A general security agreement, registered in a different registry from your mortgage, and the interesting part is where the two overlap. Both provinces have a provision deciding who owns a fixture when the personal property lender and the mortgage lender both claim it, and in Ontario the fixture lender can come and take it away.
Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.
Because a mortgage charges land and a general security agreement charges everything that is not land. Two statutes, two registries, and one awkward category sitting between them.
The mortgage is registered against title. The general security agreement is registered under the Personal Property Security Act of the province, and its reach is defined by what that Act calls personal property.
Ontario’s Act says expressly where it stops. It does not apply “to the creation or assignment of an interest in real property, including a mortgage, charge or lease of real property”, and then carves two things back in: “an interest in a fixture“, and an assignment of a right to payment under a mortgage, charge or lease that does not transfer the assignor’s interest in the real property.
That first carve-out is the whole subject of this page. A fixture is the one thing both documents can reach, and the Act has a section deciding which of them wins.
The second carve-out is why an assignment of rents is a personal property registration rather than a land one, which is covered on an assignment of rents in a mortgage.
The citable fact: Ontario’s Personal Property Security Act does not apply to the creation or assignment of an interest in real property, including a mortgage, charge or lease, other than an interest in a fixture or an assignment of a right to payment that does not transfer the real property interest.
At building materials. Ontario’s definition of personal property “includes fixtures but does not include building materials that have been affixed to real property“, which is a sharper line than most borrowers assume.
So a rooftop unit bolted to the building can be a fixture and still be personal property for the Act’s purposes. The bricks and the structural steel are not. A general security agreement does not reach into the fabric of the building.
The definition of goods is wider than the word suggests and worth reading in full, because it decides what a general security agreement can capture on a commercial or agricultural property. Ontario: goods means “tangible personal property other than chattel paper, documents of title, instruments, money and investment property, and includes fixtures, growing crops, the unborn young of animals, timber to be cut, and minerals and hydrocarbons to be extracted“.
Alberta’s definition runs the same way with a different boundary on two items: it includes “fixtures, growing crops and the unborn young of animals, but does not include trees that are not crops until they are severed or minerals until they are extracted“.
Read side by side, Ontario captures timber to be cut and minerals to be extracted as goods; Alberta waits until the trees are severed and the minerals extracted. On a property with standing timber or mineral rights that is a real difference, not a drafting variation.
| Item | Ontario | Alberta |
|---|---|---|
| Fixtures | Included | Included |
| Growing crops | Included | Included |
| Unborn young of animals | Included | Included |
| Standing timber | Timber to be cut is included | Trees that are not crops are excluded until severed |
| Minerals and hydrocarbons | Included where to be extracted | Excluded until extracted |
| Building materials affixed to the land | Outside personal property altogether | Governed by the fixtures section rather than the materials |
The citable fact: Ontario’s Personal Property Security Act defines personal property to include fixtures but not building materials that have been affixed to real property, and defines goods to include timber to be cut and minerals and hydrocarbons to be extracted, which Alberta excludes until severed or extracted.
It turns on when the security interest attached, before or after the thing became a fixture. Attach before and the personal property lender wins outright. Attach after and your mortgage lender’s registered interest beats it, unless the lender consented in writing or disclaimed.
Section 34(1)(a): a security interest in goods that attached “before the goods became a fixture, has priority as to the fixture over the claim of any person who has an interest in the real property”. No qualification. The equipment financier who took security before installation outranks the mortgagee as to that item.
Section 34(1)(b) is the other case and it is where the mortgage lender is protected. A security interest that attached after the goods became a fixture “has priority as to the fixture over the claim of any person who subsequently acquired an interest in the real property, but not over any person who had a registered interest in the real property at the time the security interest in the goods attached and who has not consented in writing to the security interest or disclaimed an interest in the fixture“.
Three things in that clause deserve attention. The mortgagee must have had a registered interest at the relevant time. The protection is lost by a written consent. And it is also lost by a disclaimer of any interest in the fixture, which is the document equipment financiers routinely ask a mortgage lender to sign.
So the question to ask when a supplier wants a landlord’s or mortgagee’s waiver is what exactly is being waived. A disclaimer of an interest in the fixture converts a priority contest the mortgage lender would have won into one it loses.
