PEKOE MORTGAGES
CREA publishes an MLS Home Price Index benchmark for each of twenty-eight Ontario real estate board areas, and the national headline buries all of them. The spread is the story: Oakville-Milton at $1,023,000 and Sault Ste. Marie at $311,800, a gap of $711,200 inside one province.
This post reproduces the whole Ontario table. Every figure was read out of CREA’s own data package rather than from a summary of it, and the year-over-year column is our arithmetic on CREA’s series rather than a CREA-published number.
| Board area | Composite benchmark, September 2026 | Year over year |
|---|---|---|
| Oakville-Milton | $1,023,000 | -4.15% |
| Greater Toronto | $917,600 | -4.65% |
| Mississauga | $903,600 | -6.42% |
| Guelph and District | $720,200 | -3.57% |
| Hamilton-Burlington | $718,600 | -5.14% |
| Barrie and District | $687,400 | -5.30% |
| Cambridge | $662,700 | -4.15% |
| Kitchener-Waterloo | $630,200 | -5.57% |
| Northumberland Hills | $628,600 | -2.45% |
| Ottawa | $623,500 | -0.30% |
| Lakelands | $610,600 | -4.80% |
| Brantford Region | $610,000 | -7.67% |
| Windsor-Essex | $570,000 | -2.45% |
| Peterborough and the Kawarthas | $568,200 | -3.78% |
| Simcoe and District | $567,900 | -3.42% |
| Niagara Region | $567,400 | -4.59% |
| Woodstock Ingersoll Tillsonburg | $566,700 | -5.09% |
| Grey Bruce Owen Sound | $555,200 | -1.70% |
| London and St Thomas | $552,500 | -2.57% |
| Kawartha Lakes | $547,400 | -8.61% |
| Kingston and Area | $542,800 | +0.50% |
| Huron Perth | $538,900 | -2.71% |
| Rideau St Lawrence | $513,200 | -5.28% |
| Sudbury | $498,000 | -1.19% |
| Quinte and District | $478,100 | -6.88% |
| Bancroft and Area | $420,700 | -13.47% |
| North Bay | $418,600 | -1.71% |
| Sault Ste. Marie | $311,800 | -2.38% |
For context, the provincial and national rows for the same month:
| Area | Composite benchmark | Year over year |
|---|---|---|
| Ontario | $736,300 | -3.86% |
| Canada, aggregate | $651,400 | -3.37% |
One board area rose. Kingston and Area, at +0.50%, was the only Ontario composite in positive territory. The other twenty-seven fell, and the provincial composite fell 3.86%.
Bancroft and Area fell hardest, by a wide margin. Down 13.47% year over year, which is more than three times the provincial rate. In a region with very few transactions an index moves hard on a small change in what sold, so read that as a direction rather than as the value of a particular property.
Ottawa was almost flat. At -0.30% it was the most stable large market in the province, which is what a very large public sector employment base tends to produce.
Twenty-one of the twenty-eight board areas are below the national aggregate. Three quarters of Ontario’s board areas sit under $651,400, which is not the picture most national coverage of Ontario housing conveys.
A benchmark does not set your down payment. The minimum is federal: 5% of the first $500,000 of value and 10% of the portion above it, with default insurance unavailable at a purchase price of $1,500,000 or more. Those thresholds do not move when a benchmark does.
What the $500,000 line does is split this table in two.
| Where the composite sits | Board areas | Minimum down payment at the benchmark |
|---|---|---|
| Under $500,000 | Bancroft and Area, North Bay, Sault Ste. Marie, Sudbury, Quinte and District | A flat 5% of the price, with no second tier |
| Over $500,000 | The other twenty-three | $25,000 plus 10% of everything above $500,000 |
At the Sault Ste. Marie composite of $311,800 the minimum is $15,590. At the Oakville-Milton composite of $1,023,000 it is $77,300. Both are our arithmetic on the regulation rather than quotes, and the difference between them is a far better description of Ontario’s housing divide than the provincial average is.
Three things, and the rate is not one of them.
The appraisal at funding. On a long closing, and especially on a pre-construction completion agreed years ago, the lender lends against the lending value at funding rather than the price you agreed. In a province where most board areas fell between 1% and 8% year over year, that gap is the live risk.
Your loan to value at renewal. A lower benchmark against the same mortgage balance is a higher loan to value, and that narrows the lender list at maturity. A borrower whose file has not been looked at since it was written is the one most exposed.
The premium band on a new purchase. The premium steps at each loan-to-value band rather than sliding, so a lower price can move a buyer into a cheaper band on the same cash. That cuts in the buyer’s favour.
If your mortgage matures in the next year, the Renewal Negotiation Playbook walks through the preparation and the order to ask questions in.
Canadian Real Estate Association, MLS Home Price Index, not seasonally adjusted, monthly series, September 2026. Read at source on 7 November 2026 from CREA’s published package `MLS_HPI_Oct_2026.zip`, worksheet “Not Seasonally Adjusted (M).xlsx”, one sheet per board area. Each column was taken by the label in its own sheet’s header row rather than by position, because a board with no townhouse or apartment series has a shorter header and its benchmark block starts further left. Year-over-year figures are our arithmetic against the row twelve months back in the same series, which is the September 2025 observation.
September is the latest month CREA has published. Next update: CREA’s package of 17 November 2026, which will carry October data, and this post is scheduled for refresh then.
A note on comparing sources. A real estate board’s own benchmark can differ from CREA’s for the same month, because boards aggregate differently. Our geo pages cite one source per figure and name it, and the TRREB figures in our October 2026 Market Watch post are a different source and a different month from these.
Oakville-Milton, at a composite of $1,023,000, down 4.15% year over year.
Sault Ste. Marie, at $311,800, down 2.38%. The gap to Oakville-Milton is $711,200.
One. Kingston and Area, at +0.50%. The other twenty-seven Ontario composites fell, North Bay among them at -1.71%.
Bancroft and Area, down 13.47%, more than three times the provincial rate. In a thin market an index moves hard on a small change in what sold.
The provincial composite was $736,300, down 3.86%. The national aggregate was $651,400, down 3.37%.
Twenty-one of the twenty-eight sit under $651,400, which is a great deal more of Ontario than most national coverage suggests.
Only in the sense that 5% of a smaller number is smaller. The tiers are federal: 5% of the first $500,000 of value plus 10% of the remainder, with insurance unavailable at $1,500,000 or more.
Five: Bancroft and Area, North Bay, Sault Ste. Marie, Sudbury and Quinte and District, all with composites under $500,000.
No. A benchmark models a representative property and holds its characteristics constant, so it moves more smoothly. An average moves when the mix of what sold changes.
Because boards aggregate differently from CREA. Cite one source per figure and name it, which is what this post and our geo pages do.
If your mortgage matures in the next twelve months, comparing the file now beats reading the renewal letter later.
Live rates, a pre-approval certificate, or a real conversation. Whichever you need first.