Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · Renewal, refinancing and rates

Renew with your bank, or go through a broker? How to actually decide

Get both numbers, then compare the whole term rather than the rate. Your lender’s renewal offer costs nothing to keep and nothing to ask about. A broker can put the same file to a panel of lenders, but not to every lender, because some large banks do not deal with brokers at all. So the two routes do not see the same market, which is the reason to look at both instead of picking one on principle.


All broker questions

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

Which is better at renewal, your bank or a broker?

Neither, as a general rule. The comparison is the thing. A renewal decision has two candidates: stay with your current lender on whatever it will agree to, or move to a different lender. A broker is how you price the second option properly. Your own lender is the only source for the first.

That is why the useful answer is not “use a broker” or “stay with your bank”. It is get both numbers and compare them net of every cost over the whole term, because a switch has costs that a stay does not.

The citable fact: a mortgage renewal decision compares staying with the existing lender against moving to a new one, and only the existing lender can quote the first while a brokerage can quote a panel for the second.

Can a broker get you every lender’s renewal offer?

No, and anyone who says otherwise is overselling. Not every large Canadian bank distributes mortgages through brokers. Where a lender does not deal with brokers, a broker cannot quote it, and that includes the possibility of your own current lender.

This cuts both ways and it is worth being plain about. A brokerage reaches lenders you would never find alone, including credit unions, monoline lenders and private lenders. It does not reach the whole market, and your existing lender’s retention offer sits outside it by definition.

So the honest sequence is: ask your lender first, then have a broker price the alternative. Doing it the other way round works too. Doing only one of them is how people leave money on the table in both directions.

The citable fact: a mortgage brokerage can only place a file with lenders that distribute through brokers, so a broker’s panel is not the entire lender market and does not include a current lender’s own retention offer.

What each route can and cannot do for you at renewal
 Your current lenderA brokerage
Can quote a stayYes, and it is the only one that canNo
Can quote other lendersNoYes, those that deal with brokers
Reaches the whole marketNoNo
Requalifying neededUsually not for a straight renewalYes, a switch is a new application
Stress test appliesNot on a straight renewal with the same lenderYes, on a switch to a new lender
Costs to completeUsually none on a straight renewalDischarge, registration and sometimes appraisal, some of which a lender may cover
Will tell you the other option is betterRarelyShould, and ours does
Which route tends to win, by what your file looks like at renewal
Your situation at maturityTends to favourWhy
Income or credit has worsened since you last appliedStayingA straight renewal does not requalify you; a switch does
Small balance, short remaining amortisationStayingThe cost of moving is spread over too little to recover
Large balance, full term aheadWorth pricing a switchA rate difference compounds over more money and more years
You want to borrow more at the same timeNeither, it is a refinanceAdding money is a different transaction with different rules
Self-employed, or income is not a T4Worth pricing a switchLenders read the same return differently, so the panel matters
You have not asked your lender for anything yetAsk firstThe renewal letter is an opening position
Your lender will not renew you at allA brokerAlternative and private routes exist and are not advertised

Why does requalifying matter so much here?

Because a straight renewal with your existing lender does not put you through the stress test, and a switch does. That single difference decides a lot of files.

If your income has fallen, your credit has slipped, or you have become self-employed since you last applied, staying may be the only route that works, and your lender knows it. That is uncomfortable and it is the truth. It is also exactly when a broker is worth talking to early, because renewing with worse credit or income has routes that are not obvious.

If nothing has worsened, requalifying is paperwork rather than a risk, and the switch is a straight price comparison.

The citable fact: a straight renewal with the same lender does not require requalifying under the stress test, while switching to a new lender is a new application and does.

What does the comparison actually have to include?

Everything that leaves your pocket, over the full term, not the rate alone. A lower rate on a switch can lose to a higher rate on a stay once the costs of moving are counted, and it often does on a small balance or a short term.

What belongs in the comparison, with no amounts stated here because they vary by lender, by province and by file:

  • The rate and the term, on both options.
  • The payment, and whether the amortisation is being reset.
  • Discharge and registration work on a switch, and whether the new lender covers any of it.
  • An appraisal, if the new lender wants one.
  • Prepayment privileges, and the penalty method if you might break early.
  • Whether the new mortgage is readvanceable or collateral charged, which affects what it costs to leave next time.

