Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · After closing

The problem surfaced when you tried to refinance or sell

Many post-closing defects are discovered not by the owner but by the next professional who looks, and that is usually an appraiser, a lender’s lawyer or a buyer’s lawyer. Finding out this way is inconvenient and it is also useful, because it tells you precisely what has to be resolved and for whom. The immediate question is narrower than it feels: your existing mortgage is unaffected, and what is blocked is the new transaction. And if you are selling, the awkward part is that the latent defect analysis now runs against you.


Problems found after closing, by circumstance

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

What is actually blocked

Does this put your existing mortgage at risk?

Short answer

No. The mortgage you hold is unaffected, because your obligations are to pay and to maintain the security and you have breached neither. What is blocked is the new thing: the refinance, the switch to another lender, or the sale. That distinction is worth holding on to, because it means you have time.

It also means the fallback is usually available. A straight renewal with your existing lender on the same terms and balance is a continuation rather than a new application, so it generally involves no new appraisal and no fresh view of the property at all.

So where a defect has just blocked a switch to a better rate, the realistic choice is often to renew where you are, resolve the defect, and shop at the following maturity. That costs you the rate difference rather than the home.

The citable fact: a defect discovered during a refinance or a lender switch does not affect the existing mortgage, and a straight renewal with the current lender generally proceeds without a new appraisal, so the practical loss is pricing rather than financing.

What the lender needs

What will a lender actually want before it advances?

Short answer

One of four things, and which one depends on the defect rather than on the lender’s mood. Proof it is resolved, a holdback until it is, a smaller loan against a reduced value, or an acceptance that the matter is insured. Ask which of those is being asked for, because people often assume the hardest one is the only one.

What a lender asks for, by the kind of defect
DefectUsual requirementWhere it is covered here
An open permit or unpermitted workThe permit closed, or a holdback until it isOpen permits and unpermitted work
A municipal work orderCompliance, or evidence the order is satisfiedMunicipal work orders
A title defect or undisclosed registrationTitle cleared, or insured overMaking a title insurance claim
A boundary or survey discrepancyA current survey, or title insurance coverageSurvey or title insurance
A structural or environmental problemA report, remediation, and often a reduced valueA buried oil tank
A zoning or use problemConfirmation of legal non-conforming statusLegal non-conforming use

Two points that save time. “Insured over” is a real answer on title matters and it is frequently faster than clearing the defect, which is one reason the title policy question comes up early. And a holdback keeps the transaction alive while the work is done, rather than ending it.

Lenders also differ in appetite, which is the other reason not to treat the first answer as final. A defect that one lender will not look at may be ordinary to another, and that is squarely a broker’s work. Where mainstream lenders decline, being declined by an A or B lender sets out what comes next.

The citable fact: a lender confronted with a title defect may accept the matter being insured over rather than cleared, which is generally faster than remediation and is one reason to establish early whether an owner title insurance policy exists.

The appraisal

What if the appraisal came back lower because of it?

Short answer

Then the loan is sized against the reduced value, and your options are to fund the gap, to borrow less, or to resolve the defect and have the property reappraised. An appraisal can also come back “subject to” completion of specific work, which is a conditional value rather than a refusal.

A subject-to appraisal is the most workable of those four and the one most often misread as a decline. It is the appraiser saying the value exists once the work is done, which is exactly what a holdback is designed for.

Appraisal outcomes on a flagged property, and what each one allows
OutcomeWhat it meansWhat it allows
Value confirmed, defect noted onlyThe defect does not affect value materiallyProceed, possibly with an undertaking
Value subject to completion of workA conditional value, not a refusalA holdback until the work is done
Value reducedThe defect is priced inA smaller loan, or fund the gap
Appraiser declines to valueThe condition prevents a reliable opinionRemediation first, or an alternative lender

Where the value is genuinely lower, the arithmetic is the same as on any shortfall. Our page on an appraisal below the purchase price sets out the mechanics, and they apply to a refinance as much as to a purchase.

One caution about reappraising. Doing the work and asking for a new appraisal costs time and a second appraisal fee, and it is worth doing only where the value gap is larger than the cost of the work. That is a calculation to run before instructing a contractor, not after.

The citable fact: an appraisal issued subject to completion of specified work states a conditional value rather than refusing one, so it can usually be paired with a lender holdback to keep a refinance or a purchase alive.

If you are selling

Now that you know about it, do you have to tell a buyer?

