Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · After closing

The seller knew and did not tell you

This is the route homeowners reach for first and it is the hardest of the six, because you have to prove what was in someone else’s head. The distinction that decides it is between a defect you could have found on a reasonable inspection and one you could not, and only the second kind generally gives you anything. Your agreement of purchase and sale matters as much as the defect, because a representation in it is far easier to run on than silence. And the clock started before you noticed, which is the part to deal with this week rather than next year.


Problems found after closing, by circumstance

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

The distinction

What separates a defect you can claim for from one you cannot?

Short answer

Whether a reasonable inspection would have found it. A patent defect is one visible or discoverable on an ordinary examination of the property, and a buyer is generally taken to have accepted it. A latent defect is one that such an examination would not reveal, and that is the category where a claim against a seller usually has to live.

That is why the first question a lawyer asks is not how bad the problem is. It is where it was, and whether anyone looking properly would have seen it.

A crack in a visible foundation wall and the same crack behind finished basement framing are the same defect in two different legal positions. So are a sloping floor you walked on and a failed sump pump inside a sealed cavity.

Where the rule comes from matters for how it is argued: a seller’s position on a resale home is governed by your agreement of purchase and sale and by the doctrine the courts apply to latent defects, rather than by a disclosure code written into a statute. Your lawyer applies it to your facts.

Where a defect sat, and what that usually means
Where it wasLikely categoryEffect on a claim
Visible on a walkthrough or in plain viewPatentGenerally accepted by the buyer
Findable by a home inspector doing a normal inspectionPatentGenerally accepted, whether or not you had one done
Concealed behind finishes, or buriedLatentThe category a claim usually needs
Actively hidden, painted over or boxed in before listingLatent, with concealmentThe strongest version of this claim
Covered by a written representation in the agreementContractual, whichever it wasUsually the easiest route to run

The citable fact: a buyer is generally taken to have accepted a patent defect, meaning one discoverable on a reasonable examination of the property, so a claim against a seller for a resale home normally depends on the defect being latent or on a written representation in the agreement of purchase and sale.

The agreement

Why does the agreement of purchase and sale matter more than the defect?

Short answer

Because a written promise is far easier to prove than a state of mind. If the agreement said the roof was free of leaks, or that the seller knew of no outstanding work orders, and that was untrue, your claim is about a document rather than about what the seller privately knew. Pull the agreement out before you do anything else.

So the useful first hour is spent reading, not inspecting. Look for representations and warranties about the property’s condition, about systems, about compliance with by-laws and about outstanding orders.

Two clauses cut the other way and you should know whether they are in yours. An entire-agreement clause can limit what you may rely on outside the document. A clause by which you accept the property in its present condition narrows what you can complain about afterwards.

Where a representation was made and the agreement also says you take the property as it stands, those two have to be read together, which is squarely a lawyer’s work rather than something to resolve from a web page.

The citable fact: a written representation in an agreement of purchase and sale about a property’s condition is provable from the document itself, so it is generally an easier basis for a post-closing claim than establishing what a seller knew and concealed.

The clock

How long do you have, and when did it start?

Short answer

Two years from discovery in both provinces, and in Ontario you are presumed to have discovered it earlier than you did. Limitations Act, 2002 s. 4 bars a proceeding after the second anniversary of discovery, and s. 5(2) presumes you knew on the day the act or omission took place unless the contrary is proved. Alberta’s Limitations Act s. 3(1) gives two years from discovery or ten years from when the claim arose, whichever expires first.

The presumption is the practical problem on a seller claim, because the act or omission is usually the sale itself. You are therefore arguing backwards from a presumed start date at closing.

What rebuts it is evidence of when you actually found out and why you could not reasonably have known sooner. An invoice, a contractor’s report, a dated photograph or an email are worth more than a recollection.

So do this today rather than at the point of instructing a lawyer: write down the date and the circumstances of the discovery, and put the supporting documents in one place. The fuller discussion of the clock is on the post-closing problems parent page.

The citable fact: on a claim against a seller the Ontario presumption in Limitations Act, 2002 s. 5(2) runs from the act or omission, which is usually the sale itself, so the buyer carries the burden of proving a later discovery date.

Is it worth it

Is pursuing the seller actually worth doing?

Short answer

Sometimes, and it depends on three things that have nothing to do with how unfair it feels: the size of the loss, whether the seller can pay, and whether a cheaper route exists. Check your title insurance and any warranty programme first, because those respond without a lawsuit.

