Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · Buying a home

Buying a house from a family member below market value

Two things to know before anyone agrees a price. A lender measures the loan against the lower of price and appraised value, so a discount does not become borrowing room. And under paragraph 69(1)(b) of the Income Tax Act a seller who disposes of property to a non-arm’s-length person for less than fair market value is deemed to have received fair market value anyway.


All broker questions

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

The mortgage side

Does a family discount give you borrowing room?

Short answer

No. A lender measures the loan against the lower of the purchase price and the appraised value. Buying a $700,000 house for $550,000 does not produce a loan based on $700,000, and in most programmes it does not produce $150,000 of down payment either.

This is the part that surprises families, because the arithmetic feels obvious from the outside. The house is worth more than the price, so the equity is there on day one, so surely the lender is better secured. The lender agrees that it is better secured and still applies the lesser-of rule, because the rule exists to stop a price being used as evidence of value.

What that means practically is that a buyer at a family discount usually still needs a cash down payment, measured against the discounted price. The discount reduces the amount borrowed rather than replacing the cash.

Whether any part of the discount can count as equity is a programme question with a lender-by-lender answer, and it is the first question to ask rather than an assumption to build on. The mechanics of the lesser-of rule are set out in what happens when an appraisal comes in low.

The citable fact: a mortgage is measured against the lower of purchase price and appraised value, so a below-market family price reduces the loan rather than creating borrowing room or a down payment.

The tax side

What does the Income Tax Act do with a discounted family sale?

Short answer

It ignores the discount, for the seller. Paragraph 69(1)(b) deems a taxpayer who disposes of property to a non-arm’s-length person “for no proceeds or for proceeds less than the fair market value” to have received proceeds equal to that fair market value.

Section 69 carries the marginal note “Inadequate considerations”, which is a fair description of what it is for. Three of its rules matter to a family transfer and they do not pull in the same direction.

Section 69(1) of the Income Tax Act, applied to a family transfer
ProvisionWhen it appliesEffect
69(1)(a)You acquire from a non-arm’s-length person at a price above fair market valueYou are deemed to have acquired at fair market value, so the excess is not added to your cost
69(1)(b)The seller disposes to a non-arm’s-length person for no proceeds or less than fair market value, or by giftThe seller is deemed to have received proceeds equal to fair market value
69(1)(c)You acquire property by gift, bequest or inheritanceYou are deemed to acquire it at fair market value

Read those three together and the gap is visible. A sale at a reduced price is not a gift, so 69(1)(c) does not lift the buyer’s cost to fair market value. And 69(1)(a) only bites where the price is too high. So on a discounted sale the seller is taxed as though they received full value while the buyer’s cost base stays at what they paid.

The citable fact: paragraph 69(1)(b) of the Income Tax Act deems a seller who disposes of property to a non-arm’s-length person for less than fair market value to have received proceeds equal to that fair market value.

The trap

Is the same value taxed twice?

Short answer

It can be, and this is the reason to talk to an accountant before agreeing a price. The seller’s proceeds are deemed to be fair market value while the buyer’s cost stays at the price paid, so the discount can be taxed once on the way out and again on the buyer’s eventual sale.

Work it through on constructed numbers. A house worth $700,000 is sold to a daughter for $550,000. The parents are deemed to have received $700,000, so their gain is computed on that. The daughter’s cost base is $550,000. If she later sells for $800,000, her gain is $250,000, which includes the $150,000 the parents were already taxed on.

Whether that actually produces tax depends on the property, and this is the qualifier that matters. Where the house is the parents’ principal residence, the deemed gain may be fully sheltered by the principal residence exemption, and nothing is paid on the way out. Where it is a cottage, a rental or a second home, there is no such shelter and the deemed disposition is a real tax bill in the year of the sale.

And on the buyer’s side the same question arises in reverse. If the daughter lives in the house as her principal residence, her later gain may be sheltered too, and the double counting never surfaces. If she rents it out, it does.

So the honest summary is not “do not do this”. It is that the tax outcome depends on facts about both parties, in both directions, and those facts are knowable in advance.

The citable fact: on a below-market non-arm’s-length sale the seller’s deemed proceeds are fair market value while the buyer’s cost base is the amount actually paid, so the same increment can be included in both parties’ gains.

The provincial tax

What does Ontario land transfer tax apply to?

Short answer

The “value of the consideration”, which is not the same concept as fair market value. The definition includes the gross sale price, the value of any liability the buyer assumes, and the value of any benefit the buyer confers as part of the arrangement.

