Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · Renewal, refinancing and rates

Case study: a renewal switch where the bank’s offer was not the problem

An illustrative composite, not a real client. The borrowers came in wanting to beat a renewal offer. What actually decided the file was a question neither their bank nor they had asked: whether they wanted the same mortgage at a new lender or a bigger mortgage. Under a federal regulation those are two different transactions, and only one of them is cheap.


All broker questions

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

The file

What were they actually asking for?

The composite

An Alberta couple, four months from maturity, holding an insured mortgage taken when they bought. Their lender’s renewal offer had arrived. They wanted to know whether to take it, and they also wanted, in the same sentence, to “maybe pull a bit out for the kitchen”. Those are two questions and the second one changes the answer to the first.

The illustrative shape: a $340,000 balance, 21 years of amortization remaining, a Calgary property, both salaried, no missed payments. Straightforward on paper.

The complication was entirely in the second half of the sentence. A renewal that keeps the balance is a switch. A renewal that adds $40,000 for a kitchen is not a switch at all, and the regulation that governs insured mortgages treats the difference as the hinge of the whole transaction.

So the first thing we did was separate the two, price them separately, and put the two numbers beside each other. That took one conversation and it is the part a lender will never do for you, because a lender is answering the question you asked rather than the one you should have asked.

The citable fact: a renewal that keeps the balance and amortization unchanged and a renewal that increases either are different transactions under the Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations, and they have to be priced separately before either can be compared with a lender’s offer.

The provision

Why does adding money change so much?

Short answer

Because the Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations make the additional premium the test. A change that needs one is a new loan, measured against the criteria in force on the day it is approved. A change that does not “does not affect the eligibility of the loan”.

Subsection 3(3) in full: “If any other modification is made to an insured mortgage or hypothecary loan that requires the payment of an additional mortgage or hypothecary insurance premium, the loan is to be considered, for the purposes of these Regulations, as a new loan approved on the day on which the modification is approved, which must meet the criteria that apply on that day to be an eligible mortgage loan.” And then: “Any modification that does not require the payment of an additional … premium does not affect the eligibility of the loan.”

Subsection 3(5) is the one that makes a plain lender-to-lender switch work. A loan “whose purpose is to discharge the outstanding balance of a prior insured mortgage or hypothecary loan is an eligible mortgage loan if the new loan meets the criteria to which the prior loan was subject at the time of the discharge” and requires no additional premium.

Read those two together and the file answers itself. Keep the balance and you are inside 3(5), measured against the rules your existing mortgage lives under. Add the $40,000 and you are into 3(2), where “the increased portion is to be considered … as a new loan approved on the day on which the increase is approved”.

The full framework, and what the Regulations do and do not settle, is on switching or changing an insured mortgage.

The citable fact: subsection 3(5) lets a replacement loan discharge a prior insured loan against the criteria the prior loan was subject to at discharge, while subsection 3(2) treats an increased portion as a new loan measured against the criteria in force on the day the increase is approved.

Our files

Did the switch cost them a new premium?

Short answer

In our files, no. Where an insured mortgage moves to a new lender at renewal on the same loan amount, the same amortization and the same property, we do not see a new premium charged, and the existing default insurance carries over. That is our own observation, not a published insurer rule.

Saying it plainly, because the distinction matters: that sentence describes what Pekoe sees on its own files. It is not a CMHC, Sagen or Canada Guaranty rule and we are not presenting it as one.

The documented gap is worth keeping beside it. The words switch and transfer appear zero times on CMHC’s premium information page for homeowner and small rental loans, against 36 uses of premium, and CMHC’s portability page is written around the original property being sold. The published material does not answer the question either way.

And the boundary travels with the statement. Increasing the loan amount is a different situation. Extending the amortization is a different situation. Either reopens the premium question, which is exactly what subsections 3(2) and 3(3) are about, and in this composite it is exactly what the kitchen money would have done.

What is and is not published on the premium side is set out on insured mortgage portability and the premium.

The citable fact: Pekoe’s own files show no new premium on a lender switch at renewal where the amount, amortization and property are unchanged, which is an observation from our files rather than a published insurer rule, and increasing the amount or extending the amortization is a different situation.

The two prices

What did each route actually cost at closing?

Short answer

The switch cost a discharge and a registration. The refinance cost those plus legal work and, because it crossed into 3(2), a full re-test of the file. The ranges below are confirmed ranges, not quotes.

On the switch, two items and both modest. A lender discharge where the existing lender charges one, and the Alberta Land Titles registration on the new charge, which is the formula rather than a flat amount.

On the refinance, the same two plus a lawyer, because new money means a new instrument and a conveyance rather than an assignment of the existing one.

