Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · Construction and new builds

Case study: one letter from a drywall subcontractor froze $148,000 of draws

An illustrative composite, not a real client. A renovation financed in four draws, three of them advanced, and then a letter to the lender from an unpaid subcontractor. Construction Act s. 78(4)(b) removes a lender’s priority for any advance made after it “had received written notice of a lien”, so the lender stopped the same day. Nothing was registered against title for another five weeks.


All broker questions

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

The file

What was the arrangement?

Short answer

A $340,000 renovation on a house the owners already held, financed by a construction loan advancing in four draws against completed work, with a holdback retained from each advance. Three draws had gone out. The fourth, $148,000, was the one that stopped.

The draw schedule as the commitment set it out
DrawTriggerAmountStatus when the letter arrived
1Demolition and framing complete$68,000Advanced
2Roof, windows and rough-in complete$74,000Advanced
3Drywall, flooring and cabinetry complete$50,000Advanced
4Substantial completion and occupancy$148,000Not advanced
Total$340,000$192,000 advanced of $340,000

The structure was ordinary and the owners understood it. What they had not understood was the holdback, which they had read as a lender’s convenience, and the reason the lender inspected before each advance.

Three draws in, the work was visibly on schedule. The problem was not in the building; it was in the builder’s payment of the drywall subcontractor out of draw 3.

The citable fact: a construction loan advances against completed work with a holdback retained from each advance, so a borrower’s exposure is to the builder’s payment of the trades rather than only to the progress of the work.

The letter

What actually stopped the draw?

Short answer

A letter, not a registration. Construction Act s. 78(4)(b) removes a prior mortgagee’s priority for an advance made after “the person making the advance had received written notice of a lien“. The subcontractor wrote to the lender. That was enough.

The provision is worth reading in full because its two limbs are different. Section 78(4): a prior mortgage “has priority, in addition to the priority to which it is entitled under subsection (3), over the liens arising from the improvement, to the extent of any advance made in respect of that conveyance, mortgage or other agreement after the time when the first lien arose, unless, (a) at the time when the advance was made, there was a preserved or perfected lien against the premises; or (b) prior to the time when the advance was made, the person making the advance had received written notice of a lien.”

Clause (a) is about registration. Clause (b) is about knowledge, and knowledge arrives faster than registration does. On this composite the sequence was:

  • Day 0. The subcontractor’s letter reaches the lender, copied to the owners.
  • Day 0. The lender places the file on hold. Not an investigation, a hold.
  • Day 2. The owners discover that draw 3 had gone to the builder’s general account rather than to the trades for the drywall work.
  • Day 36. A claim for lien is registered against title.
  • Day 41. The builder leaves the site.

Note the gap between Day 0 and Day 36. For five weeks there was nothing on title, the owners were telling anyone who asked that there was no lien, and the lender was right to be stopped anyway. Clause (b) does not wait for a registration.

The citable fact: Construction Act s. 78(4)(b) disqualifies a later advance from priority where the lender had received written notice of a lien before making it, which operates from the date of the notice rather than from any registration against title.

The cost of the standstill

What did the five weeks cost?

Short answer

Not the lien amount, which was $41,500. The cost was everything that kept running while nothing could be funded: carrying costs on a $192,000 advanced balance, rented accommodation, and a site that stopped and had to be restarted.

What the standstill actually cost on this composite
ItemWhy it aroseAmount
The lien claim itselfUnpaid drywall subcontractor$41,500
Rented accommodation, eleven extra weeksThe house was not habitable and the draw was frozen$24,200
Legal fees to deal with the lienAdvice, correspondence, and the steps to vacate it$9,800
Remobilisation by a replacement contractorThe original builder left the site$18,600
Scope increase on re-tenderCompleting work priced by someone else, later$31,000
Total beyond the lien$83,600

Those figures are the composite’s own arithmetic rather than quotes, and the proportions are the point rather than the amounts. A $41,500 payment dispute produced $83,600 of consequential cost, because the statutory consequence of the notice was to stop the only source of funds.