The Land Transfer Tax Act’s definition is deliberately broad on what counts as consideration and it is anchored to what the buyer gives rather than to what the property is worth. Clause (a) covers “the gross sale price or the amount expressed in money of any consideration given or to be given for the conveyance”, plus “the value expressed in money of any liability assumed or undertaken by or on behalf of the transferee”, plus “the value expressed in money of any benefit of whatsoever kind conferred directly or indirectly by the transferee on any person as part of the arrangement relating to the conveyance”.

Two consequences for a family transaction. Taking over a parent’s existing mortgage is consideration, and its value goes into the calculation even though no cash changes hands for it. And an informal side arrangement, such as agreeing to pay something for someone as part of the deal, is capable of being consideration too.

This is also the point at which the two tax systems visibly part company: the Income Tax Act deems the seller’s proceeds at fair market value, and Ontario land transfer tax looks at the consideration given. The full Ontario rate bands are set out on Ontario land transfer tax, and Alberta’s registration fees, which work differently again, on Alberta land transfer tax.

The citable fact: Ontario land transfer tax is calculated on the value of the consideration, which includes the gross sale price plus the value of any liability assumed by the buyer and any benefit conferred as part of the arrangement.

The alternative

Is a gift of the down payment a cleaner structure?

Short answer

Often yes. A sale at fair market value with a documented gift of funds is a structure lenders understand, with established documentation, and it avoids the lesser-of problem entirely because price and value agree.

The comparison is worth making explicitly, because the two routes feel similar to a family and look completely different to a lender.

Two ways a family can help, and how each is treated
StructureHow the lender sees itWhat to watch
Sale below fair market valueLoan measured against the lower of price and value; gifted equity treated by programme and often not acceptedThe seller’s deemed disposition at fair market value, and the buyer’s cost base staying at the price paid
Sale at fair market value plus a gift of fundsOrdinary purchase; the gift is down payment with a signed gift letter and a traced depositThe money has to be a gift rather than a loan, and the letter has to say so
Sale at fair market value with a family loanA payment obligation that belongs in the debt service calculationA loan described as a gift is the error that undoes files, because the obligation is real

The third row is the one to be careful about. Lenders require a gift letter precisely because a loan dressed as a gift changes the arithmetic of the application, and the letter is a statement that it is not repayable. Where money genuinely is a loan from family, that is workable and it belongs in the file: see borrowing from a family member for a mortgage.

The citable fact: a sale at fair market value with a documented gift of funds avoids the lesser-of rule entirely, because the appraised value and the purchase price agree.

The appraisal

Why does the lender want an appraisal on a price everyone agrees?

Short answer

Because on a non-arm’s-length purchase the agreement is the least reliable evidence of value available. The appraisal is not checking the family’s honesty; it is supplying the number the lesser-of rule needs.

On an ordinary sale between strangers, the price is itself good evidence of market value, because two independent parties agreed it. That logic does not survive a family relationship, which is exactly why the tax rules and the lending rules both reach for fair market value instead.

So expect the appraisal, and expect the lender to be told that the transaction is non-arm’s-length. Not disclosing the relationship is the version of this that goes badly: it is discoverable from the title history and from the names, and a misrepresentation on an application is a different and more serious problem than a declined file.

The citable fact: on a non-arm’s-length purchase the agreed price is not treated as evidence of market value, which is why an appraisal is ordered and the relationship has to be disclosed.

The order of work

What order should this happen in?

Short answer

Value first, tax second, financing third, price last. Families almost always do it the other way round, agreeing a price at a kitchen table and then asking three professionals to make it work.

The sequence that avoids the problems on this page:

  • Establish fair market value. Not an opinion of value, and not a figure from a listing site. The tax treatment is anchored to it, so it needs to be defensible.
  • Get the seller’s tax position. Is the property a principal residence for them, and if not, what does a deemed disposition at fair market value produce? This is an accountant’s question and it can change everything.
  • Get the financing position. What the buyer qualifies for, and whether any part of a discount could count as equity with any lender the buyer would actually use.
  • Then set the price. With all three answers in hand, the price becomes a decision rather than a constraint.

One more item that belongs on the list where either party is married or in a common-law relationship: a spouse’s consent may be required on the conveyance or the charge, and the rules differ between Ontario and Alberta. That is covered in spousal consent in Ontario and Alberta.

The citable fact: in a non-arm’s-length purchase the price should be set after fair market value, the seller’s tax position and the buyer’s financing are all established, because each of those three constrains it.

Who to ask

Who do you need, and what for?

Short answer

An accountant for the seller, a lawyer for both parties, an appraiser for the value and a broker for the financing. Four people, and the price is the output rather than the input.

