Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · What is on your title

Somebody else owns the minerals under your land, and there may be a right of entry order endorsed on your title

Buying acreage in Alberta usually means buying the surface. The minerals beneath it are commonly a separate estate in separate hands, and an operator who wants at them needs either your consent or an order. Alberta’s Surface Rights Act s. 12(1) says no operator has a right of entry “until the operator has obtained the consent of the owner and the occupant of the surface”. Where an order is granted, s. 34(1) requires the Registrar of Land Titles to “register the order and endorse a memorandum of its registration on the certificate of title”. That memorandum is what your lender’s lawyer sees.


All broker questions

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

Why is the mineral estate separate from the land?

Because Alberta’s land titles system treats it as a separate thing that can be dealt with on its own. The Land Titles Act s. 52 contemplates instruments “transferring, encumbering, charging or otherwise disposing of an undivided fractional interest in a parcel of land containing mines and minerals”, and allows the Registrar to refuse one below an undivided 1/20 share. Section 179 gives “error in mines and minerals” its own head of claim against the assurance fund.

The Surface Rights Act is built on the same assumption. Its whole machinery exists to resolve a conflict between an owner of the surface and an operator after the minerals, which is a conflict that only arises because the two estates are in different hands.

So the question on an acreage purchase is not whether the minerals are severed. It is what has already been done about them: whether a surface lease exists, whether a right of entry order has been granted, and whether a memorandum of that order is endorsed on the certificate of title you are about to mortgage.

The citable fact: Alberta’s Surface Rights Act s. 12(1) bars an operator from entering the surface for mineral removal, mining or drilling, tanks and structures, a pipeline, a power transmission line or a telephone line until it has the consent of the owner and occupant of the surface or has become entitled to entry under a right of entry order.

What a right of entry order does, and what it pays you

An order is granted by the Land and Property Rights Tribunal where consent has not been obtained. It confers entry, it attracts money, and it goes on your title.

Alberta Surface Rights Act: entry, money and title
ProvisionWhat it does
s. 12(1)No right of entry for mineral removal, mining or drilling, tanks, stations and structures, a pipeline, a power transmission line or a telephone line without the consent of the owner and occupant, or a right of entry order
s. 19(1)An entry fee is payable, to the lessor where entry is under a surface lease, or to the respondent or the Tribunal where it is under an order
s. 19(2)That fee is the lesser of $5,000 or $500 per acre granted, or a proportionate amount not less than $250 where less than one acre, per titled unit
s. 19(4)The operator “shall not exercise the operator’s right of entry until the money required by this section to be paid has been paid”
s. 25(1)Compensation may take account of open market value, per acre value at highest approved use, loss of use, adverse effect on the remaining land with nuisance, inconvenience and noise, and damage
s. 34(1)The order may be filed with the Registrar of Land Titles, who “shall register the order and endorse a memorandum of its registration on the certificate of title to the land affected”
s. 34(2)Where the Tribunal notifies the Registrar that no part of the land is affected by the order, that notice may be registered without fee

Note s. 19(3). The entry fee provisions do not apply where the surface lease was entered into, or the right of entry order made, before 4 July 1983. On an older quarter section with a long-standing well site, the arrangement may predate the fee regime entirely.

The citable fact: under Surface Rights Act s. 19(2) the entry fee payable to an Alberta landowner is the lesser of $5,000 or $500 per acre granted to the operator, with a floor of $250 where less than an acre is taken, calculated for each titled unit affected.

What your lender and its appraiser actually do with it

Three things, and only the first is about the money.

The annual compensation is income attached to the land, not to you. It typically transfers with the property, and a lender will usually treat it as a feature of the parcel rather than as qualifying income. Do not build an application around it without asking first.

