Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · Private lending

Can one lawyer act for both the borrower and the lender?

In Ontario the starting point is no, with a closed list of exceptions. In Alberta the starting point is yes, in appropriate circumstances. And the Ontario exception everyone relies on has a trap in it: a person lending through their own RRSP is not a lending client, even where the mortgage is registered in a trust company’s name.


All broker questions

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

Ontario starts with no

What is the Ontario rule?

Short answer

A prohibition. The Law Society of Ontario’s Rules of Professional Conduct rule 3.4-12 provides that “Subject to rule 3.4-14, a lawyer or two or more lawyers practising in partnership or association must not act for or otherwise represent both lender and borrower in a mortgage or loan transaction.”

Note that it binds the firm, not just the individual. Two lawyers in the same partnership cannot split the sides between them.

Rule 3.4-14 then lists the ways out. A lawyer may act for both where the lender is a “lending client”; where the lender is selling the property to the borrower and the mortgage is part of the price; where the lawyer “practises in a remote location where there are no other lawyers that either party could conveniently retain”; where the loan is under a stated threshold; or where lender and borrower “are not at ‘arm’s length’ as defined in section 251 of the Income Tax Act (Canada)”.

So on a vendor take back, or a mortgage between family members, one lawyer is permitted. On an ordinary private mortgage between strangers it is not, unless the lender fits the definition.

The citable fact: Ontario’s rule 3.4-12 prohibits a lawyer or their firm from acting for both lender and borrower in a mortgage transaction, subject to the exceptions listed in rule 3.4-14.

The trap

Does lending through an RRSP count?

Short answer

No, and this is the point most worth knowing here. The commentary to rule 3.4-13 states that “an individual lending money through that individual’s RRSP does not qualify as a lending client even if the mortgage is registered in the name of a trust company because the funds being lent are those of the individual and not those of the trust company.”

Read the reasoning, because it generalises. What matters is “whose funds are being lent”, not whose name is on the charge.

The same commentary says that “Registering a mortgage or preparing a loan in the name of a trust company or other type of corporation or partnership that would otherwise qualify as a lending client is not, by itself, sufficient”.

And a mortgage investment corporation does not get there by being a corporation: “A mortgage investment company is not considered a finance company unless it satisfies the criteria in Rule 3.4-13.”

So a self-directed RRSP mortgage in Ontario normally needs two lawyers. If someone has told you one will do because the paperwork shows a trust company, the Law Society has addressed exactly that.

The citable fact: under Ontario’s rule 3.4-13 commentary an individual lending through their own RRSP is not a lending client even where the mortgage is registered in a trust company’s name, because the funds are the individual’s.

Who qualifies

Which lenders are lending clients?

Short answer

A defined list, and it is narrower than “a business that lends money”. Rule 3.4-13 names “a bank, trust company, insurance company, or credit union” and then a finance company meeting two tests at once.

A finance company qualifies only if its material business “involves making or refinancing loans, or entering into other similar arrangements for advancing funds or credit” and its shares or ownership interests, or those of an affiliate, “are listed on a stock exchange within or outside Canada that is a Designated Stock exchange for the purposes of the Income Tax Act (Canada)”.

That second limb is the gate. An unlisted private lender, however large, is not a lending client.

The list also includes an approved lender under the National Housing Act, a qualified mortgage lender publicly identified as such by an approved mortgage insurer, certain government and municipal bodies and their agencies, and subsidiaries publicly identified as such.

Ontario: can one lawyer act for both sides?
The lenderOne lawyer permitted?
A bank, trust company, insurance company or credit unionYes, a lending client
A publicly listed finance company whose material business is lendingYes, if both limbs of the test are met
An unlisted private lenderNo, not a lending client
A mortgage investment corporationNo, unless it satisfies the rule 3.4-13 criteria
An individual lending through their own RRSPNo, whatever name the charge is registered in
A vendor taking back a mortgage as part of the priceYes, a separate exception
A family member not at arm’s lengthYes, a separate exception

The citable fact: Ontario’s lending client definition requires a finance company to have lending as its material business and to be listed on a Designated Stock Exchange, so an unlisted private lender does not qualify.

