Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · After closing

You closed, then found a problem: your routes and the clock on each

Start with the part that worries people most: a defect discovered after closing does not put your mortgage at risk. A mortgage obliges you to pay and to maintain the security, and a problem you inherited breaches neither. Where a defect does reach your financing is later, at a refinance, a switch at renewal or a resale. What needs acting on now is the clock, because every route to recovering money has a limitation period, and in Ontario the law presumes you knew about the problem on the day the act or omission happened unless you prove otherwise.


All broker questions

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

First question

Does a problem found after closing affect your mortgage?

Short answer

Not the mortgage you already hold. Your obligations are to pay and to keep the security insured and in repair, and inheriting a defect breaches neither of those. No lender can call a mortgage because you discovered something about the property after you took title.

Where it does reach your financing is at the next moment a lender has to form a view of the property. That is a refinance, a switch to a different lender at renewal, or a sale.

At those points an appraiser or a lawyer may see what you have discovered, and the property may support less than it did, or need the problem resolved before anyone will advance against it. That is a real consequence and it is a later one, which is why the sequence below starts with the clock rather than with the lender.

A straight renewal with your existing lender is the exception, because it is a continuation rather than a new application and generally involves no fresh view of the property at all.

The citable fact: a defect discovered after closing does not breach a borrower’s obligation to pay or to maintain the security, so it does not put an existing mortgage into default, and it reaches financing only at a refinance, a lender switch or a sale.

The routes

Who might actually owe you something?

Short answer

Six possibilities, and they are not alternatives you choose between so much as a list to work through. The seller, a builder or warranty programme, your title insurer, the provincial assurance fund, your own lawyer, and your property insurer. Which of them is live depends on what the problem is and on what you bought at closing.

Most homeowners in this position think only of the seller, which is the hardest of the six and often not the best one. A title insurance policy, if you bought an owner policy, responds without anyone having to be sued.

Routes after a post-closing discovery, and what each one turns on
RouteLive whenWhat it turns on
The sellerThe defect was latent and they knew, or they made a representationWhat you can prove they knew, and the limitation clock
A builder or new home warrantyThe home is new enough to be coveredThe programme’s own coverage periods and claim deadlines
Your title insurerYou bought an owner policy and the problem is a covered title matterThe policy wording, not the seller’s conduct
The provincial assurance fundA registration under the land titles system caused the lossThe statutory conditions, and it is usually a last resort
Your own lawyerA search, a condition or an advice step was missedProfessional negligence, with its own clock
Your property insurerThe loss is sudden and accidental rather than pre-existingThe policy, and most will exclude a pre-existing defect

Two of those are covered in depth already on this site. Alberta’s assurance fund against title insurance sets out how the fund and a policy interact, and title fraud in Ontario covers the case where a registration was fraudulent.

The citable fact: a title insurance owner policy responds on its own terms rather than on proof of the seller’s conduct, so where a covered title defect is discovered after closing the policy is generally a faster route than a claim against the seller.

The clock

How long do you actually have?

Short answer

Two years from discovery in both provinces, and an outer limit that differs. Ontario’s Limitations Act, 2002 s. 4 bars a proceeding after the second anniversary of the day the claim was discovered, with an ultimate limit of 15 years from the act or omission under s. 15(2). Alberta’s Limitations Act s. 3(1) gives two years from discovery or 10 years after the claim arose, whichever expires first.

The Ontario provision that catches people is not the two years. It is s. 5(2), which presumes a person knew of the matters giving rise to the claim on the day the act or omission took place, unless the contrary is proved. So the burden of showing you only found out later is yours.

Section 5(1) sets out what “discovered” means, and it is a four-part test: you knew the loss had occurred, that it was caused by an act or omission, that the act or omission was that of the person you are claiming against, and that a proceeding would be an appropriate means to remedy it. The clock also runs from when a reasonable person in your circumstances ought to have known those things, whichever is earlier.

Alberta frames the consequence differently, and the difference matters. Under s. 3(1) the defendant, on pleading the Act as a defence, “is entitled to immunity from liability in respect of the claim”. The claim is not erased; the defence is absolute once pleaded.

Limitation periods on a post-closing claim, Ontario and Alberta
OntarioAlberta
From discovery2 years, Limitations Act, 2002 s. 42 years, Limitations Act s. 3(1)(a)
Outer limit15 years from the act or omission, s. 15(2)10 years after the claim arose, s. 3(1)(b)
Which appliesThe ultimate period overrides even an unexpired one, s. 15(1)Whichever of the two expires first
Presumption of knowledgePresumed known on the day of the act or omission, s. 5(2)Knew, or ought to have known, under s. 3(1)(a)
Effect of expiryA proceeding shall not be commencedDefendant is entitled to immunity on pleading the Act

None of which tells you your own deadline, because that depends on facts only a lawyer reviewing your file can establish. What it tells you is that waiting to see whether the problem gets worse is the one strategy with a cost attached.