Short answer

This is the uncomfortable turn in this circumstance and it needs your lawyer rather than a web page. The analysis that would have helped you against your own seller now runs against you: a defect a buyer could not find on a reasonable inspection is a latent defect, and you now know about it. Get advice before the property is listed, not after an offer.

The practical consequences are worth thinking about in advance because they shape the decision to sell at all.

  • Resolving the defect first removes the question entirely and usually protects the price. Where it is affordable, it is the cleanest route.
  • Disclosing it is a decision to take with your lawyer, and the wording of any disclosure is their work rather than your agent’s.
  • Pricing it in is common and does not by itself answer the disclosure question.
  • Saying nothing about a latent defect you know of is the position that creates the risk, which is set out from the buyer’s side on the seller who knew and did not tell you.

Note that your own claim against the person who sold it to you, if one survives, does not disappear because you sell. It also does not transfer to your buyer. Those are both questions for your lawyer, and they are worth asking in the same conversation.

This page is general information and not legal advice, and what you must disclose when selling a property you know to be defective is precisely the question to put to your own lawyer before listing.

The citable fact: an owner who discovers a latent defect becomes, on a subsequent sale, a seller with knowledge of it, so the disclosure question should be settled with a lawyer before the property is listed rather than after an offer is received.

Who to ask

Who to ask, and in what order

Short answer

Your broker first in this circumstance, which is the exception in this family, because the immediate question is what a lender needs and whether another lender needs less. A lawyer before you list if you are selling. A litigation lawyer separately, because the clock on recovering the cost is still running.

  • A licensed mortgage broker: exactly what the lender is asking for, whether a holdback works, and whether another lender treats it differently.
  • A real estate lawyer: before listing, on disclosure, and on whether the defect can be insured over.
  • A real estate litigation lawyer: on recovering the cost from whoever is responsible, because that clock runs independently of your transaction.
  • A contractor or engineer: a written scope and cost, which is what a holdback is sized from.

Where the cost of resolving it is the obstacle, remember that the routes on the parent page are about who pays for it, and that pursuing them does not have to wait for the transaction to finish.

The citable fact: because a defect blocking a refinance or a sale and a claim to recover its cost run on separate tracks, the transaction requirement and the limitation period should be dealt with in parallel rather than sequentially.

F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

A defect turned up during my refinance. Is my mortgage at risk?

No. Your existing mortgage is unaffected. What is blocked is the new transaction, which means you have time to deal with it properly.

What is my fallback if the refinance or switch fails?

A straight renewal with your existing lender, which is a continuation rather than a new application and generally involves no new appraisal. You lose the rate difference, not the home.

What will the lender want?

Usually one of four things: proof the defect is resolved, a holdback until it is, a smaller loan against a reduced value, or acceptance that the matter is insured. Ask which one is being asked for.

What does “insured over” mean?

That a title insurer accepts the risk of the defect so the lender does not have to wait for it to be cleared. On title matters it is frequently faster than remediation.

Would another lender see it differently?

Often, yes. Appetite for a flagged property varies considerably, which is why a first decline is not a final answer and is squarely a broker’s work.

The appraisal came back lower. What now?

Fund the gap, borrow less, or resolve the defect and reappraise. Check first whether the appraisal is “subject to” completion of work, which is a conditional value rather than a refusal and pairs with a holdback.

Is it worth doing the work to get a higher value?

Only where the value gap exceeds the cost of the work plus a second appraisal fee. Run that calculation before instructing a contractor.

I want to sell instead. Do I have to tell the buyer?

Ask your lawyer before listing. The latent defect analysis that would have helped you against your own seller now runs against you, because you know about the problem.

Does selling end my claim against the person who sold it to me?

Not automatically, and it does not transfer to your buyer either. Both are questions for your lawyer, worth asking in the same conversation as the disclosure question.

Is Pekoe’s chat a real person or an AI bot?

A real licensed broker during business hours. Outside them you leave a question and a broker replies directly, rather than an AI persona answering as though it were an advisor.

Find out what the lender actually needs resolved

A defect that blocks one lender does not always block another, and the fix is often smaller than the first answer suggests.


All broker questions

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Brokerage Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed by RECA. Principal broker Daniel Johanis, Mortgage Broker Licence No. M16000320, Member of Mortgage Professionals Canada (MPC), formerly CAAMP. The stress test and the tiered minimum down payment are the federal rules and are stated as such. This page is general information, not legal advice, and if you are selling, what you must disclose about a defect you now know of is a question for your own lawyer before the property is listed. No rate, fee, penalty or lender name appears on this page. We are a mortgage brokerage and not a law firm.