Alberta starts with yes

Why is Alberta different?

Short answer

Because it has no separate borrower and lender rule. The Law Society of Alberta’s Code of Conduct handles it inside the general joint retainer rule, whose commentary says that “In appropriate circumstances, a lawyer may act for or otherwise represent both lender and borrower in a mortgage or loan transaction. Consent must be obtained from both clients at the outset of the retainer.”

The same commentary names the relationship as one of conflicting interests, listing “mortgagor and mortgagee” and “spouses granting a mortgage to secure a loan” among its examples.

The conditions are consent plus disclosure. Where a lawyer acts for both, they “must disclose to the borrower and the lender, before the advance or release of the mortgage or loan funds, all information that is material to the transaction”, and “The duty to disclose arises even if the lender or the borrower does not ask for the specific information.”

Alberta also records how a lender’s consent usually arrives: it “is usually confirmed in the documentation of the transaction, such as mortgage loan instructions, and the consent is generally acknowledged by a lender when the lawyer is requested by it to act.”

And the joint retainer rule itself requires the lawyer to be satisfied it “is in the best interests of each client”, and to warn both that nothing one tells the lawyer stays confidential from the other.

Ontario against Alberta on a joint retainer
 OntarioAlberta
Default positionProhibitedPermitted in appropriate circumstances
Where the rule livesIts own rules, 3.4-12 to 3.4-16Commentary to the general joint retainer rule
Is there a lender definition?Yes, the lending client test in rule 3.4-13No
ExceptionsFive, enumeratedNone enumerated; a best-interests judgement instead
Consent requiredYes, and deemed for a lending client on written instructionsYes, from both clients at the outset
Disclosure before funds moveAll material information, in writingAll material information
Firm-wide or personal?Firm-wide, including partners and associatesAddressed as a lawyer-level judgement

The citable fact: Alberta permits a lawyer to act for both lender and borrower in appropriate circumstances with consent from both at the outset, with no lending client definition and no enumerated exception list.

What you lose

What does a shared lawyer cost you?

Short answer

Confidentiality between the two of you, by design. Alberta’s rule requires the lawyer to “advise each client that no information received in connection with the matter from one client can be treated as confidential so far as any of the others are concerned”.

And it can end mid-transaction. Each client must be told that “if a conflict develops that cannot be resolved, the lawyer cannot continue to act for both or all of them and may have to withdraw completely”.

Ontario’s commentary warns in the same direction and tells lawyers to formalise it, “including making contemporaneous notes, obtaining a signed acknowledgment of the joint retainer from lender and borrower, and retaining copies of other relevant documents”.

Ontario also spells out what must be disclosed and gives a worked example: “a price escalation or ‘flip’, where a property is re-transferred or re-sold on the same day or within a short time period for a significantly higher price.”

That example tells you what the rule is really guarding against, and it is worth knowing if you are the lender.

The citable fact: on a joint retainer the lawyer must tell both clients that nothing either says is confidential from the other, and must withdraw entirely if an unresolvable conflict develops.

The institutional shortcut

Why did the bank never ask you about this?

Short answer

Because its consent is deemed. Ontario’s rule 3.4-16 provides that where a lawyer is jointly retained by a client and a lending client, “the lending client’s consent is deemed to exist upon the lawyer’s receipt of written instructions from the lending client to act”.

In that situation the lawyer need not give the lending client the usual joint retainer advice, nor obtain and confirm its consent in writing, “unless the lending client requires that its consent be reduced to writing”.

That is why an institutional mortgage feels like it has no conflict step. The step exists; the lender has simply pre-consented through its instructions.

Note the asymmetry. The borrower still gets the full advice. It is the institution’s consent that is shortened, not yours.