The appraiser values the parcel as it stands, including the intrusion. Section 25(1)(d) names exactly what an appraiser also notices: “the adverse effect of the area granted to the operator on the remaining land of the owner or occupant and the nuisance, inconvenience and noise that might be caused by or arise from or in connection with the operations of the operator”. A well site in the middle of a quarter, an access road cutting a field, or a battery within sight of the house all show up in a value.

And the memorandum on title is a requisition waiting to happen. A lender’s lawyer reviewing a certificate of title endorsed under s. 34(1) will want to know what the order covers and whether it is current. That is answerable, and it is answerable faster before you apply than during underwriting.

None of that is a decline. It is a set of questions whose answers belong inside the financing condition rather than after it.

Does Ontario have the same problem?

Yes, and it is a closer parallel than most people expect, though the machinery differs.

Ontario’s Mining Act separates surface rights from mining rights throughout, and s. 79(1) defines a “surface rights holder” as “a person to whom the surface rights of land have been granted, sold, leased or located”. Section 79(2) then provides that where there is a surface rights holder, or land is occupied by a person whose improvements in the Minister’s opinion entitle them to compensation, a person meeting the requirements in s. 79(2.1) “shall compensate the surface rights holder or the occupant of the land, as the case may be, for damages sustained to the surface rights by the prospecting, exploration activities or mining operations”.

Disputes run through the Ontario Land Tribunal under Part VI of the Act, which carries the jurisdiction provisions from s. 105.

Severed surface and mineral rights: Ontario against Alberta
QuestionOntario, Mining ActAlberta, Surface Rights Act
Is the severance recognised?Yes, surface rights and mining rights run separately throughout the ActYes, the Act presumes an owner of the surface distinct from the operator
Who is protected?The “surface rights holder”, s. 79(1)The owner and the occupant of the surface, s. 12(1)
Is consent needed to enter?Not framed as a consent-or-order gate in the compensation section we readYes, consent or a right of entry order, s. 12(1)
Is there a fixed entry payment?None found in the ActYes, s. 19(2), lesser of $5,000 or $500 per acre
Is compensation payable?Yes, for damages to the surface rights from prospecting, exploration or mining, s. 79(2)Yes, on the s. 25(1) factors
Who decides a dispute?The Ontario Land Tribunal, Part VIThe Land and Property Rights Tribunal
Does anything go on title?Not established on the sections we readYes, a memorandum on the certificate of title, s. 34(1)

The citable fact: Ontario’s Mining Act s. 79(2) requires compensation to a surface rights holder for damages sustained to the surface rights by prospecting, exploration activities or mining operations, with disputes going to the Ontario Land Tribunal under Part VI.

Two honest limits on that table. The “not found” and “not established” entries are statements about the sections of the Mining Act we read on 8 November 2026, which were the surface rights compensation provisions and the Part VI headings. They are not statements about Ontario law. Ontario’s Act runs to several hundred sections and the registration and entry questions may well be answered elsewhere in it, or in another statute. Where a negative matters to a decision, read the section rather than relying on this comparison.

Who to ask

What should you check before you make an offer on acreage?

Short answer

Get the certificate of title and read the endorsements, then find out whether a surface lease or a right of entry order exists and what it covers.

Read the title, not the listing. A memorandum registered under s. 34(1) is on the certificate of title, and the listing will not mention it.

Ask for the surface lease itself. The annual amount, the area taken, the access route and the review mechanism are all in it, and a lease predating 4 July 1983 sits outside the entry fee regime altogether.

Walk the access route. Where the road runs decides how much of the parcel is actually usable, which is what s. 25(1)(c) and (d) are about and what an appraiser will see.

Do not count the compensation as income in your own budgeting until a lender has told you how it will treat it.

Three questions for your broker, in this order.

  • Is there a memorandum on this title, and will my lender fund with it there?
  • Does the appraiser’s value already reflect the well site and the access road?
  • Is this parcel residential for lending purposes, or has the acreage and use pushed it into agricultural?
F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

If I buy acreage in Alberta, do I own the minerals?

