around the lot. Section 643(4): a non-conforming use of part of a lot “may not be extended or transferred in whole or in part to any other part of the lot and no additional buildings may be constructed on the lot while the non-conforming use continues”. Within a building it can spread: section 643(3) allows a non-conforming use of part of a building to be “extended throughout the building”, while still barring enlargement or structural alteration of the building itself.
Ontario’s silence on destruction does not mean a free rebuild. It means the question runs on the continuity test and on whatever the local official plan and bylaw say, which is a less certain place to be standing than a statutory percentage.
The citable fact: under section 643(6) of Alberta’s Municipal Government Act a non-conforming building damaged or destroyed to the extent of more than 75 per cent of the value of the building above its foundation may not be repaired or rebuilt except in accordance with the land use bylaw.
Ontario has a route and Alberta mostly does not. Ontario’s committee of adjustment may permit “the enlargement or extension of the building or structure” under section 45(2)(a)(i), and may permit a different use that is “similar to the purpose for which it was used” or “more compatible with the uses permitted by the by-law” under section 45(2)(a)(ii).
Both of those powers carry the same condition, and it is the continuity test again: the earlier use must have “continued until the date of the application to the committee”. Let the use lapse and the application goes with it.
There is a boundary on the enlargement power too. No permission may be given “to enlarge or extend the building or structure beyond the limits of the land owned and used in connection therewith on the day the by-law was passed”. You cannot buy the lot next door and spread onto it.
Ontario has a second route that does not depend on a committee at all. Section 34(10) lets the bylaw itself be amended “so as to permit the extension or enlargement of any land, building or structure used for any purpose prohibited by the by-law”, provided the use continues in the same manner and for the same purpose.
Do not confuse any of that with a minor variance. The minor variance power in section 45(1) is a separate thing, exercisable where “the general intent and purpose of the by-law and of the official plan, if any, are maintained”, and section 45(1.0.1) adds that it must also conform with any prescribed criteria and any criteria the municipality has set by bylaw. The non-conforming powers sit in subsection (2) and are “in addition to its powers under subsection (1)”.
Alberta’s only comparable opening is indirect. Section 643(5)(c) allows alteration “in accordance with a land use bylaw that provides minor variance powers to the development authority for the purposes of this section”, and section 640(6) lets a bylaw authorise a development authority to approve a development that “does not comply with the land use bylaw or is a non-conforming building” where it would not unduly interfere with the amenities of the neighbourhood or materially affect neighbouring parcels. Both depend on the municipality having written that power into its own bylaw.
The citable fact: Ontario’s committee of adjustment may permit the enlargement of a non-conforming building or a change to a similar or more compatible use under section 45(2) of the Planning Act, provided the earlier use continued until the date of the application, while Alberta’s section 643 bars enlargement and structural alteration unless the municipality’s own bylaw grants minor variance powers for the purpose.
No, in either province, and the two get there by different routes. Ontario’s Land Titles Act makes a zoning bylaw bind registered land without any entry on the register. Alberta abolished the mechanism that once put zoning on title.
The Ontario provision is section 44(1) paragraph 10, which lists among the things registered land is subject to “unless the contrary is expressed on the register”, and which “shall not be deemed to be encumbrances”: “Any by-law heretofore passed under section 34 of the Planning Act or a predecessor of that section, and any other municipal by-law heretofore or hereafter passed, affecting land that does not directly affect the title to land.”
So a zoning bylaw binds your land, does not appear on your register, and is expressly not an encumbrance. A clean title search tells you nothing about it. We confirmed that by searching the Act: the words zoning and non-conforming appear in Ontario’s Land Titles Act zero times, and in the Registry Act zero times.
Alberta used to do it differently and stopped. Section 697 of the Municipal Government Act: “On September 1, 1995 a zoning caveat prepared and signed by the Director of Town and Rural Planning or the Provincial Planning Director and registered in a land titles office under a former Act ceases to have effect”, and an owner may apply to have a legacy one cancelled.
Alberta’s implied-burdens list in section 61(1) of its Land Titles Act, which sets out what a title is subject to without special mention, runs to Crown reservations, unpaid taxes, public highways and rights of way, short leases, expropriation rights and statutory easements. Zoning and land use designation are not on it.