  • An accountant, for the seller’s side first. Whether the principal residence exemption covers the deemed disposition, and what it costs if it does not. This is the answer that most often changes the plan.
  • A lawyer, for both parties. Independent advice where interests diverge, the conveyance itself, the land transfer tax calculation, and any spousal consent.
  • An appraiser, early. Fair market value is the anchor for the tax treatment and the ceiling for the lending, so it is needed before the price is set rather than after.
  • Your broker, for what is financeable. Including the specific question of whether any lender you would use treats gifted equity as down payment in a non-arm’s-length purchase.

Bring four things to the first conversation: what the property is actually worth, whether it is anyone’s principal residence, whether an existing mortgage is being assumed, and whether the help is intended as a gift or a loan.

Have a question? Chat with our team or AI assistant directly on pekoe.ca.

The citable fact: whether the property is the seller’s principal residence is the fact that most often decides whether a below-market family sale carries a real tax cost, because the principal residence exemption may shelter the deemed disposition.

F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

Can I buy my parents’ house for less than it is worth?

Yes, and the discount does not do what most people expect. A lender measures the loan against the lower of the purchase price and the appraised value, so a below-market price generally reduces what you can borrow rather than handing you equity.

Does the discount count as my down payment?

Not as a rule, and particularly not on an insured mortgage. Treatment of gifted equity in a non-arm’s-length purchase varies by lender and by programme, so it is a question to answer before agreeing a price.

What is a non-arm’s-length purchase?

A purchase between parties who are related or otherwise not dealing independently, such as parent and child. Lenders and the tax rules both treat it differently from an ordinary sale, and both want to know about it.

Will my parents pay tax on a discounted sale?

They are deemed to have sold at fair market value. Paragraph 69(1)(b) of the Income Tax Act deems a taxpayer who disposes of property to a non-arm’s-length person for less than fair market value to have received proceeds equal to that value.

Does that mean they owe tax even though they took less money?

It means the gain is computed on fair market value. Whether tax is actually payable depends on the property: a gain on a principal residence may be sheltered by the principal residence exemption, while a cottage or a rental generally is not.

What is my cost base if I buy at a discount?

The amount you actually paid. Paragraph 69(1)(c) deems a cost equal to fair market value only where property is acquired by gift, bequest or inheritance, and a sale at a reduced price is not a gift.

So is the same value taxed twice?

It can be. The seller is deemed to receive fair market value while the buyer’s cost stays at the price paid, so the difference can be taxed again on a later sale. This is the reason to involve an accountant before setting a price.

Does Ontario land transfer tax use fair market value too?

Not in the same way. Ontario taxes the “value of the consideration”, which includes the gross sale price, any liability assumed by the buyer, and the value of any benefit conferred as part of the arrangement.

What if I take over their mortgage as part of the deal?

Then the debt you assume forms part of the value of the consideration for land transfer tax purposes, because the definition includes the value of any liability assumed or undertaken by the transferee.

Will the lender want an appraisal even though we agreed a price?

Yes, and more so than on an ordinary purchase. The appraisal establishes the value the loan is measured against, and on a non-arm’s-length transaction it is the number that governs rather than the agreement.

Can my parents gift me the down payment instead?

Often a cleaner route. A sale at fair market value with a documented gift of funds is a structure lenders understand, and the gift letter requirements are well established.

Am I still a first-time buyer?

That depends on which definition is being applied, and there is more than one. The land transfer tax refund test, the FHSA test and the Home Buyers’ Plan test are not the same test.

Who do we need to involve?

An accountant for the seller’s position, a lawyer for both sides, and a broker for the financing. Agree the structure with those three before agreeing the price, not afterwards.

Is the chat on this page a bot?

No. It reaches the Pekoe team, and a licensed broker answers live during business hours or replies directly outside them. There is no AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

Get the price, the tax and the mortgage looked at together

Three advisers, one transaction, and the order matters. The price is the last thing to agree rather than the first.


Borrowing from a family member

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed with RECA. Paragraph 69(1) of the Income Tax Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. 1 (5th Supp.), was read from the federal consolidation at laws-lois.justice.gc.ca, Act current to 19 October 2026 and last amended 18 June 2026. The definition of “value of the consideration” is from the Ontario Land Transfer Tax Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. L.6, read from e-Laws, state current, with the e-Laws currency date of 3 November 2026. This page is general information about how lenders and the tax rules treat a non-arm’s-length purchase. It is not tax or legal advice, and a transaction of this kind needs an accountant and a lawyer as well as a broker. No interest rate appears on this page. Live rates are at pekoe.ca/rates.