The owners could not simply pay the subcontractor directly, either. Paying a subcontractor the general contractor owes raises its own questions about whether the owner is then exposed twice, and that is a conversation with a construction lawyer rather than a decision to make on a Friday afternoon.

The citable fact: the cost of a construction lien standstill is dominated by consequential carrying and remobilisation costs rather than by the lien amount, because written notice of a lien under Construction Act s. 78(4)(b) halts the advances that fund the work.

The holdback

Did the holdback help?

Short answer

It protected the lender, which is what it is for. Section 78(2) measures a building mortgage’s subordination by “any deficiency in the holdbacks required to be retained by the owner under Part IV”, so a holdback properly retained kept the lender’s charge where it was.

That is the part owners find hard to hear. The holdback is not a contingency fund for the owner and it is not a goodwill gesture; it is the mechanism by which the lender’s charge stays ahead of the liens. A lender that had released it early would have created exactly the deficiency s. 78(2) measures.

Construction Act, s. 78(2): “Where a mortgagee takes a mortgage with the intention to secure the financing of an improvement, the liens arising from the improvement have priority over that mortgage, and any mortgage taken out to repay that mortgage, to the extent of any deficiency in the holdbacks required to be retained by the owner under Part IV, irrespective of when that mortgage, or the mortgage taken out to repay it, is registered.”

Read the last clause once more: “and any mortgage taken out to repay that mortgage”. The takeout mortgage inherits the exposure, which is why the lender’s completion requirements on this file included evidence that the lien had been dealt with before the construction loan could convert.

So the holdback did its job and the owners still had a problem. Both of those are true at once, and understanding that is what changes how the next build is set up.

The citable fact: Construction Act s. 78(2) measures a building mortgage’s subordination to the liens by the deficiency in the statutory holdbacks and extends that subordination to any mortgage taken out to repay it, which is why a construction lender administers the holdback and requires lien-free evidence before converting the loan.

The resolution

How did it end?

Short answer

The lien was vacated by paying the claim into court on the lawyer’s advice, the lender resumed advances against a revised schedule with a replacement contractor, and the project completed eleven weeks late and $83,600 over budget on items that had nothing to do with construction.

The sequence that worked, and the order matters:

  • A construction lawyer, in week one. Not after the registration. The five weeks between the letter and the claim for lien were five weeks of available time that mostly went to hoping.
  • Vacating the lien rather than negotiating it. Paying the claim into court removed the lien from title and restored the lender’s ability to advance, which separated the funding problem from the payment dispute.
  • A replacement contractor and a revised draw schedule. The lender re-inspected, re-priced the remaining work with the owners, and restructured the final draw into two.
  • Statutory declarations from the new contractor at every draw. Which is what should have been happening from draw one.

What the owners would do differently is not complicated. Require a statutory declaration from the builder with every draw request that the trades for the completed work have been paid, and treat a trade’s complaint as a reason to call a lawyer rather than a reason to call the builder.

The citable fact: vacating a construction lien, rather than negotiating it first, restores a lender’s ability to advance under Construction Act s. 78(4) by removing the condition that disqualified further advances.

What we declined to say

What is not on this page, and why?

Short answer

The holdback percentage, the lien registration deadlines, and the amount required to vacate a lien. All three are set by the Construction Act and its regulations and we have not quoted them, because getting a deadline wrong on a lien page would cause the exact harm the page is trying to prevent.

That is a deliberate limit rather than an oversight. Lien timelines changed with the 2017 amendments to the Act and there are transitional rules about which version applies to which improvement. A figure stated here without that context would be read as applying to a reader’s project, and it might not.

What we have quoted is the priority machinery in s. 78, because that is what explains lender behaviour and because it is what we read. The deadlines belong in a conversation with a construction lawyer who knows when the contract was entered into.

Similarly, we have not said what any lender’s standard holdback is. That is a lender-specific figure and it should come from your commitment rather than from a case study.

The citable fact: construction lien registration deadlines and holdback requirements in Ontario are set by the Construction Act and its regulations with transitional rules tied to when the contract was entered into, which is why they should be confirmed for the specific project rather than taken from a general source.

Who to ask

Who do you need, and what should you ask?