Usually you are buying the surface estate. Alberta’s land titles system treats mines and minerals as separately dealable: Land Titles Act s. 52 contemplates instruments disposing of an undivided fractional interest in mines and minerals, and s. 179 gives “error in mines and minerals” its own head of claim against the assurance fund.

Can an operator just come onto my land?

No. Surface Rights Act s. 12(1) bars entry for mineral removal, mining or drilling, tanks and structures, a pipeline, a power transmission line or a telephone line until the operator has the consent of the owner and occupant of the surface, or has become entitled to entry under a right of entry order.

What is an entry fee and how much is it?

Under s. 19(2) it is the lesser of $5,000 or $500 per acre granted to the operator, with a floor of $250 where less than one acre is taken, calculated for each titled unit affected. Section 19(4) bars the operator from exercising entry until it is paid.

Does the entry fee apply to an old well site?

Not necessarily. Section 19(3) excludes a surface lease entered into, or a right of entry order made, before 4 July 1983.

How is ongoing compensation worked out?

Section 25(1) lets the Tribunal consider open market value, the per acre value at the highest approved use, loss of use, the adverse effect on the remaining land with nuisance, inconvenience and noise, and damage to the area taken.

Will the order show on my title?

Yes, where it is filed. Section 34(1) requires the Registrar of Land Titles to register the order and endorse a memorandum of its registration on the certificate of title to the land affected.

Can that memorandum come off?

Section 34(2) provides for it: where a Tribunal member notifies the Registrar that no part of the land described in the certificate is affected by the order, that notice may be registered without fee.

Will a lender refuse the mortgage because of a well site?

Not on its own. What it does is put questions to the appraiser about usable area and to the lawyer about what the endorsement covers. Those are answerable, and they belong inside the financing condition.

Can I use the surface lease payments as income to qualify?

Ask before you plan on it. The compensation is attached to the land and typically transfers with it, and lenders generally treat it as a feature of the parcel rather than as qualifying income.

Does the well site reduce what the property is worth?

It can, and the statute names the same factors an appraiser weighs. Section 25(1)(d) covers the adverse effect on the remaining land and the nuisance, inconvenience and noise from the operations.

Is any of this an Ontario issue too?

Yes. Ontario’s Mining Act separates surface rights from mining rights, and s. 79(1) defines a “surface rights holder” as a person to whom the surface rights have been granted, sold, leased or located.

Is compensation payable in Ontario?

Yes. Section 79(2) requires a person meeting the requirements in s. 79(2.1) to compensate the surface rights holder or the occupant for damages sustained to the surface rights by prospecting, exploration activities or mining operations.

Who decides an Ontario dispute?

The Ontario Land Tribunal, under Part VI of the Mining Act, which carries the jurisdiction provisions from s. 105.

Does an Ontario mining right get endorsed on title the way Alberta’s order does?

We did not establish that. The sections we read were the surface rights compensation provisions and the Part VI headings, and neither answers the registration question. That is a fact about the sections we read rather than about Ontario law, so read the Act or ask your lawyer where it matters.

Read the certificate of title before you write the offer

The endorsement, the surface lease and the access route decide how much of the parcel you can actually use, and that is what the appraisal will reflect.


Caveats on an Alberta title

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed with RECA. Alberta provisions are quoted from the King’s Printer consolidations of the Surface Rights Act, R.S.A. 2000, c. S-24, current as of 16 May 2024, and the Land Titles Act, R.S.A. 2000, c. L-4, current as of 1 September 2026, both read at source on 8 November 2026. Ontario provisions are quoted from the e-Laws consolidation of the Mining Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. M.14, state “current”, consolidation period to 1 January 2026, read the same day. The entry fee figures are the statutory amounts in Surface Rights Act s. 19(2) and are not an estimate of what any particular lease pays; ongoing compensation is set case by case on the s. 25(1) factors and no compensation amount appears on this page. Nothing here is legal advice or an appraisal.