Pekoe Mortgages
Pekoe Mortgages · Ask a Broker · Offers and financing conditions

The house was damaged between signing and closing: what you can do turns on how bad it is

There is no Ontario statute that allocates this risk. It is decided by a clause in your own agreement, and the usual shape of that clause gives you an election only where the damage is substantial. Substantial damage typically lets a buyer either end the deal and take the deposit back, or complete and take the insurance proceeds. Damage that is not substantial usually gives no right to delay and no right to a price reduction. And underneath all of that sits a second problem nobody raises with you: your lender will not advance on a property it now considers different from the one it approved.


All broker questions

Chat connects you to the Pekoe team during business hours. Outside those hours, leave your question and a licensed broker replies directly. No AI persona pretending to be an advisor.

Who carries the risk before closing?

Your agreement does, not a statute. We checked the two Ontario statutes that deal with the implied terms of a land sale contract and with conveyancing, and neither allocates the risk of damage before completion.

The Vendors and Purchasers Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. V.2, state current with a consolidation period to 22 June 2006, contains no provision about risk, destruction, damage or loss. Its single reference to insurance is in the implied terms about adjustments, where “taxes, local improvement rates, insurance premiums, rents and interest, shall be adjusted as at the date of closing”.

The Conveyancing and Law of Property Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. C.34, consolidated to 1 July 2024, contains no reference to risk, destruction or insurance either. Its six references to damage are about waste by tenants and life tenants, profits recovered after eviction, and damages for a falsified pedigree, none of which is a risk-of-loss rule.

So the rule is contractual, and the document that governs is yours. That is not a dodge: it is the most important practical consequence on this page, because it means the answer is in a clause you can read today rather than in a statute you cannot change.

The citable fact: in the two Ontario statutes we read, the Vendors and Purchasers Act and the Conveyancing and Law of Property Act, there is no provision allocating the risk of damage to a property between the signing of an agreement of purchase and sale and completion, so the allocation is contractual.

Substantial or not: the distinction that decides everything

The usual shape of the clause in a standard Ontario agreement gives the buyer an election, and only where the damage is substantial.

What the usual risk clause gives you, by severity
SeverityWhat a buyer typically getsWhat a buyer typically does not get
Substantial damageAn election: end the agreement and take the deposit back, or complete and take the insurance proceedsA guaranteed payout amount, or a rebuilt house
Not substantialGenerally nothing. The deal proceedsAn extension, or a reduction in the price
Either caseThe insurance particulars, and a reasonable chance to assessUnlimited time to decide

“Substantial” is not defined by a number and that is deliberate. It is judged on the facts, which is why two buyers with similar-looking damage can get different answers and why this is a question for your lawyer rather than a calculation.

We are not going to quote your clause to you. Standard forms are revised, there is more than one form in use, and your deal may carry amendments. This page describes the usual shape and tells you to read your own clause, which is the only one that binds anyone.

The citable fact: where a standard Ontario agreement of purchase and sale allocates pre-closing risk to the seller, the buyer’s remedy on substantial damage is typically an election between terminating with a return of deposit and completing with the insurance proceeds, and not a right to a guaranteed payment or a repaired property.

Which circumstance is yours?

Each of these is answered in full on its own page, because the evidence you need and the lending consequence differ.

Damage before closing, by what happened
What happenedThe distinctive problemRead
FireUsually substantial, so the election is live and the clock is shortThe house burned before closing
Water or floodOften argued to be not substantial, and the hidden damage questionWater damage before closing
Damage found at the walkthroughHours, not days, and often caused by the seller moving outDamage found at the final walkthrough
The property is in a flood risk areaA pre-purchase question about insurabilityFlood risk and your mortgage
Damage after you already own itYour insurance, and your lender’s interest in the proceedsInsurance proceeds and your mortgage

The half nobody raises with you: your lender

Even where you have a right to complete, your lender has to be willing to advance, and a damaged property is not the property it approved.

Insurance has to be in force. A lender will not advance without a binder, and an insurer looking at an open claim or an unrepaired loss may not write the policy you need on the day you need it.

The appraised value may no longer hold. If the lender revalues, you can find yourself with the appraisal gap problem on top of the damage, which is covered on appraisal below the purchase price.

