Not the municipality, and that is written into both provinces’ legislation rather than left to local policy. Ontario’s maintenance duty “does not apply to a highway laid out or built by any person before January 1, 2003 unless it was assumed for public use“, and Alberta’s duty “does not apply to any road made or laid out by a private person” until the municipality takes control of it. Financing is possible, and exactly one mortgage insurer publishes a condition on it.
Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.
Only once it has taken the road on. Section 44(1) of Ontario’s Municipal Act, 2001 requires the municipality with jurisdiction to “keep it in a state of repair that is reasonable in the circumstances”, and section 31 then lifts that duty off roads it has not assumed.
Section 31(4) is the mechanism: a municipality may by bylaw assume an unopened Crown road allowance or a road shown on a registered plan of subdivision for public use, and “section 44 does not apply to the highways until the municipality has passed the by-law“.
Section 31(5) covers the privately built case: “Section 44 does not apply to a highway laid out or built by any person before January 1, 2003 unless it was assumed for public use by the municipality or it has been established by by-law.”
Alberta reaches the same place in one subsection. Section 532(1) of the Municipal Government Act requires every road subject to the municipality’s direction, control and management to be kept in a reasonable state of repair, and section 532(3) then says: “This section does not apply to any road made or laid out by a private person or any work made or done on a road or place by a private person until the road or work is subject to the direction, control and management of the municipality.”
| Ontario | Alberta | |
|---|---|---|
| The duty | s. 44(1), “a state of repair that is reasonable in the circumstances” | s. 532(1), “a reasonable state of repair”, having regard to the road’s character and the area |
| Liability for default | s. 44(2), liable for all damages, subject to the Negligence Act | s. 532(2), liable for damage caused by failing to perform the duty |
| Private road excluded | s. 31(5), until assumed for public use or established by bylaw | s. 532(3), until subject to the municipality’s direction, control and management |
| Knowledge defence | s. 44(3)(a), where it did not know and could not reasonably have known | s. 532(6), liable only if it knew or should have known |
| Minimum standards defence | s. 44(3)(c), where prescribed minimum standards were met | s. 532(7), where it took reasonable steps to prevent the disrepair |
| Can spending public money create the duty? | No. s. 31(2) bars land becoming a highway by activity, “including the spending of public money” | Control is the test, not expenditure |
Section 31(2) is worth dwelling on, because it closes a route people assume is open: “After January 1, 2003, land may only become a highway by virtue of a by-law establishing the highway and not by the activities of the municipality or any other person in relation to the land, including the spending of public money.” A grader that comes down your road twice a year does not convert it into a municipal road.
The citable fact: the municipal duty to keep a road in repair does not apply to a privately built road in either province until the municipality has assumed it by bylaw in Ontario or taken it under its direction, control and management in Alberta, and in Ontario the spending of public money cannot create that status.
A road that legally exists but that nobody has taken responsibility for. In Ontario, section 26 makes all Crown surveyors’ road allowances in municipalities highways, and all road allowances, streets and lanes shown on a registered plan of subdivision highways, “unless they have been closed”. Being a highway and being maintained are different things.
Ownership follows from section 30: “A highway is owned by the municipality that has jurisdiction over it subject to any rights reserved by a person who dedicated the highway or any interest in the land held by any other person.”
So an unopened road allowance can be a municipally owned highway that has never been built, has no maintenance duty attached, and runs through what looks for all the world like somebody’s field.
Ontario has provisions for exactly that situation. Section 68(1) deals with one that was fenced in: a person in possession of part of an original road allowance abutting their land, enclosed with a lawful fence on the day the Act received royal assent, “shall, as against every person except the municipality, be deemed to have legal possession of that part of the road allowance until a by-law is passed assuming the road allowance for public use or requiring the person to remove the fence”.
Read the exception in that sentence. Against every person except the municipality. The possession is good against neighbours and no better than temporary against the municipality.
In Alberta the ownership answer is different and surprises people. Section 16: “The title to all roads in a municipality, other than a city, is vested in the Crown in right of Alberta”, and in a city it is vested in the city unless another Act or agreement says otherwise. Section 18(1) then gives the municipality “the direction, control and management of all roads within the municipality”, and section 22(1) provides that no road under that control “may be closed except by bylaw”.
Alberta’s definition of road is also broader than a plan of survey. Section 1(1)(z): land “shown as a road on a plan of survey that has been filed or registered in a land titles office, or used as a public road”, including a bridge forming part of it.
The citable fact: in Ontario a Crown surveyors’ road allowance in a municipality is a highway owned by that municipality whether or not it has ever been opened, while in Alberta title to roads outside a city is vested in the Crown in right of Alberta with the municipality holding direction, control and management.