A seller who has spent the proceeds on their next home is not a promising defendant, however clear the claim. That is worth establishing early rather than after costs have been incurred.

Work the cheaper routes first:

  • An owner title insurance policy, where the problem is a covered title matter rather than a physical defect.
  • A new home warranty programme, where the home is new enough to be covered.
  • Your property insurer, where the loss could be read as sudden and accidental.
  • The lawyer who acted for you, where a search or an advice step was missed.
Routes compared, before you pursue the seller
RouteNeeds a proceeding?Turns on
An owner title insurance policyNoThe policy wording, and whether the matter is a title one
A new home warranty programmeNoThe home’s age and the programme’s coverage periods
Your property insurerNoWhether the loss reads as sudden and accidental
The lawyer who acted for youUsually not at firstWhether a search or advice step fell below the standard
The sellerUsually yesLatent defect or a written representation, plus their ability to pay

Where the amount is modest, small claims court exists in both provinces and the monetary limit is set by regulation rather than by the Act, so ask your lawyer what the current limit is before assuming the route is open or closed.

The citable fact: title insurance and new home warranty programmes respond on their own terms without requiring a proceeding, so both should be checked before a claim against a seller is pursued.

Who to ask

Who to ask, and in what order

Short answer

A real estate litigation lawyer first, with the agreement and your discovery record in hand. Your purchase lawyer for the complete file. A broker only if the defect has to be resolved before you next refinance or sell.

  • A real estate litigation lawyer: whether the defect is latent, what the agreement promised, and your real deadline.
  • The lawyer who acted on your purchase: the full file, including searches and the reporting letter.
  • A qualified inspector or engineer: a written report on what the defect is and when it likely arose, which is evidence rather than opinion.
  • A licensed mortgage broker: whether a lender would need it resolved before a refinance, a switch or a sale.

This page is general information and not legal advice. Whether a particular defect is latent, and what your agreement actually did, are questions about your own documents and your own facts.

The citable fact: a written report from a qualified inspector or engineer on the nature of a defect and when it likely arose supports both the latent-defect question and the discovery date, which are the two issues a seller claim turns on.

F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

The seller must have known about this. Can I make them pay?

Possibly, and it is the hardest of the available routes because it turns on what you can prove they knew. It is much easier where the agreement of purchase and sale contained a written representation that turned out to be untrue.

What is the difference between a latent and a patent defect?

A patent defect is discoverable on a reasonable examination of the property, and a buyer is generally taken to have accepted it. A latent defect is one such an examination would not reveal, and that is normally the category a claim needs.

I did not have a home inspection. Does that hurt me?

It can, because the test is what a reasonable examination would have found rather than what your examination did find. Not inspecting does not turn a patent defect into a latent one.

What should I look for in my agreement?

Representations and warranties about condition, systems, compliance with by-laws and outstanding orders. Also look for an entire-agreement clause and any clause by which you accepted the property in its present condition.

How long do I have?

Two years from discovery in both provinces. Ontario adds a 15 year outer limit; Alberta gives two years from discovery or ten years from when the claim arose, whichever expires first.

Why would the clock have started before I knew?

Because Ontario’s s. 5(2) presumes you knew on the day the act or omission took place, which on a seller claim is usually the sale. Rebutting that presumption is your job, so evidence of when you found out matters.

Is there a cheaper route than suing?

Check an owner title insurance policy, a new home warranty programme, your property insurer, and whether your own lawyer missed something. All four respond without a proceeding.

What if the seller has no money?

Then the claim may be worth little whatever its merits, which is worth establishing before you incur costs rather than afterwards.

Can I use small claims court?

For a modest amount, possibly. The monetary limit is set by regulation and changes, so ask your lawyer what it currently is rather than relying on a figure you read somewhere.

Is Pekoe’s chat a real person or an AI bot?

A real licensed broker during business hours. Outside them you leave a question and a broker replies directly, rather than an AI persona answering as though it were an advisor.

Get the agreement and the clock looked at together

What your agreement said and when your limitation period started are the two things that decide whether this route is open.


All broker questions

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Brokerage Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed by RECA. Principal broker Daniel Johanis, Mortgage Broker Licence No. M16000320, Member of Mortgage Professionals Canada (MPC), formerly CAAMP. The stress test and the tiered minimum down payment are the federal rules and are stated as such. This page is general information, not legal advice, and whether your defect is latent, and what your agreement actually promised, are questions for a real estate litigation lawyer on your own documents. No rate, fee, penalty or lender name appears on this page. We are a mortgage brokerage and not a law firm.