The citable fact: Ontario’s Limitations Act, 2002 s. 4 bars a proceeding after the second anniversary of discovery and s. 5(2) presumes the claimant knew on the day the act or omission took place unless the contrary is proved, while Alberta’s Limitations Act s. 3(1) gives two years from discovery or ten years from when the claim arose, whichever expires first, read from the e-Laws consolidation for the period ending 4 December 2024, e-Laws currency date 9 November 2026, and the Alberta Act current as of 15 December 2022, retrieved 12 November 2026.

By circumstance

Which situation are you in?

Short answer

The route and the clock both change with the circumstance, and so does whether this is a legal problem, an insurance problem or a financing one. Each of these is answered in full on its own page.

Post-closing discoveries, and what each one turns on
CircumstanceWhat it turns on
The seller knew and did not tell youWhether the defect was latent, and what you can prove they knew
You have title insurance and want to use itThe policy wording, and whether you bought an owner policy at all
Your own lawyer missed somethingWhether a search or an advice step fell below the standard
You only found out years laterThe outer limitation period, and the presumption of knowledge
It surfaced when you tried to refinance or sellWhat the lender or buyer now needs resolved, and who pays

Where the problem is a specific kind of defect already covered here, go straight to it: open permits and unpermitted work, municipal work orders, a buried oil tank, legal non-conforming use, or a survey or boundary problem.

The citable fact: the available route after a post-closing discovery is determined by the nature of the defect rather than by its cost, so a title matter, a construction defect and a municipal order are pursued against different parties under different deadlines.

Who to ask

Who to ask, and in what order

Short answer

A real estate litigation lawyer first, and quickly, because the clock is the only thing here that cannot be recovered once lost. Your title insurer in the same week if you hold an owner policy. A broker only when you know whether the problem has to be fixed before you next need financing.

  • A real estate litigation lawyer: which routes are live, what your deadline actually is, and what evidence to preserve now.
  • Your title insurer: report it promptly, in writing, and keep the acknowledgement. A policy usually requires prompt notice.
  • The lawyer who acted on your purchase: for the file, the searches and the reporting letter. Ask for the whole file, not a summary.
  • A licensed mortgage broker: whether the problem affects a refinance, a renewal switch or a sale, and what a lender would need resolved.
  • Your property insurer: where the loss could be read as sudden and accidental rather than pre-existing.

One practical step before any of that: write down the date you found out and how, and keep anything that supports it. Where the law presumes you knew earlier, that record is what you are rebutting the presumption with.

This page is general information and not legal advice, and limitation periods are unforgiving in a way most legal questions are not. Speak to a lawyer about your own facts rather than relying on the periods described here.

The citable fact: because Ontario’s Limitations Act, 2002 s. 5(2) presumes knowledge from the day of the act or omission, a homeowner’s contemporaneous record of when and how a defect was discovered is the evidence that rebuts that presumption.

F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

I found a problem after closing. Can my lender do anything about it?

No. Your obligations are to pay and to keep the security insured and in repair, and inheriting a defect breaches neither. It reaches your financing only at a refinance, a switch to another lender, or a sale.

How long do I have to do something?

Two years from discovery in both provinces. Ontario adds an ultimate limit of 15 years from the act or omission; Alberta gives two years from discovery or ten years from when the claim arose, whichever expires first.

What does “discovered” mean?

In Ontario, s. 5(1) requires that you knew the loss occurred, that it was caused by an act or omission, whose act or omission it was, and that a proceeding would be an appropriate remedy. It also runs from when a reasonable person ought to have known.

Is the clock really presumed to start at closing?

In Ontario, s. 5(2) presumes you knew on the day the act or omission took place unless the contrary is proved. So showing that you found out later is your job, which is why a record of when and how you found out matters.

Who do I claim against?

Work through six: the seller, a builder or warranty programme, your title insurer, the provincial assurance fund, your own lawyer, and your property insurer. Which are live depends on the defect and on what you bought at closing.

Is suing the seller the main route?

It is the one people think of first and often the hardest. If you bought an owner title insurance policy and the problem is a covered title matter, the policy responds on its own terms rather than on proof of what the seller knew.

Will my home insurance cover it?

Usually not, because most policies respond to sudden and accidental loss rather than to a pre-existing defect. It is still worth reporting, because the answer depends on the policy and on how the loss arose.

Can I just wait and see if it gets worse?

That is the one approach with a guaranteed cost, because every route has a deadline and some of them run from a date already in the past.

What should I do today?

Write down the date you found out and how, keep anything supporting it, ask your purchase lawyer for the complete file, and book a real estate litigation lawyer.

Is Pekoe’s chat a real person or an AI bot?

A real licensed broker during business hours. Outside them you leave a question and a broker replies directly, rather than an AI persona answering as though it were an advisor.

Find out whether this reaches your financing at all

Most post-closing defects are a legal question with a financing footnote. One conversation tells you which part is ours and which part is your lawyer’s.


All broker questions

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Brokerage Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed by RECA. Principal broker Daniel Johanis, Mortgage Broker Licence No. M16000320, Member of Mortgage Professionals Canada (MPC), formerly CAAMP. The stress test and the tiered minimum down payment are the federal rules and are stated as such. This page is general information, not legal advice, and every route below is a legal claim with its own limitation period, and only a lawyer acting for you can advise on yours. No rate, fee, penalty or lender name appears on this page. We are a mortgage brokerage and not a law firm.