Not in Ontario without a judge, and Ontario has a statute written for exactly this. The Road Access Act section 2(1) bars constructing, placing or maintaining “a barrier or other obstacle over an access road” where that “prevents all road access to one or more parcels of land or to boat docking facilities therefor, not owned by that person”, subject to four exceptions.
The exceptions are narrow, and the first one is the real route: an application to a judge for an order closing the road, with ninety days notice given to the parties. The others are a closure by written agreement with the affected owners, a temporary closure for repair or maintenance, and a closure “for a single period of no greater than twenty-four hours in a year for the purpose of preventing the acquisition of prescriptive rights”.
That last exception is a tell. It exists because, on land where prescription still runs, uninterrupted use can ripen into a right, and a landowner who wants to prevent that has a lawful once-a-year way to break the continuity.
The Act defines an access road as one “located on land not owned by a municipality and not dedicated and accepted as, or otherwise deemed at law to be, a public highway, that serves as a motor vehicle access route to one or more parcels of land”. A common road is an access road “on which public money has been expended for its repair or maintenance”, and the barrier prohibition is drafted against access roads “not being a common road”.
Two limits worth knowing before anyone reaches for this Act. Section 6(1): nothing in it confers any ownership right “where the right does not otherwise exist at law”. And section 6(2): granting or dismissing a closing order “shall not be construed as a determination that the road is or is not a public highway”. It settles the gate, not the title.
Also note what the Act does not do. It imposes no maintenance obligation on anyone and requires no registration. It is a barrier statute.
Alberta has no equivalent. We checked the provision usually offered as the counterpart, and it is not one: the Public Lands Act definition of a closed road is confined to “a road that was constructed pursuant to a licence of occupation issued under this Act”, which is Crown land, not a private road serving a house.
The citable fact: Ontario’s Road Access Act prohibits a barrier over a private access road that cuts off all road access to another person’s parcel unless a judge grants a closing order on ninety days notice, or the owners agree in writing, and Alberta has no equivalent statute for private roads.
More than most buyers expect, and some municipalities publish the list. One Ontario official plan sets out that emergency services are provided on a private road only “to the extent that, in the sole judgement of the service provider, road conditions permit”, and that for solid waste collection “No service is provided“.
The same plan ties school transport to maintained public roads, and an Alberta county says the same in plainer words: school buses “travel only on maintained County roads that have been designated as school bus routes”.
Two Alberta municipalities give buyers the same instruction, and it is the instruction to follow. One: “Private roads and driveways are the responsibility of the landowners who use those roads. It is up to you to find out if you will be responsible for your road before purchasing a property.” Another: “Private internal roads and driveways are the responsibility of the landowner. Determine if you will be responsible for your road before purchasing a property.”
That second municipality adds a warning with a direct financial edge: residents served by private roads or bridges “may be responsible for the cost of repairs and/or reconstruction after floods or for required maintenance over time”. A shared bridge is the version of this that gets expensive fastest.
And not every road with a municipal name is maintained. The same county notes that “there are also some County roads that are not maintained by the County, which means no grading or snow plowing”. The name on the sign is not the answer.
One Ontario township’s own road access agreement spells out the package in a single clause, which is the clearest summary we found: municipal services such as snow removal and road maintenance “shall not be provided by the Township and that some public services such as garbage removal, school bussing and some emergency services may be severely restricted”.
The citable fact: municipalities publish that private roads can lose snow clearing, road maintenance, waste collection and school bus service, and that emergency service is provided only so far as the service provider judges road conditions permit.
Register it, because you cannot earn it by using it. Ontario’s Land Titles Act section 51(1) bars any new right over registered land “by any length of possession or by prescription”, and Alberta’s Law of Property Act section 69.1(4) bars it outright and adds that “no such right is deemed to have ever been so acquired”.
In Ontario, an easement is registered under section 39(2) of the Land Titles Act: where the Director of Titles is given the evidence required, “the easement shall be registered on title to the servient lands and may be registered on title to the dominant lands”. A right of way that exists but is unregistered still binds registered land under section 44(1) paragraph 2, which is why a title search alone does not settle access.
In Alberta there are three routes, and the choice matters.
An easement gets a memorandum on both titles under section 67 of the Land Titles Act, and an owner may even grant one to themselves across two parcels they own under section 68(1), which does not merge on common ownership. That is the right tool before a severance.
A caveat under section 130 protects an interest claimed under an unregistered instrument, and is the usual way a private road agreement reaches an Alberta title.
