Fire is the clearest case of substantial damage, which means the usual risk clause gives you a real choice rather than an argument. You can typically end the agreement and take your deposit back, or complete and take the insurance proceeds. The second option sounds better than it usually is: proceeds are what the policy pays after the deductible and the insurer’s position, not what a rebuild costs, and a lender will not advance on a burned house at all. The decision has to be made with the insurance particulars in front of you and your broker’s answer about funding.
Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.
Where the damage is substantial, the usual clause gives you that choice, and a fire is the paradigm case of substantial. The election is normally between ending the agreement with a return of the deposit, and completing the purchase and taking the insurance proceeds.
That is a contractual right, not a statutory one. Neither of the two Ontario statutes we read for this cluster allocates the risk, so the clause in your own agreement is what decides it. The statutory position is set out on damage between signing and closing.
And there is a clock. An election is not open indefinitely: you are expected to decide within a reasonable time of having the information you need to decide. Which is why the first task is getting that information rather than deliberating without it.
The citable fact: where an agreement of purchase and sale allocates pre-closing risk to the seller, a fire causing substantial damage typically gives the purchaser an election between terminating with a return of deposit and completing with the insurance proceeds, exercisable within a reasonable time.
Three reasons, and the third one ends the conversation.
| What you might expect | What you typically get |
|---|---|
| A rebuilt house | Insurance proceeds, and a construction project of your own |
| Full replacement cost | What the policy pays, after the deductible and the insurer’s assessment |
| The proceeds counted as your equity | Nothing. Proceeds are not down payment |
| Your mortgage funding as planned | A lender that will not advance on a burned property |
| The original closing date | A date that no longer works for anyone |
The lending row is the one that decides most of these. A mortgage advance requires insurance in force on the security, and no insurer binds a policy on a burned structure on normal terms. So “complete and take the proceeds” is in practice an option for a buyer who can complete without that mortgage, which is a very small group.
The citable fact: a lender will not advance mortgage funds without property insurance in force on the security, so electing to complete a purchase of a fire-damaged property is generally not available to a purchaser who requires that mortgage to close.
| Step | Why it is in this position |
|---|---|
| Tell your lawyer today | The election has a clock and only they can read your clause |
| Ask for the insurance particulars and the adjuster’s report, in writing | You cannot assess an election without them |
| Ask your broker whether the lender will still advance | If the answer is no, completing is not one of your options |
| Photograph and date everything you can safely see | Evidence degrades and gets cleared away |
| Do not sign anything the seller offers | An amendment can give away the election you have |
| Decide, with advice, inside the window | A missed election is a decision made for you |
That last row matters more than people expect. Failing to elect is not neutral: it can be treated as electing to complete, which puts you in the position of having to close on a burned house.
You are a buyer again, with a live pre-approval that may not be live for long. A rate hold has an expiry, and a file approved three months ago is re-underwritten for your next purchase anyway.
Tell your broker the day you elect, not the day you find your next house. Two things need doing: protect or replace the rate hold, and confirm nothing in your own position has changed since approval. If you are also selling, the chain matters, and that is on closing day problems.
The citable fact: a rate hold is tied to a date rather than to a purchaser, so a buyer whose purchase is terminated for substantial damage must have the hold reassessed or replaced for the next purchase rather than assuming it carries over.
Your lawyer decides whether you have an election and how long it lasts. Your broker tells you whether completing is fundable, which usually settles it.
A lawyer, the same day. Whether your clause gives an election, whether this damage is substantial, and how long you have are all legal questions on your document. This page is general information and not legal advice.
A broker, in parallel. One question: will the lender advance on this property as it now stands. The answer removes an option or confirms one, and it takes a call rather than a week.
Do not negotiate with the seller directly. An amendment signed to be helpful can cost you the election.
Three documents to gather.
Where the damage is substantial, and a fire usually is, the typical risk clause gives you an election: end the agreement and take the deposit back, or complete and take the insurance proceeds. Your own clause governs.
Contractual. Neither of the two Ontario statutes we read for this cluster allocates pre-closing risk, so the clause in your agreement decides it.
Rarely, and usually you cannot. A lender will not advance without insurance in force on the security, and no insurer binds normal coverage on a burned structure, so completing is realistically for buyers who do not need that mortgage.
Not necessarily. Proceeds are what the policy pays after the deductible and the insurer’s assessment, not the cost of rebuilding, and you would be managing the project yourself.
No. Proceeds payable for damage are not equity you contributed and a lender will not treat them as your cash.
A reasonable time after you have the information you need, which is why getting the insurance particulars is the first task rather than deliberating without them. Your lawyer reads the window off your clause.
Failing to elect is not neutral. It can be treated as electing to complete, which leaves you obliged to close on a burned house. Do not let the window pass.
Not before your lawyer reads it. An amendment signed to be helpful can give away the election you currently have.
It is tied to a date, not to you, so it must be reassessed or replaced for your next purchase. Tell your broker the day you elect rather than when you find the next house.
That is a damages question rather than part of the election, and it depends on the clause and the circumstances. Ask your lawyer rather than assuming either way.
A fire usually gives you a real choice. Whether completing is fundable usually makes the choice for you.
Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Brokerage Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed by RECA. Principal broker Daniel Johanis, Mortgage Broker Licence No. M16000320, Member of Mortgage Professionals Canada (MPC), formerly CAAMP. The Ontario statutory position is taken from the e-Laws consolidations of the Vendors and Purchasers Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. V.2, state “current”, consolidation period to 22 June 2006, and the Conveyancing and Law of Property Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. C.34, consolidation period to 1 July 2024, both read at source on 11 November 2026. We do not quote the standard-form risk clause, because forms are revised, more than one is in use and your deal may carry amendments: the clause that binds you is the one in your agreement. This page is general information, not legal advice. No rate, fee or penalty appears on this page. We are a mortgage brokerage and not a law firm.