The renewal payment shock calculator shows what a new payment does to your budget, and a worked renewal switch shows the arithmetic on a real-shaped file.

The citable fact: a renewal comparison must be made net of discharge, registration and any appraisal cost over the full term, because a lower rate on a switch can cost more in total than a higher rate on a stay.

When is staying put the right answer?

More often than a broker’s marketing suggests. Staying usually wins when the balance is small, the remaining term is short, your income or credit has worsened, the lender’s offer is genuinely competitive after you have pushed back on it, or you would lose a feature you use.

Staying usually loses when the offer is simply the first letter you were sent and you have not asked for anything better. Doing nothing at renewal is its own decision and rarely the best one.

Your lender must send you a renewal statement before maturity, and the timing rule is on its own page. Use that window rather than the last week.

Who to ask

Who should you call first, and what do you ask?

Short answer

Ask your lender what it will actually do, then ask a broker to price the alternative, and make whoever you deal with show you both numbers.

Ask your lender for a better offer explicitly. The first letter is a starting position, not a final one.

Then ask a broker to price the switch net of every cost, and to tell you if staying wins. A brokerage that will not say that is not comparing, it is selling.

Four questions that settle it.

  • What is your best offer if I stay, and what do I give up to get it?
  • What does the switch cost me at closing, and who pays each part?
  • Over the full term, which option costs less in total, and by how much?
  • Does the new mortgage change what it costs me to leave next time?

If you would rather run the lender conversation yourself, the Renewal Negotiation Playbook is a step-by-step course covering how to negotiate a renewal rate, when a switch makes sense, and what to say when the first offer arrives.

F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

Should I renew with my bank or use a broker?

Get both numbers. Only your current lender can quote a stay, and a brokerage can price a move to the lenders that deal with brokers. Compare them net of every cost over the full term rather than on the rate.

Can a broker quote every lender?

No. A brokerage can only place a file with lenders that distribute through brokers, and some large banks do not. Your own lender’s retention offer also sits outside a broker’s panel by definition.

Do I have to requalify to renew?

Not for a straight renewal with your existing lender, which is why staying can be the only workable route if your income or credit has worsened. Switching to a new lender is a new application and does require requalifying.

Does the stress test apply at renewal?

Not on a straight renewal with the same lender. It does apply when you switch lenders, because that is a new application.

What does switching lenders cost me?

Discharge and registration work, and sometimes an appraisal. Some lenders cover part of it as an incentive. The amounts vary by lender, province and file, so ask for them in writing before you decide.

Is the renewal letter my lender’s best offer?

Usually not. It is an opening position, and asking for better costs nothing. Price the alternative at the same time so you know what you are comparing it against.

When should I start?

Use the renewal window rather than the final week. Your lender must send a renewal statement before maturity, and starting early is what gives you time to requalify if you decide to switch.

Will a broker tell me to stay if staying is better?

A good one will, and ours does. If a brokerage will not show you the cost of staying alongside the cost of moving, it is not running a comparison.

What if my lender will not renew me?

That is the situation where a brokerage matters most, because alternative and private lenders are not advertised and are reached through brokers. Start early, because these files take longer.

Does adding money change the answer?

Yes, because that is a refinance rather than a renewal, with different rules and a different ceiling. Say so at the start of the conversation, because it changes which lenders are even candidates.

Get both numbers before you sign anything

The renewal letter is one of the two numbers you need. We will price the other one and tell you which wins, including when that is your current lender.


Renewal Negotiation Playbook

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Brokerage Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed by RECA. Principal broker Daniel Johanis, Mortgage Broker Licence No. M16000320, Member of Mortgage Professionals Canada (MPC), formerly CAAMP. No rate, fee, penalty or lender name appears on this page, because the cost of a discharge and whether a given lender covers it are quoted per file and per province. The Renewal Negotiation Playbook is a paid Pekoe course. Nothing here is financial advice or an offer of credit, and rates change daily.