A utility right of way is the one to be careful with. Section 69(1) lists the purposes for which the Crown or a corporation may take a registrable right, and roadways appear only at paragraph (h): “constructing, maintaining and operating a temporary roadway”. The word temporary is in the statute.
We cover the prescription rules in more detail, including the one place in Ontario where they still run, on survey or title insurance in Ontario.
The citable fact: no new right of way can be acquired by use over Ontario Land Titles land or anywhere in Alberta, so access over someone else’s land has to be registered as an easement, or in Alberta protected by caveat, rather than relied on from long use.
No statute in either province requires one. The enabling powers are permissive: Ontario’s Municipal Act section 23 says a municipality “may enter into an agreement with any person to construct, maintain and operate a private road”. Several Ontario townships nevertheless require registration as a condition of building.
We checked the absence rather than assuming it. The phrase road maintenance appears zero times in Ontario’s Municipal Act, 2001 and zero times in the Planning Act, and private road appears zero times in the Planning Act. In Alberta, private road and road maintenance both appear zero times in the Municipal Government Act, and Alberta’s subdivision regulation requires only access: every proposed subdivision must provide each new lot “direct access to a road” or “lawful means of access satisfactory to the subdivision authority”.
What Ontario municipalities do with that discretion is where it gets real. One township’s template agreement recites that its zoning bylaw “provides that no building shall be erected on a lot if it does not have access on an improved road unless a Road Access Agreement, to the satisfaction of the Township, has been executed”, and requires that the agreement or notice of it “be registered against the title of the subject lands … and shall be binding upon and ensure to the benefit of the parties hereto”.
Another township’s private road policy requires that the agreement “shall be registered against the title to the lots accessing the private road” and include acknowledgements that the township does not maintain or repair the road, may not provide the usual municipal services, and is not responsible for loss or damage from a failure to maintain it.
A third requires, for an unopened road allowance, that adjoining owners enter “an agreement to be registered on title and binding subsequent owners of their property not to demand future improvement of the road allowance by the Township”.
Alberta’s registration hooks sit at the development and subdivision stage instead, and they are temporary by design. A municipality may register a caveat against title in respect of a development or subdivision agreement, and then: “If a municipality registers a caveat under subsection (2), the municipality must discharge the caveat when the agreement has been complied with.”
So an Alberta caveat about road construction is a performance security that comes off, not a permanent record of a maintenance obligation. Do not read one as proof of a maintenance arrangement, and do not read its absence as proof there is none.
The citable fact: neither province requires a road maintenance agreement by statute, several Ontario townships require one to be registered on title as a condition of building, and Alberta’s development and subdivision caveats must be discharged by the municipality once the agreement has been complied with.
CMHC wants year-round vehicular access. Sagen is the only one that publishes a private-road condition, and it is a maintenance contract: “Privately serviced roads are allowed, provided there is a maintenance contract in place.” Canada Guaranty’s guidelines do not address private roads at all.
CMHC’s published property condition is short and appears in the same words across its product pages and fact sheets: the property “must be suitable and available for full time and year-round occupancy” and “must also have year-round vehicular access including homes located on an island (via a vehicular bridge or ferry)”.
On access over someone else’s land, CMHC says nothing. We searched nineteen of its lender and consumer pages plus its fact sheets for private road, driveway, right of way and easement, and the count was zero for each while vehicular and island returned hits in the same documents. That is silence, not a rule, and it means the question falls to the lender.
| CMHC | Sagen | Canada Guaranty | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year-round access | Required, vehicular | Required for a Secondary Home, “on reasonable quality public roads, serviced by the local municipality” | Required. Properties “with only seasonal access” are ineligible |
| Private road | Not addressed | Allowed “provided there is a maintenance contract in place” | Not addressed |
| Seasonal access | Not addressed | Acceptable on a Vacation Home, road need not be ploughed in winter | Ineligible for the second-home programme |
| Island | Allowed via a vehicular bridge or ferry | Not addressed | “Island properties without bridge access” ineligible for that programme |
| Boat-only access | Not addressed in any document we retrieved | “Property may be accessible only by boat” on a Vacation Home | Not addressed |
Two things to take from that table rather than from folklore.
The first is that Sagen’s maintenance contract requirement is the one hard document the access question can turn on, and it sits in its Vacation and Secondary Homes programme rather than in its general property standards. If a file is going that route, the agreement is not optional paperwork.
The second is a caution about CMHC. Its bridge-or-ferry parenthetical is often read as a rule that boat-access property is ineligible. CMHC does not say that anywhere we could find, so we are not going to put the words in its mouth. It is a gap in the published material, and the answer on a specific file comes from the lender and the insurer, not from inference.
For the broader seasonal-property picture, including which insurer takes what, see insured cottages and seasonal access.