The citable fact: under Ontario’s section 34(1), a security interest attaching before goods become a fixture has priority over any person with an interest in the real property, and one attaching afterwards is subordinate to a person who held a registered real property interest at that time and has not consented in writing or disclaimed an interest in the fixture.
Both can, and the condition is knowledge plus timing. Section 34(2) subordinates the fixture claim to a subsequent purchaser for value, and to a prior encumbrancer’s later advances, where made without knowledge and before notice is registered.
The provision subordinates a section 34(1) security interest to the interest of “a subsequent purchaser for value of an interest in the real property” or “a creditor with a prior encumbrance of record on the real property to the extent that the creditor makes subsequent advances“, if the purchase or the advance “is made or contracted for without knowledge of the security interest and before notice of it is registered in accordance with section 54“.
Note the phrase “to the extent that”. The mortgage lender’s protection is measured advance by advance rather than granted wholesale, which matters on a construction or draw facility where money goes out in stages. The draw mechanics are on construction draws and the holdback.
And note what triggers the loss of that protection: a notice registered in the land registry office under section 54. A personal property registration alone does not put the mortgage lender on notice; the fixture claim has to be noticed against the land.
That is the practical reason a commercial file involves a title search as well as a personal property search, and why the timing of each is recorded.
The citable fact: Ontario’s section 34(2) subordinates a fixture security interest to a subsequent purchaser for value and to a prior encumbrancer’s subsequent advances, where made without knowledge of the security interest and before notice of it is registered in the land registry office under section 54.
Yes, on default, and the compensation rule is the sting. The secured party reimburses the cost of repairing physical injury but expressly not the diminution in value caused by the fixture’s absence or by the need to replace it.
Section 34(3): where a secured party has an interest in a fixture with priority over a person interested in the real property, the secured party “may, on default and subject to the provisions of this Act respecting default, remove the fixture from the real property” if, unless otherwise agreed, it reimburses any encumbrancer or owner who is not the debtor “for the cost of repairing any physical injury but excluding diminution in the value of the real property caused by the absence of the fixture or by the necessity for replacement“.
Read that economically. A building stripped of a rooftop unit gets its roof patched, and the hole in the building’s value is somebody else’s problem. For a mortgage lender, and for an owner, that is the risk the whole priority analysis is about.
There are two procedural protections. Section 34(4): a person entitled to reimbursement “may refuse permission to remove the fixture until the secured party has given adequate security for the reimbursement”. And section 34(5) requires the secured party to serve written notice of its intention to remove on “each person who appears by the records of the proper land registry office to have an interest in the real property”, stating the secured party’s name and address, a description of the fixture sufficient to identify it, and the amount required to satisfy the obligation.
So a removal should not come as a surprise. The notice goes to everyone on title, which is exactly how a mortgage lender learns about it.
The citable fact: under Ontario’s section 34(3) a secured party with priority may remove a fixture on default, reimbursing the cost of repairing physical injury but not the diminution in the real property’s value caused by the absence of the fixture or the necessity for replacement.
Close, with three differences that matter. Alberta’s section applies only to titled land, it protects a mortgage lender’s post-fixture advances directly, and it gives a purchase-money lender a 15 day window against a registered writ.
First the jurisdictional limit. Section 36(1): “Subject to the regulations, this section applies only with respect to land for which a certificate of title has been issued under the Land Titles Act.”
Then the basic rule, drafted slightly wider than Ontario’s. Section 36(2): a security interest in goods “that attaches before or at the time the goods become fixtures has priority with respect to the goods over a claim to the goods made by a person with an interest in the land”. Ontario’s paragraph says “before”; Alberta’s says “before or at the time”.
Section 36(3) then subordinates that interest to a person acquiring an interest in the land for value after the goods become fixtures, and to “a person with a registered mortgage on the land who, after the goods become fixtures, (i) makes an advance under the mortgage, but only with respect to the advance, or (ii) obtains an order confirming sale or a vesting order in a foreclosure action without fraud and before the security interest is registered”.
Section 36(5) handles the reverse case, where the security interest attaches after the goods became fixtures. It is then subordinate to a person who had an interest in the land at that time and who has not consented, has not disclaimed, has not agreed that someone may remove the goods, and is not otherwise precluded from preventing removal. Four separate ways to lose the protection, against Ontario’s two.
