Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · Title and ownership

Title fraud in Ontario: registration stopped curing it on 19 October 2006

Ontario’s Land Titles Act normally makes a registered instrument “effective according to its nature and intent”. Section 78(4.1) carves one thing out of that: “Subsection (4) does not apply to a fraudulent instrument that is registered on or after October 19, 2006.” Before that date, registration could launder a forgery. After it, it cannot.


All broker questions

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

The rule

What does registration normally do, and what changed?

Short answer

Registration normally makes an instrument work. Section 78(4) deems a registered instrument “to be effective according to its nature and intent, and to create, transfer, charge or discharge” the interest named in the register. Section 78(4.1) removes that effect for a fraudulent instrument registered on or after 19 October 2006.

Those two subsections sit next to each other and they are the whole architecture of Ontario title fraud law.

Land Titles Act, s. 78(4): “When registered, an instrument shall be deemed to be embodied in the register and to be effective according to its nature and intent, and to create, transfer, charge or discharge, as the case requires, the land or estate or interest therein mentioned in the register.”

Section 78(4.1): “Subsection (4) does not apply to a fraudulent instrument that is registered on or after October 19, 2006.”

The date is not decorative. It is the day the exception came into force, and it means the governing question on a historical fraud is when the instrument was registered rather than when it was discovered.

The citable fact: Land Titles Act s. 78(4.1) provides that the effect-of-registration rule in s. 78(4) does not apply to a fraudulent instrument registered on or after 19 October 2006.

Definitions

What counts as a fraudulent instrument?

Short answer

Four categories, and they are wider than a forged signature. The Act’s definition covers an instrument under which a fraudulent person purports to transfer land, one given under a forged power of attorney, a transfer of a charge where the charge was given by a fraudulent person, and anything that perpetrates a prescribed fraud.

Land Titles Act, definition of “fraudulent instrument”: an instrument, “(a) under which a fraudulent person purports to receive or transfer an estate or interest in land, (b) that is given under the purported authority of a power of attorney that is forged, (c) that is a transfer of a charge where the charge is given by a fraudulent person, or (d) that perpetrates a fraud as prescribed with respect to the estate or interest in land affected by the instrument”.

And “fraudulent person” means a person who executes or purports to execute an instrument if “(a) the person forged the instrument, (b) the person is a fictitious person, or (c) the person holds oneself out in the instrument to be, but knows that the person is not, the registered owner of the estate” or interest affected.

The four routes into the definition, with the practical version of each
ClauseWhat it coversWhat it looks like in practice
(a)A fraudulent person purporting to receive or transfer an interestSomeone impersonating the owner and selling or mortgaging the property.
(b)An instrument under a forged power of attorneyA relative or a stranger using a fabricated power of attorney to mortgage a home, often an elderly owner’s.
(c)A transfer of a charge where the charge was given by a fraudulent personA fraudulent mortgage sold on to an assignee, which is how an innocent party ends up holding it.
(d)An instrument perpetrating a fraud as prescribedThe residual category, filled in by regulation rather than by the Act.

Clause (b) is the reason our page on signing a mortgage under a power of attorney exists. A forged power of attorney does not merely make the mortgage voidable between the parties; it brings the instrument inside this definition and takes it outside s. 78(4).

The citable fact: the Land Titles Act definition of a fraudulent instrument expressly includes an instrument given under the purported authority of a forged power of attorney, and a fraudulent person includes a fictitious person and someone holding themselves out as the registered owner while knowing they are not.

The innocent party

Is a lender or buyer who knew nothing protected?

Short answer

Partly, by s. 57(3), and the protection is narrower than it reads. It covers a purchaser or mortgagee in good faith for valuable consideration where the vendor or mortgagor “having been registered as owner through fraud or error”, which is a different situation from the fraud being in the instrument itself.

Land Titles Act, s. 57(3): “Subsection (1) does not render liable any purchaser or mortgagee in good faith for valuable consideration by reason of the vendor or mortgagor having been registered as owner through fraud or error or having derived title from or through a person registered as owner through fraud or error, whether the fraud or error consists in a wrong description of the property or otherwise.”

Read what that addresses: the vendor or mortgagor was registered as owner through fraud, and you dealt with the register as you found it. That is the classic deferred indefeasibility case, and the subsection protects the innocent party in it.

What it does not do is reverse s. 78(4.1). Where the instrument you are relying on is itself the fraudulent instrument, registration does not make it effective, and good faith does not supply what s. 78(4) has been switched off for.

Where the loss lands, and which provision decides it
SituationGoverning provisionEffect
An ordinary registered instruments. 78(4)Effective according to its nature and intent.
A fraudulent instrument registered on or after 19 October 2006s. 78(4.1)Section 78(4) does not apply to it. Registration does not make it work.
You dealt with someone who had been registered as owner through frauds. 57(3)A purchaser or mortgagee in good faith for valuable consideration is not rendered liable on that ground.
You were wrongfully deprived and cannot recover elsewheres. 57(4)Assurance Fund compensation, subject to due diligence, last-resort and deadline conditions.
A title insurance policy covers the losss. 57(4)(c)The Fund is unavailable to the extent compensation can be recovered otherwise.

