Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · Private and alternative lending

Case study: getting off a private mortgage and back to a prime lender

An illustrative composite, not a real client. A private first mortgage taken after a credit event, one year to fix the file, and an exit that came down to three things: twelve months of clean payment history, a value that left room under the 80 per cent ceiling, and income documented the way a prime lender measures it.


All broker questions

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

The file

What was actually on the table?

The composite

An Ontario household on a one-year private first mortgage, taken twelve months earlier after a layoff produced two collections and a credit score in the low 500s. Income was back, the collections were settled, and the private term was maturing. The question was whether a prime lender would now take the file.

The illustrative shape: a detached house, a private first mortgage sitting at roughly 68 per cent of value, one borrower back in salaried work for eleven months, the second self-employed throughout, and no missed payment on the private mortgage at any point in the year.

What made this a file rather than an application is that almost none of the work happened at the end. The exit was decided by three things that were either in place by month nine or were not going to be in place at all: the payment record, the documented income, and the room under the loan-to-value ceiling.

A private mortgage is a bridge over a period, not a product you grow out of automatically. Nothing about reaching maturity creates an exit, which is the part most people find out too late.

The citable fact: an exit from a private mortgage to a prime lender is determined by the payment record, the documented income and the loan-to-value position assembled during the private term, not by the private term reaching maturity.

The test

What does a prime lender require that a private lender did not?

Short answer

A private lender underwrites the property. A prime lender underwrites the borrower against criteria set out in regulation, and those criteria are published. The shift from one to the other is a shift from “is there equity” to “does the borrower meet each listed test”.

Where a mortgage is insured, the criteria live in the Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations, SOR/2012-281, made under the Protection of Residential Mortgage or Hypothecary Insurance Act. Uninsured prime lending is not governed by that instrument in the same way, but the criteria are the reference point the market works from, and they are the clearest published statement of what a prime file has to look like.

The useful thing about reading them is that they are a list. A private file is assessed on judgement about security; a prime file is assessed against items that can be ticked off one at a time, months in advance.

The published criteria, and where the illustrative file sat against each
CriterionProvisionThe illustrative file
Credit score of at least 600 for one borrower or guarantor5(1)(g)The salaried borrower was back above it by month ten. This was the binding item.
Gross debt service not exceeding 39%5(1)(h)Inside, once the self-employed income was documented properly
Total debt service not exceeding 44%5(1)(h)Inside, with the settled collections no longer carrying payments
Amortization not exceeding 25 years5(1)(c)Taken at 25 years
At least one unit occupied by a borrower or close relative5(1)(i)Owner-occupied
Reasonably likely to be repaid, on the highest payment over the term5(1)(j)The forward-looking test, which is why the documentation mattered

Note what is not on that list. There is no provision about having previously held a private mortgage, and none about a past credit event as such. What is tested is the position now.

The citable fact: the Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations set a credit score floor of 600 for at least one borrower or guarantor and debt service ceilings of 39 and 44 per cent, and they contain no criterion about having previously borrowed privately.

The ceiling

Why does the 80 per cent rule decide whether an exit is possible at all?

Short answer

Because moving off a private mortgage is a refinance, and a refinance is capped. Section 418(1) of the Bank Act restricts a residential loan, together with any mortgage with an equal or prior claim, to 80 per cent of the value of the property at the time of the loan.

The wording is worth reading, because it is expressed against value rather than against a purchase price: the restriction bites “if the amount of the loan, together with the amount then outstanding of any mortgage having an equal or prior claim against the property, would exceed 80 per cent of the value of the property at the time of the loan”.

Two consequences for an exit. The new prime mortgage has to be large enough to pay out the private mortgage in full, including any accrued interest and the lender’s own charges. And the whole of it has to fit inside 80 per cent of a value somebody else verifies.

On the illustrative file the private mortgage sat near 68 per cent of value, which left room. Where a private first mortgage has crept toward the high seventies, the arithmetic can close the exit entirely, and that is a reason to plan it early rather than a reason to despair. How value is defined and verified is set out in what happens when an appraisal comes in low, and the ceiling itself in why you can only refinance to 80 per cent.