Sections 36(6) and (7) add a contest Ontario’s section does not spell out. The security interest is subordinate to a creditor who registered “a writ of enforcement, judgment, order, certificate or similar instrument” in the land titles office after the goods became fixtures and before the security interest was registered. But that creditor “does not take priority over a purchase-money security interest in goods that is registered … not later than 15 days after the goods are affixed to the land”.
On removal, Alberta is firmer about conduct and the same about money. Section 36(8) requires the right of removal to be exercised “in a manner that causes no greater damage or injury to the land and to other property situated on it and that puts the occupier of the land to no greater inconvenience than is necessarily incidental to the removal”. Section 36(9) gives reimbursement for damages but, as in Ontario, “is not entitled to reimbursement for diminution in the value of the land caused by the absence of the goods removed or by the necessity of replacement”. Section 36(10) allows permission to be refused until adequate security is given, and 36(11) routes disputes to the Court.
| Question | Ontario, s. 34 | Alberta, s. 36 |
|---|---|---|
| Does the section apply to all land? | No stated limit | Only land under a certificate of title, s. 36(1) |
| Security attaching before the fixture | Priority over any real property interest | Priority where it attaches before or at the time |
| Security attaching after the fixture | Loses to a registered interest absent written consent or disclaimer | Loses on any of four grounds in s. 36(5) |
| A mortgage lender’s later advances | Protected where made without knowledge and before s. 54 notice | Protected advance by advance under s. 36(3)(b)(i) |
| A registered writ or judgment | Not addressed in the section | Beats the security interest, unless a purchase-money interest is registered within 15 days of affixing |
| Compensation on removal | Physical injury only, not diminution in value | Damages to the land interest only, not diminution in value |
The citable fact: Alberta’s section 36 applies only to land under a certificate of title, protects a registered mortgagee’s post-fixture advances advance by advance, and subordinates a fixture security interest to a registered writ unless a purchase-money security interest is registered no later than 15 days after the goods are affixed.
In Alberta, yes, and the provision is unusually practical. Section 36(4) deems an advance made in reliance on a clear search to have been made before any notice registered that same day.
The wording sets out three conditions: “a search is made of a certificate of title”, “at the time of the search there is not any notice under section 49 endorsed on that certificate of title”, and “on the day that search is made, in reliance on that search, mortgage money is advanced under a mortgage registered against that certificate of title”.
Where all three are met, “that mortgage money is deemed to have been advanced before the registration of any notice under section 49 not disclosed by that search notwithstanding that a notice was registered against that certificate of title on the day that the search was made”.
That is a solution to a genuine problem. Registrations and advances both happen during business hours, and without a rule like this the order of two events on the same day would decide priority. The provision picks the lender who searched and relied.
It also tells you what good practice looks like: search the same day you advance, and keep the search. The deeming depends on reliance on that search, so the record of it is the protection.
The corresponding Alberta registration against title is the caveat, and how those work is on a caveat on Alberta title.
The citable fact: Alberta’s subsection 36(4) deems mortgage money advanced on the day of a title search showing no section 49 notice to have been advanced before the registration of any such notice not disclosed by that search, even if one was registered the same day.
Three things: what the collateral description covers, whether you have already given a competing interest in equipment, and whether anyone is being asked to sign a disclaimer.
The collateral description. A general security agreement is usually drafted over all present and after-acquired personal property. On a commercial property that reaches further than owners expect, because of how wide the statutory definition of goods is, and because fixtures are inside it.
Existing equipment finance. If a supplier financed the rooftop units, the walk-in cooler or the production line, that lender may well hold a security interest that attached before the item became a fixture. Under both Acts, that interest can outrank the mortgage as to those items. Knowing it exists before closing is better than discovering it on a default.
Any disclaimer or consent. This is where a signature changes an outcome. In Ontario, section 34(1)(b) protection evaporates where the registered interest holder “has consented in writing to the security interest or disclaimed an interest in the fixture”. In Alberta, section 36(5) lists consent, disclaimer and an agreement allowing removal as three separate ways to lose it.
If the file also involves a holding company, an operating company and a lease between them, the structure interacts with all of this and is set out on holdco and opco commercial mortgages, and the tenant side is on lease priority and a commercial mortgage.
The citable fact: a written consent or a disclaimer of an interest in a fixture removes the protection that both Acts otherwise give to a person holding a registered real property interest at the time a later security interest attached.
A lawyer decides what is a fixture, the searches answer who registered what and when, and your broker works out whether the structure is financeable before you are committed to it.
