Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · Offers and financing conditions

You found damage at the final walkthrough and you are closing tomorrow

This is the version of the problem with the least time and the most pressure to sign something. Holes in walls from furniture, a cracked countertop, a damaged floor, missing appliances or fixtures: individually small, collectively not, and discovered when everyone wants the deal done. The usual risk clause gives a buyer an election only on substantial damage, and moving damage rarely qualifies, which is why the realistic outcomes are a holdback, a credit, or closing and pursuing it afterwards. The thing not to do is decide at the door.


Damage before closing, by circumstance

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

Can you refuse to close over walkthrough damage?

Usually not, because the usual clause requires substantial damage and moving damage rarely is. Scuffed walls, a chipped counter and a scratched floor are not in the same category as a fire, and a buyer who refuses to close over them risks being the party in breach.

Two different complaints get confused here, and they have different answers. Damage to the property is one thing. Things that have been removed, where the agreement said they stayed, is another: that is a question about what you bought rather than about risk of loss.

And the statutory position is the same as the rest of this family: there is none. Neither of the two Ontario statutes we read allocates pre-closing risk, as set out on damage between signing and closing. Your clause governs, and your lawyer reads it.

The citable fact: damage caused by a seller vacating a property is unlikely to meet the substantial damage threshold in a standard risk clause, so it ordinarily gives a purchaser no right to refuse to complete.

Fixtures and chattels: a different complaint entirely

If something that was supposed to be included has gone, that is not damage, it is non-delivery of what you contracted for. The agreement’s list of included chattels and excluded fixtures is the document that settles it, and the remedy is usually money rather than an exit.

Two complaints that look the same at the walkthrough
 Damage to the propertySomething missing
Governed byThe risk clauseThe chattels and fixtures list
ThresholdSubstantial, or nothingWas it included? Yes or no
Typical remedyElection only if substantialAn adjustment or a claim for the value
Evidence neededDated photographs, assessmentThe agreement, and the listing if relevant
Can it stop the closing?RarelyRarely, but it is more negotiable

Check the agreement rather than your memory of the showing. A light fixture or a mirror that was there when you viewed is only yours if the agreement says so.

The citable fact: an item removed by a seller that the agreement of purchase and sale listed as included is a failure to deliver what was contracted for rather than damage to the property, so it is governed by the chattels and fixtures provisions rather than by the risk clause.

The realistic outcomes

Walkthrough damage: what actually happens
OutcomeWhat it needsThe catch
A holdbackBoth lawyers agreeing, and your lender permitting itSome lenders will not allow one, so ask before you propose it
A credit on the statement of adjustmentsThe seller agreeing a figureUsually final, so value it before accepting
Close and pursue it afterNothing, but it is a claim rather than a chequeThe cost of pursuing may exceed the damage
Delay the closingThe seller agreeing, and your rate hold survivingYour own onward sale, if you have one
Refuse to closeA substantial damage finding you probably do not haveYou risk being the party in breach

The holdback row is where your broker earns their place. A holdback changes what the lender is funding against and some will not permit one at all, so proposing a holdback your lender refuses wastes the only hours you have.

The citable fact: a closing holdback requires the lender’s permission as well as the agreement of both lawyers, because it alters the funds advanced against the security, so a purchaser should confirm the lender’s position before proposing one.

What a one-day delay actually costs

Enough that it is rarely worth it over cosmetic damage, and the biggest cost is invisible. Interest, the seller’s carrying costs, moving and storage and any per diem in the agreement all come into play, and they are specific to the deal.

And your rate hold has an expiry. A delay that pushes past it means the replacement is priced at the market when you need it, with no recourse against anyone. That cost can exceed the damage you are arguing about, which is a calculation worth doing before you dig in.

If you are selling as well as buying, a delay can stop your own sale closing, which is covered on closing day problems.

Who to ask

What should you do standing in the house?

Short answer

Photograph everything with timestamps, send it to your lawyer before you leave, and agree nothing with the seller or the agents on the spot.

Photograph and video everything, with dates. This is the one thing only you can do and only now.

Send it to your lawyer from the driveway. They decide whether this is damage, non-delivery or nothing, and what can be asked for. This page is general information and not legal advice.

Call your broker about a holdback before anyone proposes one. A holdback the lender will not allow is not an option, however reasonable it sounds.

Agree nothing at the door. Verbal reassurances and a quick signature are how buyers release claims they had not valued.

Three things to establish before you drive away.

  • What is damaged, and what is simply missing. They are different complaints.
  • What the agreement says was included.
  • Whether you have an onward sale closing on the same date.
F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

I found damage at the walkthrough. Can I refuse to close?

Usually not. The usual risk clause requires substantial damage and moving damage rarely qualifies, so refusing risks putting you in breach. Your lawyer reads your clause.

Appliances are gone. Is that the same thing?

No, and the distinction matters. Something missing that was included is non-delivery of what you contracted for, governed by the chattels and fixtures list rather than the risk clause, and the remedy is usually money.

How do I know what was included?

Read the agreement rather than relying on the showing. A fixture or mirror that was there when you viewed is only yours if the agreement says so.

Can we hold money back at closing?

Sometimes, if both lawyers agree and your lender permits it. A holdback changes what the lender funds against and not all will allow one, so confirm with your broker before proposing it.

Should I take a credit instead?

Often the practical answer, and usually final. Value the damage before accepting a figure rather than after.

Can I close and sue later?

You can, but it is a claim rather than a cheque, and the cost of pursuing it can exceed the damage. Worth a frank conversation with your lawyer about proportion.

Should I delay the closing?

Rarely over cosmetic damage. Interest, carrying costs and moving all cost money, and a delay past your rate hold expiry is a cost with no recourse against anyone.

What is the first thing to do?

Photograph and video everything with timestamps, then send it to your lawyer before you leave the property. It is the one thing only you can do and only now.

The agents want to sort it out between us. Is that fine?

Agree nothing at the door. Verbal reassurance and a quick signature are how buyers release claims they had not valued. Route it through your lawyer.

I am selling the same day. Does that change my options?

Yes, significantly. A delay on the purchase can stop your own sale closing, which puts you in breach on a second agreement. Say so to your lawyer immediately.

Photograph it, send it, agree nothing

You have hours and the pressure is to sign. The three steps that protect you take ten minutes and cost nothing.


All broker questions

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Brokerage Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed by RECA. Principal broker Daniel Johanis, Mortgage Broker Licence No. M16000320, Member of Mortgage Professionals Canada (MPC), formerly CAAMP. The Ontario statutory position is taken from the e-Laws consolidations of the Vendors and Purchasers Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. V.2, state “current”, consolidation period to 22 June 2006, and the Conveyancing and Law of Property Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. C.34, consolidation period to 1 July 2024, both read at source on 11 November 2026. We do not quote the standard-form risk clause, because forms are revised, more than one is in use and your deal may carry amendments: the clause that binds you is the one in your agreement. This page is general information, not legal advice. No rate, fee or penalty appears on this page. We are a mortgage brokerage and not a law firm.