Ontario also sets a reporting duty the other way: where a lawyer acts for a lender on a mortgage, they “shall provide a final report on the transaction, together with the duplicate registered mortgage, to the lender within 60 days of the registration of the mortgage”.

The citable fact: Ontario deems a lending client’s consent to a joint retainer to exist on the lawyer’s receipt of written instructions to act, which is why an institutional mortgage appears to skip the conflict step.

Your file

What should you do about it?

Short answer

Ask early who is acting for whom, because on an Ontario private mortgage the answer often means two lawyers and that changes the timeline as well as the cost.

If you are lending through a self-directed RRSP in Ontario, plan on your own lawyer from the start rather than discovering the point a week before closing.

If you are the borrower on a private deal and someone offers you “the lender’s lawyer can handle it”, check which exception they say applies. There are only five.

In Alberta, you can share a lawyer more readily, but read what you are consenting to: nothing you tell that lawyer is confidential from the other side.

What we cannot do is tell you whether a specific lender fits the lending client definition. That is a legal conclusion about that lender, and it is the lawyer’s call.


Independent legal advice

The citable fact: on an Ontario private mortgage the default is two lawyers, and only five enumerated exceptions in rule 3.4-14 permit one lawyer to act for both sides.

Who to ask

Is this legal advice?

Short answer

No, and the whole subject belongs to the law societies rather than to us. Whether a particular lender meets Ontario’s lending client definition is a legal conclusion, and the lawyer asked to act for both sides is the one who has to reach it.

We are a mortgage brokerage. We can tell you early that a private file will probably need two lawyers, build that into the timeline, and introduce you to counsel. We cannot tell you whether a conflict rule is satisfied.

The citable fact: the Law Society of Ontario publishes its Rules of Professional Conduct without a single currency date, so the position here is given as read on 3 November 2026 rather than as of a published version.

More answers

Related questions

This page sits in the Ask a Broker collection, where a licensed broker answers one question per page.

F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

Can one lawyer act for both sides of a mortgage in Ontario?

Only within five listed exceptions. The default rule prohibits a lawyer, or their firm, from acting for both lender and borrower in a mortgage or loan transaction.

Does lending through my RRSP let one lawyer act?

No. The Law Society’s commentary says an individual lending through their own RRSP is not a lending client even if the mortgage is registered in a trust company’s name, because the funds are the individual’s.

Is a mortgage investment corporation a lending client?

Not automatically. The commentary says a mortgage investment company is not a finance company unless it satisfies the rule’s criteria, which include being listed on a Designated Stock Exchange.

What about a vendor take back mortgage?

That is its own exception. Where the lender is selling the property to the borrower and the mortgage is part of the purchase price, one lawyer may act.

What about a mortgage from my parents?

Also an exception, where lender and borrower are not at arm’s length as defined in section 251 of the Income Tax Act.

Is Alberta the same?

No. Alberta permits a lawyer to act for both in appropriate circumstances, with consent from both at the outset and full disclosure of material information before funds move. There is no lending client definition.

What do I give up by sharing a lawyer?

Confidentiality from the other side. The lawyer must tell both clients that nothing either of them says can be kept from the other, and must withdraw completely if an unresolvable conflict arises.

Why does my bank mortgage not involve any of this?

Because the lender’s consent is deemed to exist once the lawyer receives written instructions to act. The step is shortened for the institution, not for you.

Settle who is acting for whom before the deal is firm

On an Ontario private mortgage the answer is usually two lawyers, and finding that out late costs time you may not have.


See live rates

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed with RECA. The Law Society of Ontario Rules of Professional Conduct publish no single currency date; rule 3.4-13 and its commentary carry an amendment note of September 2026, and the rules were read on 3 November 2026. The Law Society of Alberta Code of Conduct was read at version 2026_V1 dated 1 September 2026. Law society rules change. General information, not legal advice.