And insurance proceeds are not down payment. Proceeds payable for damage are not your equity and a lender will not treat them as cash you brought. Who they are paid to, and on what conditions, is part of the negotiation.

The citable fact: a lender will not advance mortgage funds without property insurance in force, so damage that prevents an insurer from binding coverage prevents completion regardless of the purchaser’s contractual right to complete.

Who to ask

What should you do in the first twenty-four hours?

Short answer

Tell your lawyer today, ask the seller for the insurance particulars in writing, and tell your broker before you decide anything, because the lender’s position shapes your options.

A lawyer, immediately, because the election has a clock. Whether your damage is substantial, whether your clause gives you an election, and how long you have to make it are legal questions on your document. This page is general information and not legal advice.

Ask for the insurance particulars in writing. You cannot assess an election without knowing what is covered, what the deductible is and what the insurer has said.

Tell your broker before you choose. If the lender will not fund a damaged property, completing is not actually one of your options, and finding that out after you elect to complete is the worst sequence available.

Four things to do today.

  • Photograph and date everything, from every angle, before anyone touches it.
  • Get the clause from your agreement in front of your lawyer.
  • Request the insurance particulars and any adjuster’s report, in writing.
  • Ask your broker what the lender needs to still advance, and by when.
F.A.Q.

Frequently asked questions

Who is responsible if the house is damaged before closing?

Your agreement decides. In the two Ontario statutes we read, the Vendors and Purchasers Act and the Conveyancing and Law of Property Act, there is no provision allocating that risk, so the allocation is contractual and the clause in your own agreement governs.

Can I walk away?

Typically only where the damage is substantial, and then as an election: end the agreement and take the deposit back, or complete and take the insurance proceeds. Where the damage is not substantial there is usually no right to end it.

Can I get the price reduced instead?

Usually not. The typical clause gives an election rather than an abatement, so a buyer with non-substantial damage generally has no right to a reduction or to an extension.

What counts as substantial?

It is not defined by a number. It is judged on the facts, which is why similar-looking damage can produce different answers and why it is a question for your lawyer rather than a calculation.

Am I entitled to see the insurance details?

You need them to assess an election at all, so ask for the particulars and any adjuster’s report in writing. What you cannot demand is a guaranteed payout figure.

Will the insurance money rebuild the house?

Not necessarily, and that is the trap in electing to complete. Proceeds are what the policy pays, subject to the deductible and the insurer’s position, not what a rebuild costs.

Can I use the insurance proceeds as my down payment?

No. Proceeds payable for damage are not equity you brought and a lender will not treat them as your cash. Who they are paid to and on what conditions is part of the negotiation.

Will my lender still fund it?

Not automatically. A lender will not advance without insurance in force, and an insurer looking at an open claim may not bind coverage on the day you need it. Tell your broker before you decide anything.

Could the appraisal change?

Yes. If the lender revalues a damaged property you can end up with an appraisal gap on top of the damage, which is a cash problem at closing.

What should I do first?

Photograph and date everything before anyone touches it, then get your clause in front of your lawyer the same day. Evidence and the clause decide this, in that order.

Read the clause, get the insurance particulars, ask the lender

Three steps, all available today, and they settle whether you have an election and whether completing is genuinely open to you.


All broker questions

Pekoe Financial Inc. o/a Pekoe Mortgages is a licensed mortgage brokerage. Ontario: FSRA Brokerage Licence #13321. Alberta: licensed by RECA. Principal broker Daniel Johanis, Mortgage Broker Licence No. M16000320, Member of Mortgage Professionals Canada (MPC), formerly CAAMP. The Ontario statutory position is taken from the e-Laws consolidations of the Vendors and Purchasers Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. V.2, state “current”, consolidation period to 22 June 2006, and the Conveyancing and Law of Property Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. C.34, consolidation period to 1 July 2024, both read at source on 11 November 2026. We do not quote the standard-form risk clause, because forms are revised, more than one is in use and your deal may carry amendments: the clause that binds you is the one in your agreement. This page is general information, not legal advice. No rate, fee or penalty appears on this page. We are a mortgage brokerage and not a law firm.