The citable fact: subsection 418(1) of the Bank Act caps a residential loan, together with any equal or prior mortgage, at 80 per cent of the value of the property at the time of the loan, which is the ceiling every private mortgage exit has to fit inside.

The payment record

What did twelve months of payment history have to show?

Short answer

Every payment on time, on the private mortgage and on everything else. A perfect year on the mortgage beside a thirty-day late on a card is not a perfect year, because the credit report does not rank them the way the borrower does.

This is the part a borrower controls completely and the part most often spent. On the illustrative file the household kept the private mortgage current for twelve months and also, deliberately, kept two small revolving accounts open and paid in full each month. Closed accounts stop generating the record that the next lender wants to read.

There is a second-order point here that is easy to miss. A private mortgage may not report to the credit bureaus at all, which means a flawless year on it can be invisible in the score. Where that is the case the payment record has to be evidenced directly, usually with twelve months of cancelled cheques or bank statements showing the debits, and the lender has to be told to expect it. Whether a private mortgage appears on your report is covered in does a private mortgage show on your credit report.

Settled collections do not vanish from the report, and they do not need to. What changes is that they stop being open items with balances, which is what the score and the underwriter both respond to. Raising a score deliberately rather than hoping is set out in how to raise a credit score before a mortgage.

The citable fact: a private mortgage may not report to the credit bureaus, so twelve months of on-time payments on one can be invisible in a credit score and has to be evidenced directly with statements or cancelled cheques.

The income

How was the self-employed half of the income documented?

Short answer

With two years of filed returns and the notices of assessment that go with them, read together rather than separately. A private lender had not needed either. A prime lender measures income from documents it can verify at source, and a self-employed borrower is measured on what was filed.

On the illustrative file this was the item that took longest, because one return had been filed late during the year of the credit event. A late return is still a filed return, and the notice of assessment that follows it is the document that counts. What does not work is an income figure from internal records with no filing behind it.

The practical sequence on a file like this one: get both returns filed and assessed, then order the notices of assessment, then build the income on the two assessed years rather than on the better of them. Where a business is incorporated the corporate statements come in as well, and the question becomes what is drawn rather than what is earned.

The reason this is worth the effort in advance is paragraph 5(1)(j), the forward-looking test: the loan has to be reasonably likely to be repaid, assessed on the highest payment over the term. That is a test about documented capacity, and documents take weeks to assemble rather than days.

The citable fact: self-employed income on a prime file is measured from filed returns and the notices of assessment that follow them, so a late filing has to be completed and assessed before the income can be used at all.

The cash

What did it cost to move the mortgage?

Short answer

Three fees on this composite, all of them confirmed ranges rather than quotes: a discharge fee, an appraisal fee and legal fees on the refinance. None of them is financeable, so all of them are cash on closing day.

Illustrative closing costs on the exit, confirmed ranges rather than quotes
ItemConfirmed rangeWhy it arises
Discharge fee on the private mortgage$300 to $500The outgoing lender’s charge for discharging its security once it is paid out
Appraisal fee$300 to $600Ordered to establish the value the 80 per cent ceiling is measured against
Legal fees on the refinance$1,500 to $3,000Registering the new charge, paying out the old one and reporting to the new lender

Those are ranges Pekoe has confirmed, not prices for your file, and the private lender’s own exit terms sit on top of them and vary by lender. Ask for a discharge statement in writing rather than an estimate, because it is the document the lawyer actually pays from.

The planning point: these costs land on the same day and have to come from savings. A household that spends its last cash accelerating payments in month eleven can arrive at the exit qualified and unable to close, which is the same trap described in our debt consolidation case study.

The citable fact: the closing costs on a private mortgage exit are paid in cash on funding day and cannot be added to the new mortgage, so the cash has to be preserved through the final months of the private term.

The mechanics

What happens to the private lender’s charge on closing day?

Short answer

It is paid out of the new advance by the lawyer and then discharged from title. The borrower does not pay it off and then arrange a new mortgage; both sides happen in one transaction on one day.

The order on the day is: the new lender advances to the lawyer, the lawyer pays the private lender the amount on its discharge statement, the private lender provides the discharge, and the discharge is registered. The new charge is registered at the same time and takes first position.