That distinction is the practical difference between a lender who advanced against a forged discharge of someone else’s mortgage and a lender who advanced to a fraudster impersonating the owner. The statute treats them differently and a lawyer will explain which case a particular file is.

The citable fact: Land Titles Act s. 57(3) protects a purchaser or mortgagee in good faith for valuable consideration where the vendor or mortgagor was registered as owner through fraud or error, which is a different situation from the instrument being relied on itself being a fraudulent instrument under s. 78(4.1).

The Assurance Fund

Can the loss be recovered from the province?

Short answer

Sometimes, from the Land Titles Assurance Fund under s. 57(4), and it comes with three conditions: demonstrated due diligence, an inability to recover just compensation otherwise, and an application made within the period the Act specifies.

Land Titles Act, s. 57(4): a person is entitled to compensation from the Assurance Fund if “(a) the person is wrongfully deprived of land or of some estate or interest in land by reason of, (i) the land being brought under this Act, (ii) the registration of a fraudulent instrument, or (iii) any misdescription, omission or other error in a certificate of ownership or in an entry on the register attributable to an officer appointed under this Act or their representative in a land registry office; (b) the person has demonstrated the requisite due diligence as specified by the Director if the person is wrongfully deprived … by reason of the registration of a fraudulent instrument; (c) the person is unable under subsection (1) or otherwise to recover just compensation for the person’s loss; and (d) the person makes an application for compensation within the time period specified in subsection (5.1).”

Clause (b) is the one to notice. Where the deprivation comes from a fraudulent instrument, the Fund is available only to a claimant who has demonstrated “the requisite due diligence as specified by the Director”. That is not a general standard of reasonableness; it is a standard set administratively, and it rewards having done the ordinary checks rather than having skipped them.

Clause (c) makes the Fund a last resort. A claimant who can recover from a title insurer, a solicitor or the fraudster is expected to do that first.

And clause (d) imposes a deadline. The Act specifies the period in s. 57(5.1), which is a reason to raise a suspected fraud with a lawyer immediately rather than investigating it yourself for a few months first.

The citable fact: Land Titles Act s. 57(4) makes Assurance Fund compensation for the registration of a fraudulent instrument conditional on the claimant having demonstrated the due diligence specified by the Director, being unable to recover just compensation otherwise, and applying within the period specified in s. 57(5.1).

The mortgage angle

How does title fraud actually reach a homeowner’s mortgage?

Short answer

Two ways. Someone registers a mortgage against your home without your knowledge, usually through impersonation or a forged power of attorney; or someone forges a discharge of your existing mortgage and sells the property out from under both of you.

The first is the one most people mean. An impersonator obtains a mortgage secured on a property they do not own, takes the advance, and disappears. The registered owner discovers it when a lender they have never heard of begins enforcement.

The second is less familiar and more damaging to lenders. A forged discharge removes a legitimate charge from the register, leaving the property apparently unencumbered, which enables a sale or a new mortgage to a party who checks the register and finds nothing.

Both routes depend on the register being treated as conclusive, which is precisely what s. 78(4.1) stopped for fraudulent instruments registered from 19 October 2006 onward. The statutory answer is now that the fraudulent instrument does not do its work, and the fight is about who bears the consequences rather than about whether the register is right.

What reduces the risk in practice is unglamorous: knowing what is registered against your own property, keeping your mailing address current with the land registry and your lender, and taking seriously any correspondence from an institution you have no relationship with. Owners who rent out a property or live abroad are the most exposed, because the warning signs arrive somewhere they are not.

The citable fact: title fraud affecting a mortgage ordinarily takes one of two forms, a charge registered by an impersonator or under a forged power of attorney, or a forged discharge of a legitimate charge, and in both cases s. 78(4.1) prevents registration from making the fraudulent instrument effective.

Title insurance

Does title insurance cover this?

Short answer

Typically yes for the policies sold on residential purchases and refinances, and the policy wording governs rather than anything on this page. We are not going to describe any insurer’s coverage in detail, because we have not read the policies and a summary of an insurance policy is the wrong thing to rely on.

What we can say is how it fits with the statute. Section 57(4)(c) makes the Assurance Fund a last resort, available only where the claimant “is unable under subsection (1) or otherwise to recover just compensation”. A title insurance policy is one of the routes that “otherwise” contemplates, which means having a policy changes which door you knock on rather than whether you have one.

Two practical points worth raising with your lawyer. First, whether the policy on your purchase was an owner’s policy or a lender-only policy, because those protect different people. Second, whether a refinance years later came with its own policy, because coverage obtained at purchase does not automatically extend to a later transaction.