Short answer

Your broker before the build about the draw structure and the holdback, your builder for a statutory declaration with every draw, and a construction lawyer the week a complaint arrives rather than the week a lien is registered.

  • Your broker, before the first draw. How many draws, what triggers each, what the lender retains, and what happens to the schedule if a draw is delayed.
  • Your broker, on the contingency. A standstill has carrying costs whether or not anything is being built. A project with no contingency turns a dispute into a crisis.
  • Your builder, every single draw. A statutory declaration that the trades for the completed work have been paid. A builder who resists it is giving you information.
  • A construction lawyer, on the first complaint. Written notice to the lender stops advances by operation of s. 78(4)(b), so the clock starts before anything is registered.
  • A construction lawyer, on paying a subcontractor directly. It is not obviously safe and it is not obviously unsafe. It depends, and the answer is worth getting before the payment rather than after.
  • No adviser at all, for the priority rules. They are quoted above. What needs a person is the deadlines, the holdback and the route out.

Bring three things to the broker conversation: the budget with a contingency, the builder’s name and recent references, and a schedule you believe rather than the one on the proposal.

The citable fact: because written notice to a lender halts advances under Construction Act s. 78(4)(b) before any lien is registered, the time to involve a construction lawyer is when a trade first complains rather than when a claim for lien appears on title.

F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

Is this a real client?

No. It is an illustrative composite built to show how the statutory priority rules play out. No client information appears on this page.

What stopped the draw?

A letter from an unpaid subcontractor to the lender. Section 78(4)(b) removes a lender’s priority for any advance made after it received written notice of a lien.

Was anything registered against title?

Not for five weeks. Clause (b) operates on written notice, so the lender was correctly stopped long before a claim for lien appeared on title.

Could the owners have paid the subcontractor directly?

Possibly, and it is not obviously safe. Paying a trade the general contractor owes raises its own exposure questions, which is a conversation for a construction lawyer rather than a Friday decision.

How much did the lien claim cost?

$41,500 on this composite. The consequential costs came to $83,600, which is the point of the page rather than the figures themselves.

Why were the consequential costs so high?

Because the notice stopped the only source of funds. Rented accommodation, legal fees, remobilisation and re-tendered scope all ran while nothing could be advanced.

Did the holdback protect the owners?

No, it protected the lender, which is what s. 78(2) makes it for. A holdback properly retained is what keeps the lender’s charge ahead of the liens.

Can I ask my lender to release the holdback to finish the work?

Expect a firm no. Releasing it creates the deficiency s. 78(2) measures, which is the lender’s own priority rather than a policy it can waive.

Does converting the loan clear the problem?

No. Section 78(2) extends to “any mortgage taken out to repay that mortgage”, which is why lien-free evidence was a condition of conversion here.

How was it resolved?

The lien was vacated by paying the claim into court on the lawyer’s advice, which removed it from title and restored the lender’s ability to advance, separating the funding problem from the payment dispute.

What should the owners have done from draw one?

Required a statutory declaration from the builder with every draw request that the trades for the completed work had been paid.

What are the lien registration deadlines?

Set by the Construction Act and its regulations, with transitional rules tied to when the contract was entered into. We have not quoted them here on purpose; get them for your project from a construction lawyer.

What is the standard holdback?

A lender-specific figure that belongs in your commitment rather than in a case study. The statutory requirement sits in Part IV of the Act.

When should I call a lawyer?

When a trade first complains. Written notice to the lender stops advances by operation of the statute, so the clock starts before anything is registered.

A statutory declaration with every draw is the cheapest insurance on a build

It costs the builder ten minutes and it is the evidence that keeps the draws flowing. A borrower who asks for one every time is a borrower who never has this month.


Construction liens and mortgage priority

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed with RECA. This page is an illustrative composite and not an account of a real client, property or transaction. No client information appears on it. Construction Act provisions are quoted from the Ontario e-Laws consolidation, consolidation period to 1 January 2026, currency date 4 November 2026. Every dollar figure is arithmetic on the composite’s own numbers rather than a quote. No interest rate appears anywhere on this page, deliberately: a worked example carrying a rate is out of date within a week. Live rates are at pekoe.ca/rates.