Two things go wrong at this step often enough to plan for. A discharge statement that is out of date by a week can be short, because interest accrues daily, so the lawyer asks for it to be valid to the funding date. And a private lender that is slow to provide the discharge leaves a charge on title after the money has been paid, which is a separate problem with its own route: see what to do when a lender will not discharge.

The citable fact: on a private mortgage exit the old charge is paid out of the new advance by the lawyer on funding day, so the payout and the new registration are one transaction rather than two.

The near miss

Where did this file nearly fail?

Short answer

On timing. The private term had a maturity date and the prime application had a document list, and the two were five weeks out of step. Starting the exit at month eleven would have meant either an extension of the private term or a default.

Work the calendar backwards. Two filed returns and their notices of assessment, an appraisal booked and delivered, a discharge statement valid to funding, twelve months of statements where the private mortgage does not report, and a lender review of all of it. On the illustrative file that was eight weeks from first document to funding, and the first document was itself waiting on a tax filing.

The useful rule the file produced: begin the exit eleven months into a twelve month private term, not in the final month. If something is missing there is then time to fix it, and if nothing is missing the file simply funds early.

The alternative, extending the private term by a few months, is usually available and usually costs something. It is a reasonable outcome and a poor plan.

The citable fact: assembling a private mortgage exit took eight weeks of document work on this composite, which is why the exit is begun eleven months into a twelve month private term rather than in the final month.

The outcome

What was the result, and what was not the point?

Short answer

The file moved to a prime lender on a standard term with a 25 year amortization, inside the debt service ceilings, with the private charge discharged on the same day. The point was not the pricing improvement. It was that the household stopped renewing a one-year solution.

A private mortgage renewed a second and third time is a different situation from a private mortgage held once. Each renewal carries its own costs, and the file is no closer to a prime lender at the end of it than at the beginning unless the underlying items were fixed in the meantime.

What changed on this composite was not the house and not the equity. It was a score above the floor in paragraph 5(1)(g), two assessed years of self-employed income, and twelve months of evidenced payments. Those three things are what the next lender reads.

No interest rate appears on this page, and that is deliberate rather than coy. The saving on an exit like this is real and it is also the fastest-moving number in the whole file. Current pricing is at pekoe.ca/rates, updated daily, and a pre-approval certificate takes seconds.

The citable fact: a private mortgage exit succeeds on three assembled items, a credit score above the regulatory floor, documented income and an evidenced payment record, none of which is affected by how many times the private mortgage has been renewed.

The limits

What are the limits of this example?

Short answer

Everything constructed here is constructed: the province, the employment mix, the loan-to-value position, the timeline and the credit history. What is real is the regulatory criteria, the Bank Act ceiling, the document list and the confirmed cost ranges.

This is an illustrative composite. It is not a real client file with the details changed, and no client information appears on it. The reason to write it as a composite rather than as general guidance is that the sequencing only becomes visible when the items are put on a calendar together.

Three things that would change the answer. A private mortgage above roughly 75 per cent of value, where the 80 per cent ceiling may not leave room for payout plus costs. A credit event that is still open rather than settled. And an income that cannot be documented at source, which moves the file to an alternative lender rather than a prime one as an intermediate step.

Whether an exit is available to you is a question about your file, and it is answerable in one conversation rather than after an application.

The citable fact: this page is an illustrative composite, and the figures in it that are real are the published regulatory criteria and Pekoe’s confirmed closing-cost ranges rather than any client’s transaction.

Who to ask

Who do you need, and in what order?

Short answer

Your accountant first, your broker second, your private lender third and a lawyer last. The order matters because the accountant’s work is the long pole and everything downstream waits on it.

  • Your accountant, for the filings and the notices of assessment. Two assessed years, including any return filed late. Ask for the assessments themselves rather than a summary, because the assessment is the document a lender reads.
  • Your broker, for the position. What the current loan-to-value is against a realistic value, which lenders will look at the file, and what is missing. This is the conversation that sets the calendar.
  • Your private lender, for a discharge statement in writing. Not an estimate. Ask what it charges to discharge and whether there is any minimum interest term left to run.
  • A lawyer, once there is an approval. The payout and the new registration happen in one transaction, and the lawyer is the one who makes them land on the same day.