The citable fact: Sagen is the only mortgage insurer that publishes a private-road condition, allowing privately serviced roads where a maintenance contract is in place, while CMHC requires year-round vehicular access and does not address private roads, rights of way or easements in its published material.
Four things, and all four are answerable before you commit. Who owns the road. Whether there is a registered easement or caveat giving you the right to use it. Whether a maintenance agreement exists and who signs it. And whether the municipality maintains anything at all.
The first two are your lawyer’s work, from the parcel register and the plan. The third is usually a document held by neighbours rather than by anyone official. The fourth is a phone call to the municipality that is worth making yourself, because the answer is often more specific than a website.
Where we come in is the insurer and lender side: whether the file needs a maintenance contract, whether year-round access can be demonstrated, and what a lender will want to see about a shared bridge or a seasonal stretch. Those answers shape the financing condition, so get them before the condition is drafted rather than during it.
One practical note on timing. A road agreement among several owners takes as long as the slowest neighbour, and a municipal road access agreement takes municipal time. Neither fits comfortably inside a short financing condition.
The citable fact: the four access questions that decide a private-road file are who owns the road, whether a registered easement or caveat grants the right to use it, whether a maintenance agreement exists, and what the municipality maintains, and none of them is answered by a clean title search alone.
This page sits in the Ask a Broker collection, where a licensed broker answers one question per page.
No. Ontario’s maintenance duty does not apply to a road laid out or built by a private person unless the municipality assumed it for public use or established it by bylaw, and Alberta’s duty does not apply until the road is subject to the municipality’s direction, control and management.
No. Ontario’s Municipal Act says land may only become a highway by a bylaw establishing it, “and not by the activities of the municipality or any other person in relation to the land, including the spending of public money”.
Not in Ontario, in most cases. The Road Access Act bars a barrier that prevents all road access to another person’s parcel unless a judge grants a closing order on ninety days notice, the owners agree in writing, or the closure is temporary for repairs or lasts no more than twenty-four hours in a year.
No. The provision often offered as the equivalent, in the Public Lands Act, applies to a road constructed under a licence of occupation on public land, not to a private road serving a residence.
Not on Ontario Land Titles land or anywhere in Alberta. Ontario’s Land Titles Act bars any new right by possession or prescription, and Alberta’s Law of Property Act says no easement is acquired by prescription and none is deemed ever to have been.
Register it. In Ontario an easement is registered on the servient title under section 39 of the Land Titles Act. In Alberta it is an easement with a memorandum on both titles, or a caveat under section 130 protecting an interest under an unregistered agreement.
No statute in either province requires it. Several Ontario townships require registration as a condition of building, and Alberta’s development and subdivision caveats must be discharged by the municipality once the agreement has been performed.
Municipalities publish that snow clearing, road maintenance and waste collection may not be provided, school buses run only on maintained designated routes, and emergency services reach a private road only so far as the service provider judges conditions permit.
Sagen will on its Secondary Home programme, “provided there is a maintenance contract in place”. CMHC requires year-round vehicular access and does not address private roads. Canada Guaranty’s guidelines do not address them either, and its second-home programme excludes properties with only seasonal access.
Sagen’s Vacation Home programme states that a property “may be accessible only by boat”. CMHC does not address boat access in any document we retrieved, so its bridge-or-ferry wording should not be read as a published rule against it. On a specific file, the lender and insurer give the answer.
Who owns the road, whether your right to use it is registered, whether a maintenance agreement exists, and what the municipality actually maintains. A clean title search answers none of them, and the financing condition should be drafted after you know.
Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed with RECA. Ontario statutes were read at their e-Laws consolidations: Municipal Act, 2001 from 2 June 2026, Land Titles Act from 17 August 2026, Planning Act from 1 July 2026, Road Access Act from 15 December 2009. Alberta’s Municipal Government Act and Land Titles Act were read from the King’s Printer, both current as of 1 September 2026, the Law of Property Act as of 15 December 2022 and the Public Lands Act as of 12 December 2024; the Matters Related to Subdivision and Development Regulation is current as of 24 October 2022. Municipal documents quoted are a township road access agreement dated 2022, a private road standards policy dated 17 August 2023, an unopened road allowance bylaw passed 6 April 2022, an official plan consolidated December 2024, and two Alberta county rural living pages that publish no date. Insurer material is CMHC’s product pages and fact sheets, Sagen’s Vacation and Secondary Homes programme page, and Canada Guaranty’s Lifestyle Advantage page last updated November 2025 and its underwriting guidelines dated March 2026. All retrieved 3 November 2026. General information, not legal advice.