And a point about the thing that is not insurance: title insurance is not a substitute for knowing what is registered against your property. A policy pays after a loss; a parcel register read once a year prevents one from running for months undetected.

The citable fact: Land Titles Act s. 57(4)(c) makes Assurance Fund compensation available only where the claimant cannot recover just compensation under s. 57(1) or otherwise, so an available title insurance recovery affects which remedy applies rather than whether a remedy exists.

Who to ask

Who do you need, and what should you ask?

Short answer

A real estate litigation lawyer, immediately, if you suspect a fraud. Your own lawyer for a parcel register search if you simply want to know what is on title. Your broker if a charge you do not recognise is affecting a renewal or a refinance.

  • A lawyer, the same week. Section 57(4)(d) imposes a deadline and clause (b) imposes a due diligence standard. Both reward acting rather than waiting.
  • Your lawyer, for the parcel register. Ask what is registered against the property today, not what was registered when you bought. It is a short search and most owners have never seen one.
  • Your lawyer, on your title insurance. Whether there is an owner’s policy, whether a later refinance carried one, and who the insured is.
  • Your broker, if a strange charge is blocking a transaction. A registration you do not recognise will stop a refinance or a switch at the lawyer’s stage, and it is better identified before the application than during it.
  • Your lender, if correspondence arrives from an institution you have no relationship with. That is a signal rather than a nuisance.
  • No adviser at all, for the statutory provisions. They are published and quoted above. What needs a person is which of them applies to your facts.

Bring three things to the lawyer: the property’s address and legal description, a copy of anything you have received from an unfamiliar institution, and the dates of your own purchase and any refinance. The dates matter because s. 78(4.1) turns on when an instrument was registered.

The citable fact: because Land Titles Act s. 78(4.1) applies to a fraudulent instrument registered on or after 19 October 2006, the registration date of the instrument in question is the first fact a lawyer needs on a suspected title fraud.

F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

What does registration normally do?

Land Titles Act s. 78(4) deems a registered instrument to be effective according to its nature and intent, and to create, transfer, charge or discharge the interest named in the register.

What changed in 2006?

Section 78(4.1): subsection (4) “does not apply to a fraudulent instrument that is registered on or after October 19, 2006”. Registration no longer makes a fraudulent instrument effective.

Why does the registration date matter?

Because the exception applies to instruments registered on or after that date. On a historical fraud the governing question is when the instrument was registered, not when it was found.

What is a fraudulent instrument?

One under which a fraudulent person purports to receive or transfer an interest in land, one given under a forged power of attorney, a transfer of a charge given by a fraudulent person, or one perpetrating a prescribed fraud.

Who is a fraudulent person?

Someone who forged the instrument, a fictitious person, or a person who holds themselves out in the instrument as the registered owner while knowing they are not.

Does a forged power of attorney count?

Yes, expressly. Clause (b) of the definition covers an instrument “given under the purported authority of a power of attorney that is forged”.

Is an innocent lender protected?

Partly. Section 57(3) protects a purchaser or mortgagee in good faith for valuable consideration where the vendor or mortgagor was registered as owner through fraud or error. It does not reverse s. 78(4.1) where the instrument itself is the fraudulent one.

What is the Land Titles Assurance Fund?

A statutory compensation fund. Section 57(4) allows a claim where a person is wrongfully deprived of land by, among other things, the registration of a fraudulent instrument.

What conditions apply to a Fund claim?

Three: demonstrated due diligence as specified by the Director where the deprivation arises from a fraudulent instrument, an inability to recover just compensation otherwise, and an application within the period the Act specifies.

How does title fraud reach a mortgage?

Usually a charge registered by an impersonator or under a forged power of attorney, or a forged discharge of a legitimate charge that makes the property look unencumbered.

Who is most exposed?

Owners whose warning signs arrive somewhere they are not: landlords, owners living abroad, and owners whose mailing address with the land registry or the lender is out of date.

Does title insurance cover it?

Typically the residential policies do, and the wording governs. The Assurance Fund is a last resort under s. 57(4)(c), so an available insurance recovery changes which remedy applies rather than whether one exists.

Does my purchase policy cover a later refinance?

Not automatically. Ask your lawyer whether the policy was an owner’s or a lender-only policy, and whether a later refinance carried its own.

What can I do myself?

Read your own parcel register, keep your mailing address current with the land registry and your lender, and treat correspondence from an unfamiliar institution as a signal rather than junk mail.

If something on your title does not look right, the clock on the Assurance Fund is real

Section 57(4) requires a claim to be made within the period the Act specifies and requires the claimant to have demonstrated the due diligence the Director sets. Both of those reward acting early.


All broker questions

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed with RECA. Statutory wording is quoted from the Land Titles Act (Ontario, e-Laws, consolidation period to 17 August 2026, currency date 4 November 2026). This page describes how the statute allocates loss; it is not legal advice, and a title fraud claim is a matter for a lawyer immediately rather than eventually. No interest rate appears on this page. Live rates are at pekoe.ca/rates.