Which leaves the proof to documents held privately, and in Alberta there is no index of those either. The Alberta Land Surveyors’ Association says so: “There is no central database of Real Property Reports or a record who might have previously prepared a Real Property Report on a particular parcel of land.”
The citable fact: section 44(1) paragraph 10 of Ontario’s Land Titles Act makes a zoning bylaw bind registered land without appearing on the register and expressly not as an encumbrance, and section 697 of Alberta’s Municipal Government Act extinguished registered zoning caveats on 1 September 1995.
You prove it, and the onus is explicitly yours. One Ontario city states it directly: “The legal non-conforming use protection remains an exemption to the application of the law and must be established by the party asserting it, that being you the landowner.”
The same city sets out what that means in practice: “There is no specific rule regarding the type of evidence required. However, a landowner contending an entitlement to the statutory legal non-conforming use protection is expected to provide independent cogent evidence of the existence of the non-conforming use.”
Another Ontario city’s form puts the evidence bar in a single condition: a minimum of one statutory declaration from a person with knowledge, and then this, “Facts provided in the statutory declaration must be corroborated by physical evidence (building permits, photographs, tax records, print materials, etc.)”. A third is blunter still: an application “will not be accepted if there are only statutory declaration(s); there must be other accompanying documentation”.
And note what the Ontario result is called. One city’s verb is acknowledge: the city will review the information and, if appropriate, “acknowledge that the information provided supports the claim to a legal non-conforming right”. That is not a certificate, and some municipalities circulate the determination to neighbours before issuing it.
Ontario’s other letters do less than buyers assume. One municipality states that a compliance letter “does not verify the lawful or proposed use of a property. A Permitted Use Letter is required to confirm this.” Another warns that a zoning letter “is not the same as zoning approval. It is written confirmation that the appropriate approvals have been granted.”
| Ontario | Alberta | |
|---|---|---|
| On title | Nothing. Bylaws bind without an entry | Nothing. Zoning caveats extinguished in 1995 |
| What you can obtain | A letter, variously called a zoning, compliance, permitted use or legal non-conforming verification letter | A municipal stamp on a surveyor’s Real Property Report |
| Who bears the onus | The landowner asserting the protection | The owner, who must supply the Real Property Report |
| Can the document say “legally non-conforming”? | Only where the municipality issues that specific letter | Yes in some municipalities. One returns a report stamped “compliant, non-compliant, or legally non-conforming” |
| Relief for old buildings | Through the committee of adjustment | One county issues a “Deemed Stamp of Compliance” for buildings predating a date in its own bylaw history |
Alberta’s version is more concrete because the document is a survey rather than a letter. One town returns the Real Property Report “stamped either compliant, non-compliant, or legally non-conforming, with additional details provided in a cover letter”, and notes that the stamp “is frequently requested by lending institutions or purchasers before the transfer of property”.
But the stamp’s scope is narrow, and a county that spells this out is worth quoting: reviewing a Real Property Report does not confirm “if the necessary building permits have been obtained”, nor “if the uses on site are being carried out in accordance with the necessary permits”, nor “if buildings meet Land Use Bylaw regulations other than minimum setback requirements”. We go through that in detail on the Real Property Report and compliance stamp.
The citable fact: the onus of establishing legal non-conforming status falls on the landowner asserting it, Ontario municipalities require a statutory declaration corroborated by physical evidence such as building permits, photographs or tax records, and some Alberta municipalities will stamp a Real Property Report as legally non-conforming.
It turns a rebuild into an open question, and that is what a lender is weighing. The property secures the loan, so anything that limits putting the building back where it stands is a security question rather than a paperwork one.
Three practical effects, in the order they usually surface.
The appraisal has to describe it. An appraiser valuing a legal non-conforming property is valuing a right that cannot be recreated, which is a different exercise from valuing a conforming house. An appraisal that misses the status is not useful to anybody.
Insurance and rebuild interact. In Alberta the 75 per cent line means a severe loss can leave an owner with proceeds and no right to rebuild as it stood. That is a conversation to have with an insurance broker before closing, not after a fire, and bylaw coverage exists for a reason.
The documentation takes longer. Because nothing is on title, the evidence is a municipal letter or a stamped survey, and those are obtained on municipal timelines rather than conveyancing ones. On a purchase with a financing condition, start that request the day the offer is accepted.