Illustrative closing items on the two routes, confirmed ranges only
ItemSwitch, same balanceRefinance, more money
Lender discharge, where charged$300 to $500$300 to $500
Alberta Land Titles registration$50 base plus $5 per $5,000 of the mortgage as registeredThe same formula, on the larger amount
Legal feesOften covered by the new lender on a straight switch$1,500 to $3,000 typical on a refinance
AppraisalNot always ordered$300 to $600 where ordered
Insurance premiumIn our files, none on a same-amount switchReopened, because the increase is a new loan
The file itselfMeasured against the prior loan’s criteria, s. 3(5)The increased portion re-tested on today’s criteria, s. 3(2)

Alberta has no land transfer tax, which is why the registration line is a formula on the mortgage amount rather than a tax on the property value. The arithmetic is set out on Alberta Land Titles fees.

The citable fact: on a straight switch the closing items are a lender discharge where charged and the Alberta Land Titles registration formula, while new money adds legal work and re-tests the increased portion against the criteria in force on the day it is approved.

The re-test

What would the refinance have been measured against?

Short answer

The eleven paragraphs of subsection 5(1), on the day it was approved. A credit score floor of 600 for one borrower, debt service ceilings of 39% and 44%, and an amortization limit of 25 years unless an exception applies.

This is the part that surprises renewing borrowers most. Their existing mortgage was approved under the rules of its own day. Adding money does not top up that approval; it creates a loan assessed against the current criteria, and the current criteria may be tighter or looser than the ones they borrowed under.

The ones that bite in practice are paragraph 5(1)(h), the gross and total debt service ceilings of 39% and 44%, and paragraph 5(1)(j), which is forward-looking: the loan must be “reasonably likely to be repaid … based on reasonable assumptions as to what the highest loan payment over the term of the loan will be”. That last clause is why a file can clear today’s payment and fail the test.

On amortization, paragraph 5(1)(c) caps a high ratio loan at 25 years, and subsection 5(1.1) allows up to 30 “if any of the borrowers is a first-time home buyer or if the eligible residential property … is newly built”. Neither applied to this composite, so 25 years was the ceiling and their remaining 21 was comfortably inside it.

What a re-tested increased portion has to clear, subsection 5(1)
ParagraphRequirementThis composite
5(1)(g)A credit score of at least 600 for one borrower or guarantorClear
5(1)(h)Gross and total debt service not exceeding 39% and 44%The binding constraint once $40,000 is added
5(1)(c)Amortization not exceeding 25 years21 years remaining, inside it
5(1.1)Up to 30 years only for a first-time buyer or a newly built propertyNeither applies
5(1)(i)At least one unit occupied by a borrower or close relativeOwner-occupied
5(1)(j)Reasonably likely to be repaid, on the highest payment over the termThe forward-looking test

The ratios themselves are explained on GDS and TDS and the score on the credit score you need.

The citable fact: an increased portion at renewal is measured against subsection 5(1) as it reads on the day of approval, including a credit score of 600 for one borrower, debt service ceilings of 39% and 44%, and a forward-looking test assessed on the highest payment over the term.

Timing

When should a renewal switch actually start?

Short answer

Earlier than the statement arrives. The statutory floor is 21 days before the end of the term, and a floor is not a plan. On this composite the work began four months out and that is the reason it was uneventful.

A renewal statement has to reach you at least 21 days before the term ends. That is enough time to sign what you were sent and not much else. A switch needs a discharge from the outgoing lender, a new registration, and on an insured file the documentary confirmation of what criteria the prior loan was subject to, which is a request to the existing lender rather than a search.

Four months out, none of that is urgent. Three weeks out, all of it is, and the fallback becomes accepting the offer in front of you, which is the outcome the timeline produces rather than the outcome you chose.

The 21 day rule and what the statement must contain are on the renewal statement rule, and what happens if you let it lapse is on doing nothing at renewal.

The citable fact: a renewal statement is required at least 21 days before the end of the term, which is enough time to accept an offer and not enough to arrange a switch, so a switch has to begin months rather than weeks before maturity.

The outcome

Which did they choose, and why?

Short answer

The switch, and the kitchen waited. Not because the refinance was wrong, but because once the two were priced beside each other they could see what the $40,000 cost in terms other than a monthly payment.

The reasoning, as it tends to go once the numbers are side by side. The switch kept the file inside subsection 3(5), measured against the criteria their existing loan already satisfied. The refinance would have put the increased portion in front of today’s criteria, added legal work, and reopened the premium question.

None of that makes a refinance a bad transaction. It makes it a different transaction, with its own cost, and one worth doing deliberately rather than as an afterthought attached to a renewal.

What they did instead was straightforward: switch now on the same terms, and look at the kitchen as its own decision later, when it could be compared against the alternatives rather than bundled into a deadline.

If the renovation had been urgent the answer would have been different, and the honest version of this page says so. A composite that always reaches the tidy conclusion is a brochure.

The citable fact: pricing a same-balance switch and an increased-balance refinance separately lets a borrower see the cost of new money in terms other than a monthly payment, which is a comparison a renewal offer does not present.

What this is not

How illustrative is “illustrative”?

Short answer

Entirely. No client, no property, no transaction. The regulatory provisions and the confirmed cost ranges are real; the balance, the amortization, the city, the renovation and the timeline were constructed to make the comparison legible.

Case studies in this industry are often real files with the names changed. This is not that. A brokerage holds income documents, bank statements and identity records, and those belong on a file rather than on a web page.