Bring four things to the first conversation: your private mortgage balance, its maturity date, your most recent credit report, and an honest answer about whether last year’s taxes are filed. The fourth one decides the timeline.

Have a question? Chat with our team or AI assistant directly on pekoe.ca.

The citable fact: on a private mortgage exit the tax filings are the longest item on the critical path, so the accountant is the first call rather than the lender.

F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

Is this a real client?

No. It is an illustrative composite and no client information appears on it. The regulatory criteria, the document list and the confirmed cost ranges are real; the province, the employment mix, the loan-to-value position and the timeline were constructed.

How long does it take to get off a private mortgage?

On this composite, eight weeks from the first document to funding, and the first document was waiting on a tax filing. Begin eleven months into a twelve month term so that a missing item can still be fixed.

What credit score do I need to go back to a prime lender?

The Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations set a floor of 600 for at least one borrower or guarantor, in paragraph 5(1)(g). That is a floor rather than a target, and a file sitting just above it has less room for anything else to be imperfect.

Does a private mortgage help my credit score?

Often not at all, because many private lenders do not report to the credit bureaus. Where that is the case a flawless payment year has to be evidenced directly with bank statements or cancelled cheques instead.

Can I refinance to more than 80 per cent to pay out a private mortgage?

Generally no. Subsection 418(1) of the Bank Act caps a residential loan, together with any equal or prior mortgage, at 80 per cent of value, and an insured refinance is not generally available to get past it.

Do settled collections have to be removed from my report?

No, and they usually cannot be. What matters to the score and to the underwriter is that they are settled rather than open with a balance, so the entry remains while its effect changes.

What does the exit cost?

On this composite: a discharge fee of $300 to $500, an appraisal fee of $300 to $600, and legal fees on the refinance of $1,500 to $3,000. Confirmed ranges rather than quotes, and the private lender’s own exit terms sit on top of them.

Can those costs go onto the new mortgage?

Not as a rule. They are paid on funding day from savings, which is why spending the last of the cash on extra payments in the final month of the private term is a trap.

Do I pay out the private lender myself?

No. The new lender advances to your lawyer, the lawyer pays the private lender the amount on its discharge statement, and the discharge is registered while the new charge goes on. One transaction, one day.

What if my private mortgage matures before I am ready?

An extension of a few months is usually available and usually costs something. Treat it as an acceptable outcome rather than a plan, because an extension changes nothing about the items the next lender will read.

What if a prime lender still says no?

An alternative lender is often the intermediate step rather than another private term, particularly where income is real but cannot be documented at source. The point is to move up one level rather than to renew in place.

Do I need two years of tax returns if I am self-employed?

On a prime file, expect two filed years with their notices of assessment, read together rather than with the better year chosen. A return filed late still counts once it has been assessed.

Why is there no interest rate on this page?

Deliberately. The gap between private and prime pricing is the reason people do this, and it is also the fastest-moving number in the file, so a worked example carrying either rate goes stale within a week. Live rates are at pekoe.ca/rates.

Is the chat on this page a bot?

No. It reaches the Pekoe team, and a licensed broker answers live during business hours or replies directly outside them. There is no AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

Start the exit eleven months before the private term ends

An exit from a private mortgage is built, not applied for. The work is in the payment record, the paperwork and the value, and all three take months rather than days.


Exiting a private mortgage

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed with RECA. This page is an illustrative composite and not an account of a real client, property or transaction. No client information appears on it. The regulatory provisions described are from the Eligible Mortgage Loan Regulations, SOR/2012-281, and section 418 of the Bank Act, both read from the federal consolidation at laws-lois.justice.gc.ca. Closing-cost figures are ranges Pekoe has confirmed and are illustrative rather than quotes. No interest rate appears anywhere on this page, deliberately: the gap between private and prime pricing is the reason people do this, and a worked example carrying either rate is out of date within a week. Live rates are at pekoe.ca/rates. Whether an exit is available to you depends on facts this page does not have.