Where this most often comes up for us is a property with a suite, a shop, or a structure that predates the current bylaw. The honest sequence is: confirm what the municipality will put in writing, get that in front of the lender early, and treat the closing date as dependent on it.
None of that makes a non-conforming property unfinanceable. It makes it a file that needs the municipal answer first. Have a question? Chat with our team or AI assistant directly on pekoe.ca.
The citable fact: because non-conforming status appears nowhere on title in either province, the evidence on a mortgage file is a municipal letter or a stamped survey obtained on municipal timelines, which is why the request should start when the offer is accepted rather than near closing.
No. Whether a particular use qualifies, whether it has been discontinued, and what evidence will satisfy a municipality are planning and legal questions on your facts. A planning consultant and a lawyer are the right people, and in Ontario the onus of proof is on you.
Two questions worth putting to the municipality in writing rather than guessing at. Will you confirm the status, and in what document. And if the answer is no, what route exists, which in Ontario means a committee of adjustment application under section 45(2) and in Alberta means whatever variance power the local bylaw grants.
What we bring is the financing side: what a lender needs to see about the status, how long that evidence takes to assemble, and how to structure a financing condition that does not expire while a municipality is still looking at your file.
The citable fact: whether a use qualifies as legal non-conforming and whether it has lapsed are planning and legal questions decided on the facts of the property, and in Ontario the landowner asserting the protection bears the onus of establishing it.
This page sits in the Ask a Broker collection, where a licensed broker answers one question per page.
In Alberta, six consecutive months. Section 643(2) of the Municipal Government Act says any future use must then conform with the bylaw in effect. Ontario’s Planning Act states no period, only that the protection lasts so long as the use continues.
In Alberta, not if the damage exceeds 75 per cent of the value of the building above its foundation. The rebuild then has to comply with the land use bylaw. Ontario’s Act sets no destruction threshold, so the question runs on continuity and local policy.
Yes. Alberta says so expressly in section 643(7): the use is not affected by a change of ownership or tenancy. In Ontario the protection attaches to the continuing use rather than to the owner.
In Ontario, a committee of adjustment may permit an enlargement under section 45(2)(a)(i), provided the use continued until the application date and the enlargement stays within the land owned and used with it when the bylaw passed. In Alberta section 643(5) bars enlargement unless the local bylaw grants minor variance powers for the purpose.
Ontario’s committee may permit a use it considers similar to the original, or more compatible with what the bylaw allows, under section 45(2)(a)(ii). Alberta has no equivalent provision.
No. In Ontario, section 44(1) paragraph 10 of the Land Titles Act makes a zoning bylaw bind registered land without any entry on the register and expressly not as an encumbrance. In Alberta, registered zoning caveats were extinguished on 1 September 1995.
You do. One Ontario city states that the protection is an exemption to the application of the law and “must be established by the party asserting it, that being you the landowner”, and expects independent cogent evidence of the use.
A statutory declaration from someone with knowledge, corroborated by physical evidence such as building permits, photographs, tax records or print materials. At least one city refuses an application supported only by declarations.
In some Alberta municipalities, yes. One town returns a Real Property Report stamped compliant, non-compliant or legally non-conforming. In Ontario the nearest equivalent is a municipal letter, and some letters expressly do not verify the use at all.
Not inherently, but it changes what the file needs. Because nothing is on title, the lender relies on a municipal letter or a stamped survey, and those arrive on municipal timelines, so the request should start when the offer is accepted.
Nothing about non-conforming status sits on title, so the whole file turns on what the municipality will put in a letter or on a stamped survey. That request takes municipal time, not conveyancing time.
Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed with RECA. Ontario’s Planning Act was read at its e-Laws consolidation from 1 July 2026, last amendment 2026, c. 8, Sched. 7, and the Land Titles Act from 17 August 2026. Alberta’s Municipal Government Act and Land Titles Act were read from the King’s Printer, both current as of 1 September 2026. The municipal forms, policies and pages quoted are from Hamilton, Toronto, Ottawa, Cambridge, Richmond Hill and Mississauga in Ontario, and from Canmore, Rocky View County and Calgary in Alberta; most publish no date of their own and were retrieved 3 November 2026. The Alberta Land Surveyors’ Association page publishes no date. All retrieved 3 November 2026. General information, not legal or planning advice. Whether a use qualifies and whether it has lapsed are decided on the facts of your property.