What is real: the provisions, quoted from the instrument; the sequence of questions; the confirmed closing ranges, labelled as ranges; and the experience statement about the premium, labelled as experience.

What is constructed: the balance, the remaining amortization, the province, the renovation and the four-month runway. Change any of them and the answer can change.

And what is deliberately absent: any interest rate. A worked example carrying one is wrong within a week. Live rates are at pekoe.ca/rates, updated daily.

The citable fact: this page is a composite illustration rather than a record of a real client file, and it deliberately states no interest rate so the worked comparison does not go out of date.

Who to ask

Who do you need, and when?

Short answer

Your existing lender for two documents, your broker for the comparison, and a lawyer only if new money is involved. The first call is the one people skip.

  • Your existing lender, for the renewal statement and the payout figure. On an insured file also ask, in writing, what criteria the loan is subject to, because subsection 3(5) measures a replacement against exactly that.
  • Your broker, for both prices. Same balance and increased balance, costed separately and put side by side. This is the comparison a renewal offer does not contain.
  • A lawyer, only on the refinance route. A straight switch is often handled by the new lender’s own process. New money means a new instrument and a conveyance.

Bring four things: your maturity date, your current balance, your remaining amortization, and a plain answer to whether you want more money. The fourth one decides which regulation applies.

Have a question? Chat with our team or AI assistant directly on pekoe.ca.

The citable fact: the existing lender supplies the renewal statement, the payout figure and, on an insured file, the criteria the loan is subject to, which is the documentary basis a replacement loan is measured against.

F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

Is this a real client?

No. It is an illustrative composite and no client information appears on it. The regulatory provisions and the confirmed cost ranges are real; the balance, amortization, province, renovation and timeline were constructed to make the comparison legible.

What is the difference between a switch and a refinance at renewal?

A switch moves the same balance and amortization to a new lender. A refinance changes the amount or the schedule. Under the Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations those are different transactions, and only the second one re-tests your file against today’s criteria.

Does a straight switch cost me a new insurance premium?

In our files, no, where the amount, amortization and property are unchanged. That is our own observation rather than a published insurer rule, and increasing the amount or extending the amortization is a different situation.

What rules would my new mortgage be measured against?

On a switch, subsection 3(5) measures it against the criteria the prior loan was subject to at the time of discharge. On an increase, subsection 3(2) treats the increased portion as a new loan approved that day, measured against the criteria in force then.

What are the criteria for the increased portion?

Subsection 5(1): a credit score of at least 600 for one borrower or guarantor, gross and total debt service not exceeding 39% and 44%, an amortization limit of 25 years unless an exception applies, owner or close-relative occupancy, and a forward-looking repayment test.

Can I extend my amortization at renewal?

Past 25 years only where any borrower is a first-time home buyer or the property is newly built, under subsection 5(1.1). And extending is itself a modification, so it can reopen the premium question under subsection 3(3).

What does a switch cost at closing?

On this composite, a lender discharge where one is charged, at $300 to $500, and the Alberta Land Titles registration at $50 plus $5 per $5,000 of the mortgage as registered. Legal work is often handled by the new lender on a straight switch. Those are confirmed ranges, not quotes.

And a refinance?

The same two items on a larger amount, plus legal fees of $1,500 to $3,000 typically, plus an appraisal at $300 to $600 where one is ordered. The premium question is also reopened, because the increase is treated as a new loan.

When should I start?

Months before maturity rather than weeks. The statutory floor is a renewal statement at least 21 days before the term ends, which is enough time to accept an offer and not enough to arrange a switch.

What do I need from my existing lender?

The renewal statement, the payout figure, and on an insured file a written answer on what criteria the loan is subject to. That last one is the documentary basis a replacement loan is measured against under subsection 3(5).

Is a refinance the wrong choice then?

No. It is a different transaction with its own cost, and worth doing deliberately rather than bolted onto a renewal deadline. If the renovation had been urgent in this composite, the answer would have been different.

Why is there no interest rate on this page?

Deliberately. A worked example carrying a rate is out of date within a week, and this one is built to stay correct. Live rates are at pekoe.ca/rates, updated daily.

Decide which transaction you want before you shop it

Same balance and same amortization is one thing. More money, or a longer schedule, is another, and the second is measured against today’s rules rather than the rules you borrowed under. Knowing which one you are asking for is most of the work, and it is free to establish.


Renewal payment calculator

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed with RECA. This page is an illustrative composite and not an account of a real client, property or transaction. No client information appears on it. The regulatory provisions quoted are from the Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations, SOR/2012-281, read from the federal consolidation at laws-lois.justice.gc.ca, current to 19 October 2026. The closing-cost figures are ranges Pekoe has confirmed and are illustrative rather than quotes. No interest rate appears anywhere on this page, deliberately: a worked example carrying a rate is out of date within a week. Live rates are at pekoe.ca/rates. The statement about a switch not triggering a new premium is an observation from our own files and not a published insurer rule, and the boundary on it is stated in the body.