Bring both searches to the first conversation, and a list of equipment that was financed rather than bought outright. That list is what turns this from an abstract priority discussion into a specific one.
Have a question? Chat with our team or AI assistant directly on pekoe.ca.
The citable fact: whether an item is a fixture is a legal question for a lawyer, the priority outcome depends on dated personal property and title searches, and whether a lender will advance behind an existing interest is the broker’s part.
Whether anything on your property is a fixture, what any lender’s policy is, and the two Acts’ remaining several hundred sections. This page covers one intersection and says so.
Both statutes are long and this page reads two sections of each, plus the definitions and the Ontario non-application provision. Everything else, including the rest of the priority scheme, the registration machinery and the default remedies, is outside it.
The characterisation question is the one to be most careful about. Whether a given unit, cooler, press or sign has become a fixture is decided on the facts, and both provinces’ priority rules only engage once that is settled. We have not applied the test to anything here, and we are not going to.
One further caution about currency, since it is visible on the face of our own sources. Ontario’s Act was read at a consolidation period of 1 October 2025 and Alberta’s at current as of 1 June 2024. Those are more than a year apart, so a difference between the two provinces could in principle be a difference in when each text was last consolidated rather than a difference in the law. Where a point matters, check the provision as at the date you need.
The citable fact: this page reads the fixtures and definitional provisions of Ontario’s and Alberta’s Personal Property Security Acts, read at consolidation dates of 1 October 2025 and 1 June 2024 respectively, and does not address whether any particular item is a fixture.
Because the mortgage charges land and the general security agreement charges personal property, under a different statute and a different registry. Ontario’s Act says it does not apply to an interest in real property, other than an interest in a fixture.
A fixture. Ontario’s definition of personal property includes fixtures but excludes building materials that have been affixed to real property, so each province has a section deciding who takes priority over a fixture.
If their security interest attached before the unit became a fixture, Ontario’s section 34(1)(a) gives them priority as to that fixture over any person with an interest in the real property, including your mortgage lender.
Then your mortgage lender is protected, provided it held a registered interest in the real property at that time and has not consented in writing to the security interest or disclaimed an interest in the fixture.
Yes, on default, where it has priority. Under Ontario’s section 34(3) it reimburses the cost of repairing physical injury, but expressly not the diminution in value caused by the fixture’s absence or by the need to replace it.
Yes. Section 34(5) requires notice in writing of the intention to remove, served on each person who appears on the land registry records to have an interest in the real property, with the secured party’s details, a description of the fixture and the amount owing.
Not outright, but you can hold them up. Ontario’s section 34(4) and Alberta’s section 36(10) both let a person entitled to reimbursement refuse permission until the secured party has given adequate security for it.
In Ontario, yes to the extent of advances made without knowledge of the security interest and before notice of it is registered in the land registry office. In Alberta, section 36(3)(b)(i) protects a registered mortgagee’s post-fixture advance, but only with respect to that advance.
Close, with three differences. It applies only to land under a certificate of title, it covers a security interest attaching “before or at the time” the goods become fixtures, and it lists four ways rather than two to lose the protection against a later-attaching interest.
A registered writ or judgment beats a fixture security interest registered after the goods became fixtures, but it does not beat a purchase-money security interest registered no later than 15 days after the goods are affixed to the land.
In Alberta, yes. Subsection 36(4) deems mortgage money advanced in reliance on a search showing no section 49 notice to have been advanced before any such notice not disclosed by the search, even if it was registered that same day. Keep the search.
Ask what it gives up first, and take legal advice. A written consent or a disclaimer of an interest in the fixture removes the protection both Acts otherwise give to a registered real property interest, which can reverse the priority outcome entirely.
A general security agreement is usually presented as a formality beside the mortgage. It is a separate instrument in a separate registry with its own priority rules, and the one question worth asking out loud is which of your fixtures it reaches.
Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed with RECA. Ontario’s Personal Property Security Act was read from the e-Laws API, state current, consolidation period 1 October 2025. Alberta’s Personal Property Security Act was read from the Alberta King’s Printer HTML edition, current as of 1 June 2024. Every quotation on this page is from one of those two Acts, and note that the two consolidation dates are more than a year apart. This page explains priority rules between registered interests. It is general information about how the two statutes allocate priority, not advice about your own security documents, and the characterisation of any particular item as a fixture is a question for a lawyer on the facts of your property.